You are correct.
If the Jays make the playoffs, how much is Thole actually needed? Would Dickey make the post season roster? Estrada, Sanchez, Stroman, Happ. Looks pretty good to me. Some catcher at AAA with a bat looks better than Thole.
If the playoffs started tomorrow I'm leaving Dickey and Thole off the roster. Dickey takes an inning to get his knuckler going so relief isn't an option for him. Kratz is the backup C, avg sucks too but at least he has some pop.
Go with 4 starters, 7 relievers and extra guy on the bench.

