Blackberry VS I-Phone?

Omega 600

New member
Sep 17, 2009
295
0
0
Ok, I'm a bit technilogically challenged here, but getting tired of what I have. My whole system is Windows/MS based. I have a Blackberry Pearl, as it was the least expensive at the time. I'm working with a new client who has an I-Phone and my brother also has one. I'm impressed by the bigger screen and the ability to see attachments much more clearly over the tiny screen of my Pearl.

One of my beefs right now is that I get emailed an attachment with either pdf or xls and, though I can open it and see limited pieces of it, I can't see it all. I bought an extra memory card (Mini SD) and have the ability to save the attachments onto this card, then with a little attachment, transfer that file to my laptop for a closer look. DAMN! The BB saves the pdf as a jpg file so I still can't read it on the computer!

I went to the Rogers store today to compare RIM vs I-Phone. I was told by the salesguy that the I-phone won't open pdfs or XL spreadsheets as they are apple software based. Is this true?

What can I do to get the most out of this GD phone stuff?
 
I haven't tried to open an Excel spreadsheet, but my iPhone opens PDFs just fine ... and allows me to "zoom in" and scroll around to read it better. Not sure about "saving" attachments locally - never felt the need to try.
 
I've read ppt, doc, els and PDF files on my iPhone.

OTB
 
Just tossing this in as I don't know the model of the blackberry...what i was told/shown is that if you receive a pdf via email, you can't zoom in to read it on a blackberry. of course, you can on an i-phone. for me, 100% deal breaker. incidently, docs-to-go is the business class app for i-phone.
 
Omega,
Tell us more about your daily usage.
1. Normally, my email is used on the BB to make quick replies while I'm out in the field, but occasionally I have to make design comments on drawings emailed to me ASAP. I need to be able to easily read the documents quickly to give an emailed approval.
2. It hasn't happened yet in 2010, but sometimes I'm on the road at a hotel/motel with no Internet but I have Rogers service on the mobile. I'd like to be able to save an attachment in its true form onto a mini SD card (my BB has one, not sure if I-phone does) and plug it into my USB port of the laptop. Then I can work on the attachment, make necessary changes, put that new file onto the Mini SD and send it out on the I-phone. Not a convenient option, but I would not need that every day either. I believe I would have to get some kind of pdf app for my BB Pearl to do that.
 
Just tossing this in as I don't know the model of the blackberry...what i was told/shown is that if you receive a pdf via email, you can't zoom in to read it on a blackberry. of course, you can on an i-phone. for me, 100% deal breaker. incidently, docs-to-go is the business class app for i-phone.

You can if you have a pdf reader application on your blackberry. I have and can read pdf's. I also have an application (docs to go) that allows me to create/edit/read word/excel/ppt documents.
 
You can ...

thanks for clarifying.

as for the OP's desire to save attachments, transfer them to a laptop and back. iphone has no sd anything. you could use an app to transfer files via the usb port of your computer. you could use winscp if you jailbreak. personally, a non-jail-broke iphone/itouch isn't worth much to me. too many restrictions. if you jailbreak, you can do almost anything you want. no risk. no cost.
 
if its the screen size that's bugging you but you like the other BB features/advantages, just get a Blackberry storm.... Same size screen as the iphone and touch as well.
 
I have noticed that many Blackberry owners have an iPod Touch which addresses their entertainment and gaming needs and so in many ways they have the best of both worlds.
 
1. Normally, my email is used on the BB to make quick replies while I'm out in the field, but occasionally I have to make design comments on drawings emailed to me ASAP. I need to be able to easily read the documents quickly to give an emailed approval.
2. It hasn't happened yet in 2010, but sometimes I'm on the road at a hotel/motel with no Internet but I have Rogers service on the mobile. I'd like to be able to save an attachment in its true form onto a mini SD card (my BB has one, not sure if I-phone does) and plug it into my USB port of the laptop. Then I can work on the attachment, make necessary changes, put that new file onto the Mini SD and send it out on the I-phone. Not a convenient option, but I would not need that every day either. I believe I would have to get some kind of pdf app for my BB Pearl to do that.

OK.

