Building Walls

Anderson,

are you illiterate?

Do you understand that the govt. was unable to show that the wall had to be built on disputed land for security purposes?

Do you understand you can't grab something from someone else, if you don't own it?

Do you understand that it was obvious in this case that the wall was built where it was built not for security (as it could have been built further back), but as an irrititant? as a bully tactic? The ISC had said so and the Israeli govt. has said it will respect the decision - so they aren't disputing it either.

The only one left disputing the decision is you.
 
TQM said:
are you illiterate?

Do you understand that the govt. was unable to show that the wall had to be built on disputed land for security purposes?

Do you understand you can't grab something from someone else, if you don't own it?

Do you understand that it was obvious in this case that the wall was built where it was built not for security (as it could have been built further back), but as an irrititant? as a bully tactic? The ISC had said so and the Israeli govt. has said it will respect the decision - so they aren't disputing it either.

The only one left disputing the decision is you.

I understand the decision very well. I also understand that behind the scenes there are reasons for moves, court decisions and yes covert concepts exist.Just ask DQ about that.

Bullying the people who murder your children ? OMG.
 
DonQuixote said:
Yes. They've been outlawed but they still
exist on Palestinian lands depriving them
of their orchards, etc.

That issue is even more important than the wall.


Hmmm, orchards vs little Jewish babies having their heads blown off on a bus.
 
DonQuixote said:
Your opinion about religion is your choice.

Our 1st Amendment protects that practice.

Communists held the same view of religion as yours.
They weren't very successful in their Atheist views,
were they? I suggest you look at religion is being
part and parcel of a society and culture. Who are
we to say whether religion has any value. I do know
this, you can't find a culture that is void of such
an existential view of reality.


I do not care who wants to be religious-their choice for sure and I support it. I just stop supporting the claim that a suicide bomber states that Allah told him to .Thats the line of where I stop my support. I also do not accept Baruchs claim for the same shit before someone points that out
 
My view is that

Israel has already pretty much agreed that some 90% of the settlements will have to go (this is pretty much what Barak and Arafat had been negotiating on), and as such, Israel should immediately dismantle all settlements that they know and admit to as being illegal.

They started a unilateral process of dismantling settlements, and I very much approve of this - particularly since it was unilateral action (something both sides need to do more of). This process became derailed because of the sheer intense stupidity of both Hamas and Hezbollah, leading up to last year's war in Lebanon.

It needs to get back on track. It needs to pick up the pace.

If there are, say, 10% of settlements that are truly "disputed", it should go to an arbitration process, with both sides needing to show flexibility. The amount of land we are talking about is very very small. There's no sense in letting peas get in the way of lasting peace.
 
See , that is where you are mistaken-at your most basic premise .

Lasting peace cannot be until 1 side states that they have a right to exist.

Arbitration between 2 sides when 1 side cannot agree because they are divided is a concept that cannot be. Can you make an agreement with a dictator and when said dictator is overthrown the new guy states ''null and void.

Quite interesting though how you grasp this with Castro, but cannot with Arafat , or the new Arafat, or the next Arafat.
 
Lasting peace is easy.

It requires an embrace.

It's happening in Ireland, a place where it seemed equally improbable. It wasn't all that long ago that they said peace was impossible until the IRA did this and that and until the Unionists did this and that.

The same is true here.

Economically, Israel needs a viable Palestinian trading partner. Palestine needs a economically strong Israel.

I've been clear that both sides need to take unilateral actions. Both sides already have started this process. It may not be apparent to you, but it is to me.

Lasting peace isn't that far off.

But now is the time to redouble all efforts. Now is the time to remove all impediments to peace. No preconditions are needed. The rhetoric needs to go. Both Olmert and Abbas seem to realize this. The shtick needs to go (your position is basically shtick).
 
Everything you state is correct with one attachment. You make peace with the people who are currently vowing to destroy you in Arabic and promote Arafats ''peace by piece'' concept.
So you deal with Hamas then Fatah says no or the other way around.

