Bryant - Guilty or innocent?

  • Thread starter Thread starter burt-oh-my!
  • Start date Start date

How should Bryant be found in the cyclist's death?

  • 100% innocent - self defense all the way

    Votes: 88 43.8%
  • Guilty of a traffic infraction ( wrong way/dangerous driving)

    Votes: 32 15.9%
  • Vehicular Homicide ( i.e. current charges)

    Votes: 55 27.4%
  • Manslaughter

    Votes: 14 7.0%
  • 100% guilty of murder - he clearly tried to kill the guy

    Votes: 12 6.0%

  • Total voters
    201
  • Poll closed .
100% not guilty

Self defense all the way. The biker courier dude should have been charged. He tried to assault Bryant and got what he deserved.

Don't mean to be rude or insensitive, but society is better off today with this loser not being alive today.
 
Regardless of the "attack" by the cyclist, Bryant had choices. It was 9:00 and there were all kinds of people around who could have helped. He made a bad decision.
 
Ok... so I was on vacation when all this went down and don't have ALL the facts, but didn't he "drag the cyclist under his car" for a few hundred feet? I don't know about you, but if I "hit something" while I was driving... I would stop IMMEDIATELY! NOT after a few hundred feet.

This being the case, at the very least- vehicular manslaughter in my book.
 
believer26 said:
Regardless of the "attack" by the cyclist, Bryant had choices. It was 9:00 and there were all kinds of people around who could have helped. He made a bad decision.

Yup and they all rushed to stop things didn't they? Far as I know there weren't even any 911 calls until after it was over.

Sheppard had choices too... he also made bad decisions.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Ok... so I was on vacation when all this went down and don't have ALL the facts, but didn't he "drag the cyclist under his car" for a few hundred feet? I don't know about you, but if I "hit something" while I was driving... I would stop IMMEDIATELY! NOT after a few hundred feet.

This being the case, at the very least- vehicular manslaughter in my book.

No he didn't. Short version:

Sheppard and Bryant have an incident... not sure who hit who... no damages
Sheppard slams backpack on hood of car.
Bryant goes to leave
Sheppard grabs on to side of car by driver's door
Car goes speeding down road, going over to oncoming lane - unclear at this point whether cyclist is just hanging on or grabbing at the wheel/Bryant
Car comes close enough to cause Sheppard to hit a tree, something else and then get knocked off by hitting a mail box
Sheppard lands under car and is run over by the rear wheels
Bryant stops the car shortly afterwards and calls 911

Given the quality of your posts in the past I was quite surprised to see you post an opinion without getting the facts first.
 
Moraff said:
No he didn't. Short version:

Sheppard and Bryant have an incident... not sure who hit who... no damages
Sheppard slams backpack on hood of car.
Bryant goes to leave
Sheppard grabs on to side of car by driver's door
Car goes speeding down road, going over to oncoming lane - unclear at this point whether cyclist is just hanging on or grabbing at the wheel/Bryant
Car comes close enough to cause Sheppard to hit a tree, something else and then get knocked off by hitting a mail box
Sheppard lands under car and is run over by the rear wheels
Bryant stops the car shortly afterwards and calls 911

Given the quality of your posts in the past I was quite surprised to see you post an opinion without getting the facts first.
Bryant was/ is a Lawyer correct? This being the case he is CLEARLY a highly educated individual and clearly VERY familiar with the legalities involved in such a situation...

Why start moving the car at all????? Just lock yourself in the car and call 911. Let the cops figure it out. End of story. Cyclist gets arrested for whatever charge they get him for- no one gets injured, no one gets killed.

Right? (Unless there is A LOT more to this story than we know (or are being told).... too bad know one can get the other guy's story on this matter... I'm just saying...)
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Why start moving the car at all????? Just lock yourself in the car and call 911. Let the cops figure it out. End of story
He couldnt have, he was driving a convertible with the top down
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Bryant was/ is a Lawyer correct? This being the case he is CLEARLY a highly educated individual and clearly VERY familiar with the legalities involved in such a situation...

Bryant is the former Attorney General, a lawyer, and the gentlemen heavily involved in passing laws on street racing and pitbull bans.

Cycleguy007 said:
Why start moving the car at all?????

Because Sheppard was younger, bigger and apparently intoxicated and raging. Apparently Bryant felt he needed to get away from Sheppard to preserve his safety. One could just as easily say "Why did Sheppard feel the need to run after Bryant and grab the side of the car?" Unless he's kin to Superman he's not going to stop it.

Cycleguy007 said:
Just lock yourself in the car and call 911.

Sorry forgot to mention it was a convertible. Mr. Bryant also had his wife in the car with him.

Cycleguy007 said:
Let the cops figure it out. End of story. Cyclist gets arrested for whatever charge they get him for- no one gets injured, no one gets killed.

Right? (Unless there is A LOT more to this story than we know (or are being told).... too bad know one can get the other guy's story on this matter... I'm just saying...)

Last report I heard police were still reviewing the video footage from security cameras along the street where it occurred.
 
Sammy the Bull said:
He couldn't have, he was driving a convertible with the top down
Oh...

I clearly need to read all the facts on the story and get sworn statements from both the highly educated and intelligent lawyer and the lowly cyclist before I make further comment... :o

Anyone got the cyclists current contact info?

