Brass Rail shooting update

WinterHawk said:
Personally I'd draft them as Human Bomb Disposal Units to find roadside bombs.
Nah... organ donors.
 
I do think any personal property they have, and a percentage of their future income if they ever get out of jail, should go to look after their victims' kids.

Some cultures had that practice, I always thought it was silly that we don't.
 
Psubs said:
You are in possession of a gun gets you 2 years in jail.
You discharge a gun in public, you should get 5 years in jail even if you don't hit anyone.
You injure someone, you get 10 years.
3rd degree 20 years.
2nd degree 25 years.
1st degree life.
Sounds very reasonable to me.
 
WinterHawk said:
What matters is that these 2 idiots broke the law and because of it someone died. Does it really matter that they didn't want to kill the person who died? I don't think it matters. Unless they feared for their lives, and I don't think that was the case, then they should be the price for taking someones life.

Personally I'd draft them as Human Bomb Disposal Units to find roadside bombs. Let the deaths mean someone else lives!!!

Since their lives were not at risk and they decided to take a life. I say I like the idea of giving them something to do that has value to society. Human Bomb Disposal units sounds like a good solution. Why should we house and feed a person for the rest of his/her life for being stupid?
 
Psubs said:
You are in possession of a gun gets you 2 years in jail.
You discharge a gun in public, you should get 5 years in jail even if you don't hit anyone.
You injure someone, you get 10 years.
3rd degree 20 years.
2nd degree 25 years.
1st degree life.


Won't stop the jerks who shoot and kill many people then kill them self. How would the law up above stop those jerks?
 
automorph said:
sad and tragic that an innocent person died...........if it was a bouncer I wouldnt give a crap.........too many bouncers act like idiots.......more of them need to be shot

That's a bit harsh.

I must admit that *some* bouncers can be over the top but they don't pick on everyone and it's not the most stress free job. Hundreds of partons go in and out of the doors of clubs and bouncers are not trying to pick fights with everyone.

I have always had a good time with bouncers in every type of club everywhere in the world cos I normally treat them with respect, tip them and share a joke or two with them too to ease their job as they nornmally get treated like cr@p anyway.

Until you have been a bouncer and have had to deal with the odd tools who have attitude its hard to say but to glee at them being shot is not a cool thing as they protect us patrons too.

The fact that they ejected troublesome guys and those two guys came back with a gun tells me that the bouncers did the right thing and their intuition and desire to protect was correct.

Those two guys could have been really nasty and violent to the girls too maybe touching them in inappropriate places etc. They also could have shot patrons and staff so the bouncers did the right thing.

The fact that the guy shot an innocent person let alone a bouncer at point blank range is really cowardly. For you to celebrate it is not much better.
 
S.C. Joe said:
From the Toronto Star.........


"I am going to shoot you,'' Zekarias is alleged to have threatened, after brushing himself off from a rough deposit on the street, as bouncer Mario Ordonez told police.


In his own police interview, Gibson told court, Zekarias acknowledged his rage over brutish ejection. "It did not matter to Zekarias that he was 115 pounds. He was angry'' '



This sounds like he was like beaten up. Quote, A "brutish ejection" and "a rough deposit on the street".

Was that really called for? The guy was only 115 lbs. Thats feather weight, why not just take his arm and lead him out the door?

I always believe in to "treating others as they treat you", now this shooting afterwards did take the saying too far and yes now a kid is without a dad. Its a very sad story.

B.R. is dam lucky those guys took off running afterwards. Heck that was a 9mm high power gun. The shooter might have had many bullets in there left and could have keep on shooting until he was out of bullets.

Its nice that Canadians are not super nuts like some of these shooters in the USA.
 
Black guys with guns and chips on their shoulders = dangerous combination to society. Ship'em back to Eritrea where they can play with guns all they want.
 
Why does SCJOE have to "knock it off"? He's not entitled to his opinion?

I don't think hes condoning what happened, just saying there might be some mitigating facts to this tragedy.

Also, since you seem to be in the know reagarding the BR, what were the circumstances about the other shooting involving the bouncers a few years ago? Two shootings involving bouncers??? Don't know of any other bar in Toronto that can claim that? Do you?

Or do I "have to knock it off" as wll?

Marcus Aurellis
 
Sorry, I did not think I was blaming the victim. He had nothing at all to do with any of this but was at the wrong place at the wrong time.


Isn't funny thou, how the people for guns, always think the answer to gun problems is, if more people had guns there be less problems with guns :confused:
 
I have no sympathy for the shooter. If a bouncer makes reasonable requests you have two options:
a) comply and stay
b) leave

This might not be 2nd degree but manslaughter.

I'm using the jane creba case as an example. A few weeks ago it was mentioned in the Toronto Star that one of the shooters was going to get manslaughter.

I think (this part was not explained but I searched out the definitions of 1st, 2nd and MS to try and determine why this happened) the defense might be going with the following angle.....

yes the guy had a gun, yes he was trying to shoot someone but the person he shot was not the person he INTENDED to shoot.

This is NOT to say that I like this kind of thinking and in fact I was appalled because in my opinion the fact should be that the shooter knew that bullets can be lethal and that his intention was to cause harm. The fact that he was a bad shot should not work to his benefit.

As for the piece about intimidation.... a prosecuting lawyer would probably have a hard time proving that the guy was trying to intimidate the bouncer. Otherwise a lot more of these incidences would get bumped up to 1st degree thanks to the intimidation part.
 
