Building Walls

TQM

Guest
Feb 1, 2006
2,651
0
0
Once again, the Israeli Supreme Court has shown us the value in having a true democracy as your means of government.

The building of a wall separating the Palestinian Territories from Israel was done in the name of security. And no one denies a nation's right to defend itself.

The issue has been that the lands on which some of the wall has been built are disputed by the Palestinians, in some cases for obvious reasons. The wall was building defacto new boundaries between the territories and the state.

Palestinians have wisely taken the matter to the Israeli courts on now several occasions, and on each, they've come out the victor. Basically the court agrees that Israel has a right to build a protective fence. But it doesn't have a right to build that fence just anywhere.

It's hard to disagree with this decision. And now,politically, Israelis are going to have to come to terms with the realization that all would be better off if such decisions weren't finding themselves in the courts, but were instead, the result of political smarts.

Here's the latest news:

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20581935/
 
Another example of weak Israelis who think that Jewish blood spilled is ok.

I have respect for Palestinians who shout clearly their goals and I hold weak Israelis in contempt who play to world opinion instead of caring about Jewish lives
 
Idiot.

Palestinians took the action to Israeli courts. That is a perfectly legitimate route to take. The courts have steadfastly pointed out the land the wall is built on is in some places disputed, and as such, illegitimate. And in each and every such case, the government failed to show that a wall in a more appropriate space put anything at further risk.

As such it was evident to all except you that the wall was put up as a land grab, masked by the alleged security issue.

I applaud the courageous court decision.
 
Well, it really is not evident to all but me.

The Palestinians did well, I applaud them .My hatred is for the weak Israeli left.

As for land grabs, the Arabs have 21.5 countries and we have half of one and its still too much land.

Anyway, no time to argue today,

Be well,


Supreme courts err as well.
 
Show me one false sentence

in their ruling. Just one false, contentious sentence! I can't stand the fact that you are so predisposed to a position that when the truck smacks into you, you still get up and say "damn those shooting stars!"

No court is always right. But to assume it must be wrong simply because it means admitting Palestinians were wronged is asinine.
 
We both know that court decisions are not always correct. I would not even read this because I could not care less about what these wacko left wingers who sit on the supreme court there state. They are always ruling against the government vis a vis the Arabs and Palestinians because of their bias against the right wingers .

Your only example will be to read about Kahane and how they allow Arabs and not Jews in their own Knesset.

My basic premise is for Israel to exist and if it does/does not might have no meaning on this board and only a future thread and happiness to Lansclad as he has stated in the past.

To me , Israel is important and to allow the Palestinians to have the majority and vote the country out of existance is not my end game.

It is not about land and we both know that.
 
That was the response from

outer space. Cue twilight zone theme.

Anyone want to guess who appointed the judges to the Israeli Supreme Court?
 
TQM.....you are not wrong, but consider this. Would the Palestianian authority have a court that runs on democratic principles for the Israeli's to take the Authority to court for all the terrorist inflicted costs the State of Israel has had forced upon them through the Infifada? Of course not......

The Authority may have won a courtbattle, but hell will freeze over before that wall comes down.....because it WORKS. Now if the PA wants to get control over their own territory and people and govern in a responsible manner, Iam sure Israel will pay compensation for the land that the wall is sitting on.....
 
First,

it wasn't the Authority which won the court battle. And second, the wall has to move.

Again, no one is disputing that a wall can stop incursions. The question has always been where that wall is built.
 
Bearlythere said:
...The Authority may have won a courtbattle, but hell will freeze over before that wall comes down.....because it WORKS......
Funny, didn't the late great USSR say the same about their 'wall' in Berlin?
Seem to recall JFK and Ronnie Reagan, to mention a few, weren't too happy about that wall in Berlin either.
But what the hey, it works for you, eh?.....:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Israel NEEDS to keep to it's morals, including the weakness of democracy if it is to survive. The Palestinians have support because they are seen as poor are disadvantaged. Israel needs to respond by showing that it is a democracy and is willing to follow the rule of law. They need to show the world that it's minority population has full legal rights. Even the "unbiased" Jimmy Carter has stated that Israel propper is an inclusive democracy. The demographic issue is a long term issue though and (with the removal of the West Bank and Gaza), it will be a significant number of years before there is demographic equality (around 80 years at current rates). Israel will never allow significant numbers of "refugees" entry and even if they did allow the actual 1948 refugees in, that would only take 10 or so years off the demographics.

In terms of the moral high ground, there was an interesting article in Haeretz about the settlement blocks. The basic premise was that the settlers made a choice on their own and it shouldn't be up to Israel to evacuate them from their homes insaide the eventual Palestine. One of the outcomes would be that Palestine would have to deal with having Jews living as a part of their country and their stance on human rights would be wide open for al to see.

