BlackBerry Torch or iPhone 4 ?

Soft

becomes HARD when ......
Oct 20, 2010
114
0
0
Looking for new PDA phone (using BB Bold now) so help me to select either new BB Torch or iPhone 4? Any pro and cons?
Place around GTA area to buy cheaper/unclocked set?
 
Depends on what you want.

Do you want to impress people? The iPhone is a higher status device these days. Do you want to send a lot of messages? The torch is far more practical.

I'd also say that the Android Nexus S is a competitor in this area too that maybe you should also look at, I think it's a technically better phone than either of those, although for the time being it's only on sale in the US and not yet available in Canada.

The other phone that caught my interest is the Nokia N8. It is nowhere as good as a smart phone as either iPhone or Torch, but it has a damn good 12 megapixel camera with a good Carl Zeiss lens, a good flash, and good autofocus. For me, having a damn good camera almost outweighs everything else. Unfortunately it's still running Nokia's ancient Symbian OS (although updated) and so there are relatively few apps for it--though all the basic stuff is covered. Still it takes pictures that beat many lower end dedicated point-and-shoot cameras and that's impressive for a device that you will always have in your pocket.

I'm turning this question over in my head too. One downside of the torch or iphone is that they do not work with the new carriers like Wind and Mobilicity, whereas the Nexus and Nokia phones do. Don't know if you've looked but those new carriers offer unlimited data (and unlimited everything else) at about half the price of Rogers/Bell/Telus.

(Other blackberries support the 1700 band that Mobilicity/Wind do so it's possible there will be a version of the Torch soon that does as well. It's less likely that we will see a 1700 band iPhone in the next while, though, unless t-mobile persuades Steve Jobs to release one in the US, and there aren't even rumours of that at this point.)
 
If you're going from the Bold and you do a lot of texting/emailing I can't imagine going from a keyboard to a touchscreen. I've had a full touch screen with the HTC touch and at the end of the day tired of it very quickly because of the touch screen keyboard. I have the Torch now and am very happy with it. I like the best of both worlds with the touch and keypad. I'm not an Apple guy so I haven't spent more than a few seconds on the IPhone but I have friends who love theirs although none of them use it very much for email as they have work BB's.

As far as unlocked, I've had good dealings with SN Traders www.sntradersonline.com They're in Mississauga at Dixie and Eglinton. They sell unlocked phones but when you are talking about current models......doesn't matter where you buy them you are talking about large dollars.

Good Luck!
 
I went through the same choice a few months ago. Neither phone is perfect so you will ultimately have to compromise on something. The Torch would be perfect if it had a faster processor and a higher resolution screen. Those are its two big flaws and I wish RIM had put better hardware into the Torch. After playing with both phones (in stores and with friends'/co-workers phones) I went with the iPhone4 for speed and for screen clarity.

BB has much (MUCH) better battery life - the iPhone requires recharging every day. But I got used to the virtual keyboard quite quickly, and my iPhone typing is now as fast as my BB typing (I still have a Bold from work). For internet use and apps, the iPhone is far ahead of the Torch, and apps aren't just games - there are countless productivity and lifestyle apps for the iPhone, more than what BB currently provides.

Email is not great on the iPhone. If you get more than 10 messages a day, note that the BB is sooooo much better at message handling and filing. And, the BB uses considerably less data, as RIM compresses the data packages before they are sent to your phone.

Neither phone is perfect. If you need a unit for heavy emailing, then the Torch is likely better. If you just want a personal-use smartphone though, the iPhone is currently a better unit. The ideal would be a Torch with better screen resolution and a 1G processor. Can you wait for the Torch 2, in hopes that RIM ups its game?
 
I was a Blackberry user for over 6 years. When I finally made the switch to iPhone, I was very pleased!
Excessive typing on the physical keyboard actually gave me carpal tunnel!
 
Hey Soft,

I had the same dilemma as you few months ago...

I have been a BB user from Pearl to Bold and now, the Torch.

I really liked the iphone 4, but for emailing, which I uses alot, I would rather having a keyboard than a touch screen. I still find it frustrating to use the touchscreen to type, I made too much mistakes...

The email capability on the BB is amazing, but for web browsing and multimedia, Iphone 4.

Hops this helps you out...