Peace is easy for you becuase your risk is zero. Me , well I have 2 children there and the wiggle room is nil.

If you are wrong , you start another thread-not so easy for those with Israeli children.
 
Heard it all before,

peace is impossible because the other side does this and that..... and they say this and that....... and it means they somehow will be able to wipe us out (with their homemade rockets????)

I've heard it all before.
 
DonQuixote said:
Dare we be even handed about this?

There have been more little Palestinian babies having their
heads blown/shot off than Israelis. Or, in the alternative,
their lives don't count because they're Arabs.

How about a balanced approach for a change.


If Syria, Egypt, Jorden, Lebanon, attacked Israel today the result of this war would last 6 hours. Israel could if they desire destroy all these countries within hours. Israel does not use the force that they posess and they go in weakly due to their weak leaders as we saw in Lebanon. The Israelis want peace and do not kill Palestinian babies more than Americans wish to kill Iraqui babies. The Arabs fight with their babies in front of them, hiding weapons in schools etc. Still a few do die while the Arabs target babies.
 
Andy,

As you point out Israel could destroy all these nations very quickly (that's your stated view).

This flies in the face with your other claim that somehow, Palestinian nationhood would threaten Israel. Israel could wipe out such a state just as quickly.
 
Firstly, I like the nickname Andy way better than idiot or little man !

See, steps like this does improve moods.

Israel obviously could and no doubt our trusted inside guy Dq will agree with me.Jane intelligence would probably state the same.

Palestinian nationhood would hurt Israel the least because they can fight nations, a fifth column is a problem.

I am in agreement with a Palestinian state, just not the right of return of 4+ million ''Palestinians'' with voting rights who then vote Hatikva out, the Israeli flag replaced by the PLO flag and expulsion of Jews.

Thats my problem.
 
right of return.

Get the states going then get mediation. There are legitimate cases for "right of return" to be the only morally acceptable solution. There are illegitimate cases too.

An issue facing many art galleries these days is when they find out that the painting they paid millions for, was once looted by the Nazis. Most recently this happened with some famous Klimt's.

Wrongs, regardless of how old, still have to be righted. The paintings went back to the relatives of the owners who were looted (and are now dead). In these cases, another solution would have been for the government to buy back the paintings (the families want to sell them and become rich...).

It's one way of correcting the wrong while keeping the paintings in the museum.

My only point is small - all problems have peaceful solutions.
 
dq,

You've, again, entirely missed the point.

Everyone knows there'll be a two state solution. The question is the stickin point of "right of return". Palestinians, with some merit, argue that many should have the right to return to Israel as citizens (and in some cases get their property back).

The two state solution does not address this issue.
 
TQM , I feel like Henry Higgins !

I think you got it !

The Arabs in Israel vote, The Palestinians my friend DQ want to return to Tel Aviv because that is where the fifth column works best. When There is a Palestinian state, the 4 million ( yeah , right ) will be forced to go to Haifa, Tel Aviv , and West Jerusalem to cause havok. This is the problem . I assure you the Palestinians would have a state today if they dropped the right of return for millions to go to Tel Aviv.

So, you were in ME intel , eh ?
 
I just lost a long post when terb logged me out so I'll make it shorter.

Don, some Palestinians have reason to attack and continue to deny Israel because of their upbringing in a dogma of hatred and the worry about how they are viewed on the Arab street. The educated are able to differentiate the propaganda that they were brought up with from path to bettering the being of the Palestinian people. Not all are educated or want the ability to think logically. Add to that the power plays. Hamas and Islamic Jihad will lose a considerable amount of their sway if Fatah/PLO are able to negotiate a peace with Israel and better the conditions of Palestinians lives. They will attack Israel in the hopes of killing Israelis and sparking a retaliation from Israel that will unite the people under their militants.
 