Israel needs to work to allow a reasonable peace that gives the Palestinians a choice to agree and work with peace or show the world that they are unwilling to compromise. Once Israel gets some real peace, then they will have some issues to work out in terms of the the role of religion in government, both Jewish and Muslim.

Otherwise, Isreal sullies it's reputation by events like this recent massive attacks on a Palestinian refugee camp that killed hundreds and left the camp destroyed, acts that the world will refuse to go without comment. Oh right, that was the Lebanese Army destroying the camp, going against agreements with the PLO. Of course the media that has been going willd with criticism about this....... sound of crickets and tumbleweed....... I guess not.


On another note, rockets still are being fired every day from the "peaceful" Gaza that Hamas has enforced. I actually find it disgusting the lack of humanity that these terrorists have. Take the rocket that hit a day care a couple days ago in a city that hasn't seen a day of peace in over a year. The response from those launching the rocket that hit a place filled with young children? "It's a present for the start of the new school year!"
 
TQM said:
outer space. Cue twilight zone theme.

Anyone want to guess who appointed the judges to the Israeli Supreme Court?

Supreme courts make political decisions and sometimes get overturned when the balances in the courts are changed.
Roe vs Wade ring a bell ?
What did the courts say on the ''hanging chads '' in Florida ? I liked the decision but bet you don't.

I know the balance on the bench in Israel , do you ?

It is funny though that you can see a way for peace in the ME , and right and wrong yet you ( and me too ) sometimes cannot even exist on this board.

You call out idiots, little men etc etc yet think peace is so easy with 5000 years of history and killings in that region ( yet only 1300 years or so for Muslims, and 2000 for Christians)

No, no country on Earth would be expected to allow people to vote themselves out of existence except the Jews. You do not believe in the concept of Israel and Pakistan ( founded on religion) yet you have no answer to where Jews should live.

Now , Lansclad does but that is unacceptable to Jews.
 
How civil can a country be while be at war for over 59 years now ? Is Israeli society perfect ? Far from it. A perfect democracy ? Very far from it.

Would the USA allow whomever to vote the country out of existence ? Don't think so . Would you stand behind the USA to protect their rights and citizens ? I think you would.

But not for the Jews, right ?
 
DonQuixote said:
I'm not about to get into the history of the State of Israel
and the Palestinian right to return on TERB. It would take
hours if not weeks to deal with this issue.

But, if the Israelis were to sacrifice their rule of law
to satisfy the militant constituency on the right or
the compromising constituency on the left they would
have a hollow and lifeless democracy.

Moving the wall isn't as significant as you are portraying
it. My limited reading on this issue that goes back 2
decades [:cool: ] is that Israel is in the best position
its been in a very long time. I'm assuming you know
more than me and will dismiss my postings as foolish
and stupid as you've done in the past.


No, we both know the issue of the ''right to return'' well enough .They must play the very hard area between the 2 extremes as you state, and also the Arab and Orthodox, and Russian cards in the Knesset and their idiotic parlimentary system. Through in AIPAC and all the other Jewish lobbies here in the US and the 21.5 countries that openly or covertly desire their ambition to destroy the country, and its tough. Very tough, and we both know it.
I do not care about where the wall is at all. It is not about that but about the fact that if Israel existed as 1 synagogue on 100 sq metres ( yes metres) in Tel Aviv or Elait or Haifa, it would be too much for the Arabs. Thats the issue .

With your background , surely you know who Jonathon Pollard is , right ?
 
In case anyone cares

I think no nation should be defined by religion as per their constitution. And further, I think religion is nuts.

But all this is beside the point. The only point was that the ISC made an obviously correct decision. The wall can be built but it can't be built just anywhere.
 
The disputed wall

literally separated some families from their farmland.

There was no obvious reason why it was put where it was, except as a) a landgrab of disputed land; and b) as a major irritant for a number of Palestians, who could no longer easily access their land practically adjacent land.

The ISC has righted this obvious wrong.
 
I too have no use for religion or Greek mythology or the tooth fairy as all three are equally ridiculous.

But the Jews need somewhere to live.

Now Scouser will say Brooklyn yet I grew up there and there really is not the room and I think the invitation got lost in the mail too.

All over Europe you see remnants of the chant of the second world war ''Jude, go home to Palestine''..

Finally , Jews have a little piece of land the same size as New Jersey , more or less.

Re Pollard, then you also understand the ''level playing field'' that is the US's policy towards the ME , correct ?
 
TQM said:
literally separated some families from their farmland.

There was no obvious reason why it was put where it was, except as a) a landgrab of disputed land; and b) as a major irritant for a number of Palestians, who could no longer easily access their land practically adjacent land.

The ISC has righted this obvious wrong.

The obvious reason my friend is that individuals and nations have a right to defend themselves. This does include Jews and Israel not just non Jews and non Jewish nations.