Over here many of the public schools have metal detectors and all of the court houses have them. Sure some clubs have them too. They have really help to keep the number of shooting down.

Yes, it does seem like more of our freedom is being taken away all of the time.
 
To me the use of metal detectors is not that bad of a lose of freedom. I mean I've never had a need for a metal weapon in a school, courthouse or strip club. And frankly I don't mind knowing that the chances of the dude at the next table doesn't have one either. I'm not interested in catching a stray bullet cause some guy is hammered and can't shoot straight. Nor am I interested in some wanna be tough guy waving a gun in my face because I've somehow offended him.

Sheik,

I know this has always been your stance on things and probably a point where we don't see eye to eye. But we're talking about personal safety and what's better for people as a whole. Yes the problem in part stems from people not being able to control themselves but from a legal standpoint it's probably easier to deal with the symptoms than the disease.
 
No you cant recall 2 seperated shootings where the Bouncer was the specific target can you? Didnt another incident involve another disgruntled patron who was so pissed off, he went to the kitchen store next door, BOUGHT a knife and attacked yet another Bouncer? Seems like this place has a lot of unhappy customers!!!

Read your lengthy diatribe about guns, rap music, lenient court sentences, the decline of Western Civilization etc....Thats not what i'm talking about.

There is a right and wrong way to handle problem customers, obviously the BR is lacking in this department.

BTW, when did a Zanz doorman get shot...Ive never heard of that one.

Marus Aurellis
 
S.C. Joe said:
Over here many of the public schools have metal detectors and all of the court houses have them. Sure some clubs have them too. They have really help to keep the number of shooting down.

Yes, it does seem like more of our freedom is being taken away all of the time.

For some reason I recall you saying you live in Canada.
 
papasmerf said:
For some reason I recall you saying you live in Canada.



Be nice but then over here is nice too. I live just outside of Detroit-heading north west. Canada is a 25 min drive but then its Windsor-wish it was the Falls but then I live in NY so I am good where I am.

NY gets too much snow and has higher taxes and more vehicle laws.
 
Wtf

automorph said:
sad and tragic that an innocent person died...........if it was a bouncer I wouldnt give a crap.........too many bouncers act like idiots.......more of them need to be shot

As a former dancer and someone who employees security personal I am appalled at your comment no one I mean no one deserves to be shot under any circumstances. Six or seven yr ago that could have been me. I have danced the rail. Now it was a dive like most of the downtown SC in Toronto then they may have changed now. 1) and hey news flash I have an FAC. but I think hand guns have no use in Canada and nor do gun clubs to shoot them.( riffles and shot guns are fine)
2) Yes many bouncers can be plain fools but that goes right back to club management and ownership. Hire the right people, not the juice monkeys. There are many very well trained ex military ex police and ex fighters out there. But many clubs pay shit for this job so they get shit personal.
3) Funny having rules about hats etc and stating they are gang related rules then why no metal detector. Way I understand it this guy had the gun on him. Whole situation might have been avoided
4)Ultimately the responsibility is that of the young men going to a strip club with gun in waist band and then deciding they are going shoot someone over something very very dumb.

Life with possible parole in 15 to 20 yrs. They knew guns kill (belonged to club) and guns booze and strippers is one cocktail that is not on any menu in my book. Just like the bouncers as you stated showing off. Why carry gun they doing same thing. One thing men have to realize a true gentlemen is what turns us on. Not violence outside of a sanction fight in a ring and certainly not carrying a gun unless licensed to do so.
 
Sheik said:
I've seen the bouncers in action at the rail and not once did I ever see them being excessively rude.

Is that willful blindness?

(This is the wrong thread for this. As I've said, people have a right to be assholes. Whether they are assholes or not does not make it any less a murder.)
 
fuji said:
Is that willful blindness?

(This is the wrong thread for this. As I've said, people have a right to be assholes. Whether they are assholes or not does not make it any less a murder.)
Indeed, it doesn't make it any less murder, and even for mitigation (i.e. reduction of the charge) the provocations and reaction have to be immediate - you can't go out the door and then when the doorman yells "Hey you forgot your coat" turn around shoot him and then argue I was provoked. Of course you could argue it, but I doubt it would be particularly successful in light of the jury instructions you'd get.
 
Sheik said:
When anything is outlawed, the outlaws have it.
It does make it easier for enforcement if people are found with banned substances. It does make it hard to get things which is the point of the exercise. In this case I don't know if this would have had a gun prior to this incident he wasn't a criminal.

Sheik said:
Just look at illegal drugs, ho has it? It's effectively banned and prohibited but its still available.
It is rare to find someone dying from an accidental O.D. caused by walking by a SC. It really isn't a fair comparison.

People can make/grow illegal drugs in their basements but can't plant bullets and grow guns. While it is true you could never eliminate guns from the street but they can make it really, really hard to get.

This kid in this case had a legal gun, although he was carrying it illegally, he didn't need it...

Sheik said:
Look at alcohol and how many people die as a result of it, its government regulated and controlled yet hundreds of thousands of people die every year from it.
Well there is a difference between killing yourself and killing someone else. With alcohol you aren't harming anyone but yourself (excluding drinking and driving, domestic disputes,..) with guns they are the designed to be lethal to others.

Sheik said:
Knock it off
With all due respect I assume you are posting as a member in this thread and not a Moderator? You never said why S.C. Joe had to "Knock it off" instead of expressing his opinion (not that I agree with SCJ...)