1) As previous posters have commented, you will be able to view PDF, Word and Excel files easily. I don't know about Powerpoint.
2) There is no SD card slot on the iPhone. As a workaround, use DropBox. You can get a basic account with 2GB of online storage for free. They have a free iPhone app too - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vu6us2PxxQg
 
if its the screen size that's bugging you but you like the other BB features/advantages, just get a Blackberry storm.... Same size screen as the iphone and touch as well.

If you must get a Blackberry Storm, get the second version. The hardware quality is considerably better.
 
Powerpoint are viewed as a bunch of jpgs. I don't know if any advanced features work tho.
 
I just go by the saying, "BB for business, iPhone for play."

I have a work BB, and an iPhone for personal use. BB's handling of e-mail is far superior to the iPhone's. Even when you can get "push" e-mail working on the iPhone, it just gives you a polite "incoming mail" sound alert that isn't very loud, and doesn't repeat. You can get a 3rd party app for your iPhone to get better e-mail handling, but you have to forward your e-mail to that company's server for it to be sent to your iPhone.

If you rely heavily on e-mailing for work, you might prefer the BB.

The only other advantage that BB has is Blackberry Messenger... which amounts to free text/instant messaging between BB owners.

IMO, the iPhone destroys the BB in every other category... and with the new iPhone OS due out this summer, it may catch up in the other categories as well.
 
Looks like the Crackberry days to get the business executives addicted are numbered if the following becomes a trend,

http://dealbook.blogs.nytimes.com/2...kberry-war-standard-chartered-chooses-choice/

https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...one-replaces-BlackBerry-for-some-bankers-.-.-.

BTW, for those who don`t know StandChart, this is the British Bank that used to own Mocatta Metals before Scotiabank took over which was then a dog business in 1997.

Many gold bugs in Canada know ScotiaMocatta well since many have the precious metals deposited at the bank. :rolleyes:
 
I agree that the iPhone's email management blows compared to the Blackberry. I could easily filter by subject, by sender. Easily mass delete, mass mark as read. It really is best in class.

As for the the BBM, there are programs that achieve the same thing on the iPhone. Ping comes to mind. Please note that these apps do not allow you to interact with BBM users but only with iPod touch and iPhone users in a identical manner.

I don't think the iPhone supports bluetooth keyboards but it should in the next OS update. My email habits change depending on what device I'm using. Whenever mobile, Blackberry or not, I'd use a sentence or two max. At a laptop or desktop, I'd be more willing to dole out the paragraphs if needed.

I can see easily people using portable bluetooth keyboards with their smartphones and tablets as the trend seems to be now portability (taking your info with you - think cloud computing) and mobility (small devices, tablets, smartphones).
 
thanks for clarifying.

as for the OP's desire to save attachments, transfer them to a laptop and back. iphone has no sd anything. you could use an app to transfer files via the usb port of your computer. you could use winscp if you jailbreak. personally, a non-jail-broke iphone/itouch isn't worth much to me. too many restrictions. if you jailbreak, you can do almost anything you want. no risk. no cost.

Why would anyone feel the need to save the attachment on their iPhone, if you need to do more than can be done natively on the iPhone?

You tether, and deal with the attachment natively on the PC. Why cause yourself extra grief?

Neither the iPhone nor the BBerry are substitutes for a PC. Even the iPad is expressly not a mini computer but rather an advanced touchscreen device.

Sure, the iPhone is not typically as well integrated with corporate email systems. Get over it. When you really need to get things done, you aren't using your Blackberry to edit your powerpoint charts either.
 
Certainly not text entry. Discounting the Storm which I've never used, Bold keyboards are far superior to the iphone.

I really have no issues with text entry on my iPhone, but I will concede that many do. If the bold is that good, I may have to convince my employer to get me one.
 
As for the the BBM, there are programs that achieve the same thing on the iPhone. Ping comes to mind. Please note that these apps do not allow you to interact with BBM users but only with iPod touch and iPhone users in a identical manner.

Well, there are third party iPhone apps that get you closer to true "push" e-mail as well, but RIM has BB messenger and true push email right out of the box. You just need someone's PIN. You don't need to talk them into installing a third party IM app. An app like Ping is no different to me than running any IM app on your iPhone that allows background notifications.