Many of those successful WC teams were when there was just one WC team per league, and they played the best of 5 division series against a division leader. A few years ago (I'm not sure how many, my memory is no better than yours!) they changed to the 2 WC team system, where they have the one game playoff to see who plays in the ALDS or NLDS. In theory it (the 2 WC team system) puts the WC teams at a disadvantage, as I believe they should be.
Two Wild Cards/League started in 2012.

