BMW X3 2.5i?

Arena

Member
Oct 1, 2004
541
3
18
BMW is currently offering some pretty good lease rates on the X3.
I've always driven Japanese autos, what do you all think about the BMW X3 2.5i in terms of performance, reliability and value?
 
Arena said:
BMW is currently offering some pretty good lease rates on the X3.
I've always driven Japanese autos, what do you all think about the BMW X3 2.5i in terms of performance, reliability and value?

Although the X3 is a BMW, it's not really a BMW because the whole car is made and built by Magna, not in a BMW factory. Furthermore, the 2.5 engine is being phased out ... perhaps that's the reason for a good deal. And, there are lots of options to be added on the X3 which pushes the price tag.

Hey, have a look at the new Mercedes B-Class exclusively for us Canadians ... or the Audi A3. Although, I would choose BMW over the other Teutonic brothers, it seems like the Benz and the Audi is a better deal ...
 
The X3 is a unique sport utility "lite" vehicle. PErformance, wise, you get the great BMW handling and driveability that they are renowned for. UNfortunately, the engine is a little underpowered for this kind of vehicle in my opinion unless you intend to use it like a "soccer mom" vehicle only. If you are looking for a luxury SUV that drives very well, test drive the 4.0 or 4.4. X5 (manual of course).
 
DateMasamune said:
Although the X3 is a BMW, it's not really a BMW because the whole car is made and built by Magna, not in a BMW factory.
Magna also makes the Mercedes G class and some Chrysler vehicles.

I don't think you can say that it is not a BMW. Magna is making it under contract. I would also say that the quality at Magna is probably better because they are under a watchful eye from BMW.

Also, Magna already does a lot of engineering, manufacturing and assembly for all the auto makers. These days car companies are more involved with marketing and future prototypes and less with manufacturing.
 
If I was in the market for a small, luxury SUV, I would seriously consider the X3. I think it's surprisingly good value. It's a lot cheaper than the X5 and not that much smaller. I haven't priced the Mercedes in a while so I can't make a comparison. I'd stay away from the Audi.

The 2.5 is a good engine. Any BMW inline 6 is good for 500,000+ km w/o any major work. I think that it's adequately powered, but you won't win races with it. You don't buy SUV's to burn pavement anyway.
 
Suv

Friends and I were comparing it with the X5 as it looked smaller on the outside. It did have some hp when the guy driving next to me punched it. He probably didn't like the fact I was driving next to them. Mistaken Goodtime for checking out his girl...

Personally I prefer the Benz styling, even though more bubble like, the offroad course demo was impressive. I'm considering going back to SUV as well but kept putting it off. Not that I can afford a MB...

Recent gas prices certainly keeps reality in check.
 
Last edited:
Compared the 2.5 and the 3.0 engines for the X3, hands down the bigger engine wins.
Still not really fast, but the 3.0 is smoother, quieter, and just better suited for such a heavy vehicle.
I think the critics are right, if you're going to drive a BMW, you've gotta go with the sedans.
 
If you do any serious amount of driving..50k to 80k a year..the BMW, and Mercedes lease people will go screeming home to mommy.
I was in the market last year and the BMW salesman suggested I was crazy to drive that much. Uhh yea guy...It's part of my job!
Some ultimate driving machine, eh?
 
I'm curious about the real allure of some of these Euopean sedans/suvs.
My comment about the lease situation is telling.

Why, do these companies not try and attract real-life drivers, who spend hours of there lives behind the wheel? Are these machines not designed for us?

My guess, is the real money for these car manufactures is in the used sale, after a short term lease.

I'd love to try a Bimmer or an Audi for a couple of years (tried the A6 and thought it was great!), but they have really limited leasing options, and get priced WAYYY CRazy if you drive more than 20k a year.