I'm very lukewarm on AJ. He's been a disappointment during his stay as a Jay. I think he's on contract drive mode. I'd love to see AJ back if I thought he could duplicate this year and see a one-two punch of Roy and AJ, with the Jays picking up a bat or two and with a full season under Cito.... but I don't know if I can rely on him...
Let him go. He's been very good in the 2nd half, but thats about it for his tenure as Jay, too inconsitent. For a guy who strikes out a lot of batters, his ERA shouldn't be over 4.00. Although you could also argue with Marcum out for the year, maybe they pay that extra money to keep him now??