bold plan for the electric car from Ted.com

Carrie Moon

webstar
Sep 12, 2002
1,426
0
0
Ottawa
www.carriemoon.ultraescort.com
He has some interesting plans but something about him made me want to punch him in the face. Is it just me?
 
Good presentation. He basically took bits and pieces floating around on the net and put them into a cohesive presentation. His attempts at humor kinda falls flat.

I really learned nothing new from his presentation, my conviction is that battery technology has always been the limiting factor. I feel he is downplaying the battery issue, both in terms of cost and the pollution they create.

His chart using moore's law to illustrate falling $/mile prices is a total crock. 15 years ago lithium ion was the new battery tech, I am sure production costs have come down from 15 years ago simply due to increased demand, but energy density and charge cycles has at best doubled for lithium ion cells over the past 15 years.

We need a focused approach to the electric car problem, focus on the damned batteries, put up a 10 Billion dollar prize to the first company that can make a significantly better and cheaper battery.

All these presentations take focus away from the real problem, the battery. Everything else; motor, drivertrain, chasis, electronics, is playschool stuff. Put a cheap, light, long lasting, low pollution, long life battery on the market and tomorrow everyone will be driving an electric car.
 
Saw him...

...on the HOUR last week. I think it's a very interesting concept. Batteries AREN'T the problem, infrastructure is. And that's what he's dealing with. Battery runs down...swap it out.

In any new technology, again his point, someone needs to just do it! Just start NOW...then everyone jumps on board. Then the technology gets better / cheaper. Everyone's been talking for 20 years about this crap. See the same booths at the Autoshow year in / year out. Big deal...green this...BLAH BLAH BLAH. Juts START ALREADY. And that's his point. Start NOW...not 25% in 10 years. Make it happen now and the rest will follow.

Op
 
I didnt have the patience to watch to the end

Does anyone have cliff notes???
 
Batteries are the achilles heel of the electric car. Lithium batteries are big dangerous and really expensive. Lead Acid batteries are really heavy, and they are not cheap either. Electric motors are heavy too, but they are not as big of a problem as the batteries are.

Everyone who has bumped into compressed air knows that it isn't a good medium for storing large quantities of energy usefully.

Storing energy is hard. There are reasons why we drive cars that burn gas. Gas engines are actually a pretty good technology. They won't be easy to replace.
 
Cassini said:
Batteries are the achilles heel of the electric car. Lithium batteries are big dangerous and really expensive. Lead Acid batteries are really heavy, and they are not cheap either. Electric motors are heavy too, but they are not as big of a problem as the batteries are.

Everyone who has bumped into compressed air knows that it isn't a good medium for storing large quantities of energy usefully.

Storing energy is hard. There are reasons why we drive cars that burn gas. Gas engines are actually a pretty good technology. They won't be easy to replace.
There is not enough lithium on earth to make all the batteries they will need with the current technology.