Brian Dickson found guilty in ‘webcam’ murder of York U student Qian Liu
A jury has found a 32-year-old man guilty of first-degree murder in the death of a York University student from China.
Brian Dickson's lawyer had argued his client did not mean to kill Qian Liu in her off-campus basement apartment three years ago.
As Superior Court Justice Anne Molloy charged the jury Monday morning, the parents of both Qian “Necole” Liu and Dickson listened intently from opposite sides of the courtroom as they have throughout the trial.
The defence argued that Dickson, 32, is only guilty of manslaughter because he killed Liu unintentionally as she resisted his sexual advances around 1 a.m. on April 15, 2011.
The Crown’s position was that Dickson deliberately murdered Liu to keep her silent after he forced his way into her apartment and sexually assaulted her.
During six days of evidence, the jury heard that Liu lived in the small basement apartment in the same rooming house as Dickson near the York campus.
Her former boyfriend Xian Meng, who lived in Beijing at the time, testified that he and Liu were video-chatting using “Tom Skype” when he heard a knock at her door.
She opened the door and had a brief conversation with a man who appeared to use her cellphone. The man then shoved his way into the apartment and attempted to embrace her as Liu resisted and protested, he said.
After two muffled bangs, there was silence from Liu, he said.
He could hear heavy breathing and then saw a man naked from the waist down approach the webcam and disconnect it, he said.
Liu’s body was found lying face down on her bedroom floor later that morning. Semen that overwhelmingly matches Dickson’s DNA profile was found on her mostly naked body.
The Crown told the jury that the most likely cause of death was “mechanical asphyxiation” through neck compression such as a chokehold.
In his closing argument, defence lawyer Robert Nuttall maintained a cause of death has not been established.
For the jurors to find Dickson guilty of first-degree murder, they must find the Crown proved four things beyond a reasonable doubt, Molloy said in her charge to the jury:
1) Dickson unlawfully caused the death of Liu
2) He had the state of mind required for murder
3) Dickson committed or attempted to commit a sexual assault of Liu
4) The sexual assault and the murder occurred as part of the same series of events
Molloy told the jury that second-degree murder means Dickson “meant to cause Liu’s death or caused bodily harm likely to cause death and was reckless about whether she died or not.”
But if a sexual assault is attempted or committed as part of the murder, it is automatically considered first-degree murder, she said
Because they're sick in the head.
Star article. Something doesnt make sense, its typical poor Star writing.
After two muffled bangs, there was silence from Liu, he said. But then after that it says "most likely cause of death was mechanical asphyxiation” through neck compression such as a chokehold".
How can it be both gunshots and strangling?? Thats assuming they mean gunshots with "two muffled bangs"
http://www.thestar.com/news/crime/2014/04/07/jury_deliberations_begin_in_webcam_murder_trial.html
What is wrong with some young white males (Dickson, Bernardo, Rafferty, etc.)? Can't they get sex the old fashion way --- -courtship and seduction? Why rape and murder?
Perhaps, then again perhaps it sounds like the truth?What is wrong with some young black males (insert 1000 pimp names here)? Can't they make money the old fashion way -- getting a job? Why pimp out young girls?
See how racist it sounds when you turn it around?
They didnt. I'm just taking a guess.who said anything about the bangs being gunshots?
They didnt. I'm just taking a guess.
What else could it be?? Popcorn popping??
Historically, young black males have been the target of massive discrimination so they turn to whatever activities will provide them with an income. Young white males who rape and murder do not have an historical excuse.What is wrong with some young black males (insert 1000 pimp names here)? Can't they make money the old fashion way -- getting a job? Why pimp out young girls?
Historically, young black males have been the target of massive discrimination so they turn to whatever activities will provide them with an income. Young white males who rape and murder do not have an historical excuse.
Add Russell Williams (former commander of the base at Trenton) to the list.Bernardo was 25 years ago.
Add Russell Williams (former commander of the base at Trenton) to the list.
I wouldve called that "two thumps". But thats just me.sure... popcorn popping in the microwave...
or maybe... the BANG of a table hitting the floor... or maybe the BANG of someone's head hitting a wall... or the BANG something hitting something...
or paying for it?Can't they get sex the old fashion way --- -courtship and seduction?
The full picture of Dickson’s depravity that was drawn during his January 2012 bail hearing, covered by a publication ban until Monday’s verdict: That he advocated having sex with children on online message boards; that he’d purportedly made sexual advances on another young woman who lived in Liu’s student rooming house — Dickson was a resident there too, on the ground floor; that he’d allegedly forced a woman he’d met at a nightclub in 2006 to have sexual intercourse and when she told him to stop he told her to “Shut the f--- up,” continuing for another 20 minutes — that prompted a sexual assault charge, later withdrawn by the Crown.
That a former girlfriend accused him of choking her and shoving two fingers down her throat after he’d been caught stealing money from her bank account to buy cocaine; that pornography — about half of it involving Asians and a quarter involving teenagers — had been found by police in his room; that, on message boards, he’d championed having sex with girls as soon as they hit puberty, writing that he’d “encourage” incest and exposing his own children to “lots of porn and oral.”
“As for actual incest,” he said in one posting, according to the testimony of Toronto Det.-Sgt. Frank Skubic, “I do encourage it . . . but only after they begin to develop.”
Historically, young black males have been the target of massive discrimination so they turn to whatever activities will provide them with an income. Young white males who rape and murder do not have an historical excuse.
Black people make excuses about discrimination and bullshit like that. (Not all black people mind you.) It's so easy to play the victim card isn't it.
You play the hand that you are dealt. If white was the minority, I'd play the same card if it had a chance of passing blame to someone else.
Perhaps, then again perhaps it sounds like the truth?