Blue Jays: 2016 Edition

Oh great. We're into extra innings with no DH. This seems like such a basic thing. Gotta see Gibby hum and haw out of this one in the post game.

To answer the Gibby apologists, he could have put JB at 1B and Upton in RF.

Have the rules changed. I though in AL ballparks DH rule is effect throughout the game.
 
Have the rules changed. I though in AL ballparks DH rule is effect throughout the game.

Upton pinch-hit for Smoak, then Edwin the DH took over at 1st base. This leaves the pitcher to bat for himself since there's no DH anymore.
Ultistar is right , they should've put Upton in right, Bautista moves to first and Edwin stays at DH.

Jays won so it's no big deal, but I was scratching my head at the move.

Bautista is a horrible outfielder, has been for a while and should be at first or DH from here on out.

Devon Travis MVP of the game!
 
Once the designated hitter is used for defensive purposes - you give up the dh ----- debatable move, but Mr. Gibbons actually has a bench now...so a pitcher never hit

Old true story......in the first year of the dh, Washington (just before they moved to Texas) had a big slugger named Frank Howard as dh......In a middle inning, he warmed up the pitcher......Billy Martin protested that since he was used for another purpose (the way the rule read then)..he could no longer be dh and he protested the game....protest denied.

damn I am old!
 
Upton pinch-hit for Smoak, then Edwin the DH took over at 1st base. This leaves the pitcher to bat for himself since there's no DH anymore.
Ultistar is right , they should've put Upton in right, Bautista moves to first and Edwin stays at DH.

Jays won so it's no big deal, but I was scratching my head at the move.

Great come back win but yeah that was scary; we were one time thru the order away from pinch hitter Thole!
And then if tie continued, we would have seen Happ bunting!

Alls well that ends well. Happy that we are rid of Storen. glad that we're ahead of Bosox.
 
Pinch hitting Upton - right or wrong - was the most imaginative thing Gibbons ever did....he was imagining the headline "Upton blasts homer to beat former team"
 
In an earlier Travis at bat, the ball got away from the catcher and a Jay scored but the umpire nullified the run claiming wrongly that the pitch hit Travis' bat.
 
Cashner actually looked pretty good last night with the quality start. Hope we can land him without giving up too much.

Edit: the new AL ERA leader: Sanchez!
 
Upton pinch-hit for Smoak, then Edwin the DH took over at 1st base. This leaves the pitcher to bat for himself since there's no DH anymore.
Ultistar is right , they should've put Upton in right, Bautista moves to first and Edwin stays at DH.

Jays won so it's no big deal, but I was scratching my head at the move.

Bautista is a horrible outfielder, has been for a while and should be at first or DH from here on out.

Devon Travis MVP of the game!
Gibbons in his post game interview said he didn't want to take a chance on Bautista getting injured playing first, and I can accept that as their is more traffic at first than their is in right.
That double to right in the 12th looked to me to be a catchable ball. Think Buatista's skill level has really dropped. Be very surprised if he gets 5 years and 30 million per year anywhere.

One hell of a comeback....almost went to bed after the home run.
 
In an earlier Travis at bat, the ball got away from the catcher and a Jay scored but the umpire nullified the run claiming wrongly that the pitch hit Travis' bat.

Wrongly?
 
that mastermind John Gibbons sits out his first string catcher, shortstop and left fielder.....and bats a new guy fourth........would Buck Showalter do that? And they are playing like they expect to lose 4-0 4th inning