JC
 
I personally find most of the options on smartpohones people dont use.
I had the Torch for one day.. gave it to somebody the next day. It was bulky and awkward. The keyboard is recessed when you pull it out and hard to get you fingers in there.
If you send and recieve alot of messages like I do stick with the bold 9700. if you dont get that many then the Iphone may be better overall.
I use an I phone for apps and ipod etc.
The 9700 will be upgraded soon with a better software and camera.
I agree a good camera is important and the Nokia N8. The Droid Pro from Motorola is interesting also,
But if you need fast , secure , easy , messaging the Bold is the way to go.
 
The iPhone is a hippie device these days.
 
What iphone offers which others phones don't offer? If I compare Nokia, Erricson, LG, Motrola (not BlackBerry) etc models which looks like same as iPhone, features are same then why iphone is so hot in market?

Also does it worth to get iPhone4 as compare to iPhone3?
 
Depends on what you want.

Do you want to impress people? The iPhone is a higher status device these days. Do you want to send a lot of messages? The torch is far more practical.

I'd also say that the Android Nexus S is a competitor in this area too that maybe you should also look at, I think it's a technically better phone than either of those, although for the time being it's only on sale in the US and not yet available in Canada.

The other phone that caught my interest is the Nokia N8. It is nowhere as good as a smart phone as either iPhone or Torch, but it has a damn good 12 megapixel camera with a good Carl Zeiss lens, a good flash, and good autofocus. For me, having a damn good camera almost outweighs everything else. Unfortunately it's still running Nokia's ancient Symbian OS (although updated) and so there are relatively few apps for it--though all the basic stuff is covered. Still it takes pictures that beat many lower end dedicated point-and-shoot cameras and that's impressive for a device that you will always have in your pocket.

I'm turning this question over in my head too. One downside of the torch or iphone is that they do not work with the new carriers like Wind and Mobilicity, whereas the Nexus and Nokia phones do. Don't know if you've looked but those new carriers offer unlimited data (and unlimited everything else) at about half the price of Rogers/Bell/Telus.

(Other blackberries support the 1700 band that Mobilicity/Wind do so it's possible there will be a version of the Torch soon that does as well. It's less likely that we will see a 1700 band iPhone in the next while, though, unless t-mobile persuades Steve Jobs to release one in the US, and there aren't even rumours of that at this point.)

Great analysis, Fuji. I agree with you. I'll probably replace my current Blackberry sometime this spring, and I'm considering the BB Torch or one of the slew of Android phones w/ a qwerty keyboard.

I email / text too much - I need a keyboard.

R2R
 
Unfortunately there's no clear winner in the android phones. From what I've seen, the ones that have a qwerty also run older versions or have other limitations. The Nexus S seems to be the best of the lot but it has only a standard camera and no qwerty.

I am thinking about this topic a lot because I'm going through this decision myself. I actually went and ordered the N8 on newegg (where it's on sale, you can get one for under $500 today) but then cancelled the order because of doubts about whether the Symbian OS would piss me off. That camera is so tempting... it doesn't have a qwerty but I have heard good things about "swish" which you can get on Ovi store (it draws a qwerty and you trace your fingers through the letters of the word you want, lifting off to make a space--word prediction does the rest, and if you don't quite hit the exact letter you want it figures it out anyway so long as you hit most of them).

Now I'm thinking I'll cross over into the US and pick up a Nexus S at bestbuy--they don't ship to Canada and the ebay scalpers are adding $150 to the price if you want to rebuy one via ebay. However it also doesn't have a qwerty...

Seems like if you want a qwerty you pay for it in screen resolution, processor speed, or something else.

Such a dilemma!
 
marketing!

But pretty successful marketing, it's become a statement. My nerd friends might be impressed if I get a top end Android phone, but if you want something that will impress the ladies nothing but iPhone 4 has that kind of social appeal.

Of course you might not care about status issues and just want something that works great for you in which case the choices open up a lot.
 
Depends what you want it for.

I have the iPhone 4. Compared to the 3GS, it's a POS. It's much much slower, freezes and crashes 100% more than the older version.

I've never owned a BB, but am intrigued by the Torch. If the next version of the Torch features a better, i.e. faster OS, and higher resolution screen, I'll switch to BB.
 
I have the iPhone 4. Compared to the 3GS, it's a POS. It's much much slower, freezes and crashes 100% more than the older version.

This hasn't been my experience at all, and does not seem to match the dozens of reviews and dozens of youtube comparisons I looked at when I was doing my research just 2 months ago. Too bad for your shitty experience, it must suck.