The right of return is a big issue because the Arab leaders of the past and some Palestinian leaders of today want it to be a big issue. For the rest of us, the solution was figured out long ago. Limited repatriation to those who were actual refugees (ie. from 1948) who want to live in Israel and are willing to accept Israeli law and funding to pay for resettlement of the rest in Palestine or in their host countries. In any other situation, the Arab states would have assimilated refugees in the same way that Israel assimilated a similar number of Jewish refugees from Arab states (in a much smaller population) and the same way that Canada assimilates refugees that come here. Another large number of the refugees were from '67 and (they and their descendants) have absolutely no claim to living in Israel. Many generations of Palestinians have been born in other countries but are forced to remain Palestinians because their host countries will allow anything else.

Why do many of the Palestinians not want to accept limited repatriation and Israeli funding of resettlement as a "just solution?" It is simply a matter of power. Groups such as Hamas have their power base among those who are the most disadvantaged and if they see anyone else improve their lives, Hamas would be largely finished.
 
Religion and culture.

This is one of the things that I find interesting about Israel. Israel is a Jewish state but for many of the Jews there, this has nothing to do with religion itself and has everything to do with culture. The Jewish culture is ties to religion for the simple reason that the religion was forcibly dispersed. Now that there is a Jewish home, many Israelis feel that they can be Jewish without having anything to do with religion. For them, Israel is Jewish in the same way that Canada (and the (US) is Christian. Basically, we get Christmas and Easter off work and they get Yom Kippor and Passover. The religious groups have a disproportionate influence in their government (as some say the born agains have in the US) simply because the multi-party political system and the need for coalitions. To add, much of their support comes from the settlements which will take a big hit after a peace deal.

On an interesting level regarding right of return and settlements, Hebron is a strange situation. There are currently several illegal outposts of Jews in Hebron (which the Israelis are no longer paying to keep safe). What makes Hebron interesting is that (beyond being the second holiest site for Jews) there has been a continual Jewish presence there for somewhere in the neighborhood of 1000 years (at least) until they were forced out in pre-partition arab riots and subsequent to the partition. The same can be said for the old quarter of Jerusalem which had a long established Jewish quarter until the Jordanians forced them out in '48.

The Palestinians want control over Islam's second holiest site and the right for dependents of people who once lived in Israel to go there. Why shouldn't the same apply to the Jews (except Israel knows this will be detrimental to peace).
 
DonQuixote said:
What reason would the Palestinians have to attack
Israel after they get their own state?

The restrictions/denial of their autonomy is what's
driving their anger. Your view of the Palestinians
is similar to the Unionists in N Ireland with the
Irish. My understanding is that N Ireland is at
peace and the economy is humming.

Why would it be any different in Israel & Palestine.
The Palestinians are suffering 5x as many casualties
as the Israelis. Its in both peoples best interest
to reach an accord.

Your knowledge of very very basic ME concepts is a joke. It is akin to talking to someone in grade 5 about the Palestinian issue who lives in Columbia. You claim to have been in intel in the ME , yet your lack of basic knowledge remains a joke.

I am not talking opinions because 3 Jews usually have 4 opinions on the ME and that is evident by the postings of Jews on this board. They represent most of the Jewish sides which are all over the map including the left, centre right and more radical ones like me who by the way did 3 years in the military over there.This does not mean that I am right about all my views.


The Palestinians have never missed an opportunity to miss an opportunity. They are pawns to the Arab states, always have been. They have held certain Arab states hostage over the years too to achieve their political means.They have also been used by the USA as you are aware re Pollard and the level playing field and the reason Pollard rots in our jails in the USA and will die there.They are also used by the PLO, Hamas, all the fringe radicals and yes by the Israelis as well, yet they are no angels.

And your beautiful idea of give a state and happiness flows. Well, pre 67 what was the ''occupied territories ?

Jordon is Palestine -does anyone remember TransJorden ? What the fuck was that ?