My point being... we are only ever going to get the lawyer's story now. The cyclist is dead, and can therefore not tell us HIS version of the story... He may have in fact been a sonofabitch... I am NOT abdicating his action one way or the other... but doesn't ANYONE wonder if the lawyer (being VERY WELL VERSED in how to deal with such matters), wonder, (like I do) if there is just a little more to this?
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Ok... so I was on vacation when all this went down and don't have ALL the facts, but didn't he "drag the cyclist under his car" for a few hundred feet? I don't know about you, but if I "hit something" while I was driving... I would stop IMMEDIATELY! NOT after a few hundred feet.

This being the case, at the very least- vehicular manslaughter in my book.
You may have managed to miss all the posts from folks around here who are claiming justification for putting the cyclist's life at peril because of reports that the cyclist was being agressive towards the driver.

I just hope I never run into those folks - the extrapolation of their position is that if someone raises a fist to you, you are justified in shooting them. In the present case, many have taken the position that because there were reports that the cyclist had his hands inside the car while the driver was driving away (apparently trying to "scrape him off" on a lamp post or mailbox), the driver must have felt his life was in imminent danger and thus justified in putting the cyclist's life in imminent danger while attempting to flee.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Oh...

I clearly need to read all the facts on the story and get sworn statements from both the highly educated and intelligent lawyer and the lowly cyclist before I make further comment... :o

Don't miss Thor's and Anynym's posts... they are interesting reading.....

Cycleguy007 said:
Anyone got the cyclists current contact info?

c/o Shirley McLain? (what.. too soon?) (Yes I have a morbid sense of humour it's how I deal with death)


Cycleguy007 said:
My point being... we are only ever going to get the lawyer's story now. The cyclist is dead, and can therefore not tell us HIS version of the story... He may have in fact been a sonofabitch... I am NOT abdicating his action one way or the other... but doesn't ANYONE wonder if the lawyer (being VERY WELL VERSED in how to deal with such matters), wonder, (like I do) if there is just a little more to this?

Okay I will agree that Bryant is well-versed in the law, and presumably given his involvement in street-racing laws that extends to vehicular law. However that doesn't mean he is well-versed in apparently being threatened with physical violence by a younger and taller gentlemen while he is belted into his car's seat. One who has already demonstrated his aggression by slamming his backpack onto the car hood.

You are correct that Sheppard can't tell us his side of the story. Good thing there are several witnesses as well as video clips to help get his side out.
 
I think that Bryant won't do any jail time. Bryant's too rich and too powerful. The judge will wind up giving him the benefit of the doubt.

Bryant's legal team has already hired a top PR firm to represent him. I believe the PR firm is called Navigator.

http://network.nationalpost.com/np/...t-stepping-down-as-ceo-of-invest-toronto.aspx

Bryant's also hired one of Toronto's best defence lawyers to represent him by the name of Marie Henein.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...ho-will-defend-michael-bryant/article1277047/

Bryant might have to do some community service but I don't think he'll have to do any jail time.

I think that Bryant is innocent.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Oh... I also just picked up this little tidbit... The Car ran over the cyclist and sped away from the scene... That is ALSO an offense! Leaving the scene of an accident... is it not?

What sort of lawyer is this guy???? :rolleyes:

Yes the car's rear wheels ran over the cyclist after he was dislodged from the car. And Bryant sped all of about 20' away before stopping to call 911.

If we assume that Sheppard was indeed still fighting with Bryant up until the dislodgement then Bryant really didn't do anything wrong. I certainly can't stand up and say I would have stopped the car and given Sheppard a chance to pound on me.

No he didn't go check on Sheppard... How was he to know if Sheppard was still able to continue the fight? Or if he had buddies coming after to 'even the score'? Police recommend motorists to stay in their cars if there's been a road rage incident to avoid continuing or escalating the incident.

Besides, assuming the above is true, I wouldn't have gone back to help the guy who was just threatening to do me harm....
 
Whether he 'left the scene' or stopped after ensuring his safety will be up to the court to decide. Did the leaving of the initial incident constitute "leaving the scene" or was he ensuring his safety and the whole thing is one incident.
 
Moraff said:
Yes the car's rear wheels ran over the cyclist after he was dislodged from the car. And Bryant sped all of about 20' away before stopping to call 911.
That part was left out of the news report I just read...

Anyway... there is clearly going to be much wrangling by his newly appointed and very expensive (and presumably very well connected) legal team... :rolleyes:
 
Cycleguy007 said:
That part was left out of the news report I just read...

Anyway... there is clearly going to be much wrangling by his newly appointed and very expensive (and presumably very well connected) legal team... :rolleyes:

I can't recall which of the many news bits had that tidbit of info. As more info came out the police stated that they may have charged him prematurely (or words to that effect)

Based on what's been reported in the news so far I don't think his legal team's going to have to work all that hard (assuming of course the media hasn't gotten things wrong <grin>)

Salvaging his political career..... that's likely going to take some doing however.
 
Moraff said:
Yes the car's rear wheels ran over the cyclist after he was dislodged from the car. And Bryant sped all of about 20' away before stopping to call 911.
Sources?

All the reports I've seen say that Bryant went a couple blocks after running over the cyclist (after having apparently intentionally "scraped" him off of the side of his car against a mailbox, according to reports provided by CTV). That's a whole lot more than 20 feet. In any event, Section 200 of the Highway Traffic Act requires a driver to stop immediately in the case of an accident, not down the road after having run over the victim with their rear wheels.

And I have seen no reports that Bryant called 911. There have been unconfirmed reports that his female passenger called 911, but there have also been reports that others watching the events transpire called 911 and police caught up with Bryant after he had stopped.

It is critical, especially in cases where an accused has hired an expensive PR firm to spin the story and try to change the facts, that people don't give in to fiction.