Blu-ray Versus HD DVD

That will not determine the winner

thundarr said:
Time Warner just annouced it is going with Blu-ray which is the end of HD DVD.

http://www.cnbc.com/id/22508081/site/14081545?__source=yahoo|headline|quote|text|&par=yahoo



The format that is the first to become copyable and easily pirated will be the one that everyone buys into no matter what so called big business try’s to ram down peoples thought.

Four bigger reasons why Blue ray will bust

Sony started the format and the track records on starting formats are Beta, MD and memory sticks

The do not allow Porn industry to record on it

Recording from TV HD_DVD had the first stand alone recorder

HD-DVD is backward compatible for all of those sick of format changes can rent a HD-DVD flip it over and it will still play on the standard common low cost DVD player
 
thundarr said:
Time Warner just annouced it is going with Blu-ray which is the end of HD DVD.

http://www.cnbc.com/id/22508081/site/14081545?__source=yahoo|headline|quote|text|&par=yahoo

I just bought a HD-DVD player on a boxing day blowout. I new that Warner was a wild card but less than a month ago, they announced that they will support both formats. I figured both formats would be around a while, battling it out. I bought the cheapest one, and the one most likely to see High def porn on, figuring I can watch hi def on half the movies coming out and up-convert the other half. If a winner emerged, I had a 50% change of getting it right.

Warner going to BD now puts into question the future of HD-DVD. Unless there's some development that helps HD-DVD then I doubt it will survive.

I suppose I can still return my dvd...

If I do, I won't buy a BD player until the price comes down.
 
Blu-ray camp get out the Pimm's and HD DVD camp get out the whiskey because HD DVD is dead:

"A REPORT in the Financial Times declares that Paramount has a clause in its HD-DVD exclusivity contract allowing the company to bail from HD-DVD if Warner defected to Blu-ray, and that Paramount is 'poised' to do so.

...

Universal, one of the last major studios with HD-DVD exclusivity, has declined to comment on its next-generation DVD plans since the Warner Bros.' move."

http://www.theinquirer.net/gb/inquirer/news/2008/01/08/hd-dvd-declared-dead

If true, HD DVD is done. I see no reasonable alternative.
 
Looks like Blu-ray format won the battle

Sony celebrates victory in fight against Toshiba

5 of 7 major studios back Blu-ray format

By Peter Svensson - ASSOCIATED PRESS
Updated: 01/08/08 6:44 AM
 
WoodPeckr said:
Sony celebrates victory in fight against Toshiba

5 of 7 major studios back Blu-ray format

By Peter Svensson - ASSOCIATED PRESS
Updated: 01/08/08 6:44 AM

Which also suggests a good time to buy Sony stock.:D
 
Piracy a major deciding factor for Blu-ray support

LionsGate: Piracy a major deciding factor for Blu-ray support

Posted by Don Reisinger | January 10, 2008 7:32 AM PST

At CES on Monday, I was invited over to the Blu-ray booth to speak with top executives at the major Hollywood studios supporting Blu-ray. And while I didn't have the chance to speak with every studio, I did get to speak with the President and Chief Operating Officer at LionsGate, Steve Beeks.

And while Beeks seemed like he had solid command over the finer points of the movie industry, I was interested to see why his studio chose Blu-ray over the alternative.

Expecting the canned answer like, "well we thought it was the superior format and I'm happy to say that we were right", you could imagine my surprise when the very first reason he gave was Blu-ray's piracy controls.

For those of you who don't know, Blu-ray's piracy controls -- largely based on AACS, BD+ and BD-ROM Mark -- is easily the most stringent format to date and has only partially been circumvented to this point.

Regardless, I was utterly appalled at the thought that with all of its benefits -- high-capacity, interesting new features to employ while playing movies, major industry backing -- Beeks chose piracy as the first talking point.

Of course, I had to find out more.

Immediately after finishing his spiel about Blu-ray, I asked Beeks a simple question, "With all of these piracy concerns (as you mention), how do you stop looking like the bully when you go after some kid making a few copies in his house instead of the overseas cartels in gunships?"

After a significant amount of skirting the issue, Beeks told me (correctly) that there's no way to stop piracy and the best way to combat it is to offer more features and give people a reason to buy the official version.

And yet, if that's true, why should the studio even care about which format has the more stringent piracy controls? After all, if you know how to fight piracy and you think you're doing a good job at it, why waste your time paying more for a format when you can have the same sort of features on the other and pay less to manufacture discs?

Of course, LionsGate isn't the only company that should be beaten up in this column. The entire motion picture industry is rife with a bunch of executives that have no idea what the average 18-35 year-old person wants when they buy a disc and to make matters worse, they think they do.

I have said it once and I will say it again: the music and movie industries have become relics of the old school and are unwilling to adapt to times. DRM is not only hurting each studio's bottom line, its damaging their ability to look like the good guy in an environment where pirates look like they are.

If nothing else, I learned that the movie industry is run by a subset of individuals who are totally insulated from the real world. If not already proven by the MPAA, look no further than to those poor people who thought they owned something, only to find out later they were being sued for a ridiculous amount of cash for their "crime."

If you ask me, it's time the executives at all these movie studios stop wasting our time with banalities and wake up to realize that the real pirates are out there kicking their teeth in. For once, stop going after the guy who makes a few copies in his room and find the head of an international piracy cartel to stop pirating.

Until that happens, look for even more critics, and even worse publicity.
 
WoodPeckr said:
And yet, if that's true, why should the studio even care about which format has the more stringent piracy controls? After all, if you know how to fight piracy and you think you're doing a good job at it, why waste your time paying more for a format when you can have the same sort of features on the other and pay less to manufacture discs?
I think you already know the answer, but we can all reach the same consensus.

At our homes, we choose to pay for locks for our front door, and some of us even have alarm system subscriptions that we pay extra for. But that doesn't make our homes burglar-proof. So why pay extra, when we can have the same sort of features and pay less to just shut the door?

We would consider it ridiculous to not buy a level of security in line with what we're trying to secure.

And a studio exec should consider it equally ridiculous to not make a similar evaluation with their product. Sure, codes can be broken. But the more effort it takes to break it, the more moral sway the studio has in convincing people that breaking it is wrong.

If we kept our doors unlocked, there would be plenty of folks who would say that's an invitation to "uninvited guests" to come on in. The arguments aren't that different for piracy: if little effort is made to secure the content, there are plenty of folks who say it's okay to take it.
 
WoodPeckr said:
LionsGate: Piracy a major deciding factor for Blu-ray support

I doubt this proposition very much. Both formats are pretty insecure and it's only a matter of time before Blu-ray is as compromised as can be. I don't know why LionsGate would open with talk of piracy. Maybe they're just that dumb or they were sold a bill of goods by Sony.
 
Anynym said:
And a studio exec should consider it equally ridiculous to not make a similar evaluation with their product. Sure, codes can be broken. But the more effort it takes to break it, the more moral sway the studio has in convincing people that breaking it is wrong.

I'm having a "don't copy that floppy" flashback. If this is the case, then execs are REALLY out of touch. They're dealing with the MP3/VHS generations who are both 100% used to copying the things they buy as they see fit. The only value of a broken copy protection scheme is that copying is verboten under the DMCA and similar legislation.
 
Immediately after finishing his spiel about Blu-ray, I asked Beeks a simple question, "With all of these piracy concerns (as you mention), how do you stop looking like the bully when you go after some kid making a few copies in his house instead of the overseas cartels in gunships?"

After a significant amount of skirting the issue, Beeks told me (correctly) that there's no way to stop piracy and the best way to combat it is to offer more features and give people a reason to buy the official version.

That , I agree with.

I don't know how efficient it is since I don't own any HD titles yet, AnyDVD has HD-DVD/Blue Ray version out for a while now.
 
consolation prize?

xdogWhy would you want or need to have a HD DVD disc that can play on a regular dvd player? [/QUOTE said:
Another thought on this ....... since my SO gave me an HDTV for Xmas 2006 we moved the old 32" analog to the bedroom ....... she watches in there so I can watch sports or whatever in HD .... thus it's a great feature as we can watch a movie in either location.... She's not so picky about pic quality so she's happy watching a movie on the old setup. Also when traveling we can watch the movies on a laptop or at anyone's house.

As for me, it's HD all the way. Why? When the SO bought the HDTV it was packaged with a HD-DVD player...... so I'm hoping all the recent talk of BR forging ahead doesn't pan out .... but if BR does win out it'll only be a couple hundred loonies to get a BR player so it's not like the end of the world. If you can afford an HDTV you should be able to swing buying a DVD player.

But I can see how folks get annoyed ..... when I unboxed the TV and HD player I was astounded to find no HD cable to hook them up to each other. Yeah, the regular TV looked way better on the new TV but it wasn't HD. I couldn't even watch anything HD right out of the box, had to go buy HD cables first! THAT pissed me off but it got worse.

I went to Costco and all they had was composite cables but they were a reasonable $35 (HDMI cables were @ $100 a pop back then) so I got one. Things looked good as I also picked up an HD movie to see this amazing thing. I was in the states shortly after and saw an HDMI cable for @ $40 so I snagged it. Things looked even better. Lesson learned, buy the best cable available as the picture quality really does improve.

Still, I had to upgrade the satellite to HD. Bell gave no incentive to current subscribers so we switched to Star Choice as they gave a deal and the SO liked some of their channels better. Wait for the box to arrive and get it installed. Look at the box, it has DVI output for HD. I have HDMI cable waiting for it to arrive (yeah, I saw the specs for the box said DVI output but was hoping it was wrong and would have HDMI...... not!). Go to store, buy DVI to HDMI adapter, another $25. Nickle and dime to death! But at least now I was watching my glorious 17 channels of HDTV (they've added a few more now and they keep trickling in, if I spoke french I'd be up to maybe 25?) ! In the states they have way more channels, shoulda got a US satellite box.........

I'm sure the newer boxes will have HDMI output but ya know what? It all looks great as it is. Besides the initial TV and DVD player I spent @ another $600 - $700 to get the HD show on the road. Yeah, the pic is awesome and the sound incredible .....didn't have to upgrade the home theatre, upgrading the source made it sound like a new system .... TV sounds even better than the old DVD player thru the fibre cable. But I can see why folks gripe about spending a couple hundred for a new player if their format loses out. Granted, I did all this over a year ago so prices have dropped a bit but this can be a pricey investment for sure.

But yes, we do appreciate being able to watch our DVDs on either TV or on the puter. Esp after what we spent to be able to see anything at all! And yeah, I like the HD porn ..... *lol*

;)