Best Hockey

Bobby Orr revolutionized the game. The game took a quantum leap due to his influence .

Wayne Gretzky brought us "anticipation". When you stand beside him it boggles the mind how he did so much with so little physical presence. With Wayne it was all about his mind and his heart.

I'm a huge hockey fan. I appreciate all of the differances in era and position and the competitive aspects of the game ( read ... expansion ) . However I just can't choose between the two. In my opinion it is a separate proposition. They were both absolutely wonderful hockey players and we are blessed to have watched the two of them.

Others deserving mention:

1) Mario Lemieux . A talent beyond reproach . Just not as dynamic as the previous two.
2) Gordie Howe . He could do it all . We named a goal , assist and fight in one game after him . And he did it forever!
3) Maurice Richard . A brilliant combination of skill and determination. And do not mess with him!
4) Bobby Hull. The man was a sculpted god before supplements , personal trainers and proper dieting . His raw physicality was almost freakish.

I hate to go Switzerland here boys but these guys were all in the pantheon . I don't think anyone can say "without question".
 
Malibook said:
At their absolute prime, Mario was by far the best overall, and Orr would be a star today but he would not be nearly as dominant.
The game has evolved alot.
These guys are training year-round with state of the art technology and nutrition.

How old are you? Did ya see Orr play? In '76 Canada Cup he was done, playing on 1 injured leg, and was the best player in the world. Whine & Pepe Lepew could play, but couldn't carry Bobby's Jock. In Gretzkys biggest years the average gpg was 1.6 times that of Orr's best year. For the record that would translate to a best season of 224 points. That's a defenseman kids! That is all.

Best Team? '76/'77 habs, as much as it pains me to admit it, unless you count Team Canada's
 
A Good Old Debate..... and A case for Mario

I was showing my friends hightlights of Orr, Mario and Wayne on youtube and it got me thinking of the good old debate; who is the best?

I think this; Bobby Orr had the widest margin between him and the competition at his time. Wayne Gretzky is no doubt the most successful player of all time, but Mario Lemieux is the best player of all time.

Here in Canada, Gretzky gets a lot more publicity, he is our native son, his stats are legendary. But like Mickey Mantle, with Lemieux you wonder what could have been? Without injuries, with a better team around him...... Even so he was dominant. Until his last comeback he is the only player to average 2 points a game. He was unstoppable, often by himself.

So if you want, let the debate begin relive, who is the best ever?

ps- i wished this was in the sports section.
 
Individuals participating in a team sport -never good comparisons. Not taking into account eras and styles of play, equiptment used, training methods, coaching .......not even taking into consideration Russian born or players who played their carrers in Russia -this can go on and on forever.
 
bobby orr was is still the best player ever to lace them up, and i loved bobby clarke too. both these guys had what not tooo many have now. HEART!
 
21pro said:
A Good Old Debate..... and A case for Mario

I was showing my friends hightlights of Orr, Mario and Wayne on youtube and it got me thinking of the good old debate; who is the best?

I think this; Bobby Orr had the widest margin between him and the competition at his time. Wayne Gretzky is no doubt the most successful player of all time, but Mario Lemieux is the best player of all time.

Here in Canada, Gretzky gets a lot more publicity, he is our native son, his stats are legendary. But like Mickey Mantle, with Lemieux you wonder what could have been? Without injuries, with a better team around him...... Even so he was dominant. Until his last comeback he is the only player to average 2 points a game. He was unstoppable, often by himself.

So if you want, let the debate begin relive, who is the best ever?

ps- i wished this was in the sports section.

I've always believed Lemieux was an all round better player than Gretzky for the same reasons. Good observation. Also, Gretzky had the PR figured out at an early age...not in a negative way, just very pragmatic.
Still think Orr was the greatest though. He was a pure thoroughbred of an athlete.
 
One also has to think what if Orr played today and had access to the medical advances as compared to the 1960-70's. He had numerous surgeries on that knee. It would have been a lot less complicated for him today. I would be willing to bet you could have added several years to his already incredible career.

All the others, Gretzky, Lemieux, Howe were great. Orr, IMO, he was simply the best. The guy was a human highlight reel. Skate, score, hit, fight, he did it all, most if it on one leg.
 
There is no need for any further discussion.

  1. Bobby Orr
  2. Montreal Canadiens
 
stang said:
Apparently.
Another way to examine it.
A team of 5 Gretzky's vs. a team of 5 Orr's.
Who wins?

Team Orr. One reason is there would be no Semenko or McSorley riding shot gun for Gretzky. Orr did not need any protection. He took care of his own business.
 
blueline said:
Team Orr. One reason is there would be no Semenko or McSorley riding shot gun for Gretzky. Orr did not need any protection. He took care of his own business.

Definitely. Orr didn't have bodyguards, got smacked around as much as anyone, and fought as well as anyone when he had to. It's just too bad that his knee injuries truncated his career.

I feel that Orr was the best, and the most exciting to watch. Those end-to-end rushes are still incredible.
 
Bang on with my picks

King said:
Wayne Gretzky.

80-83 Islanders.

Now as for non-league teams, there are two standouts, the 1987 Team Canada (they cut Steve Yzerman and Denis Savard)

And 1976 Team Canada who's roster is a veritable Hall of Fame list.

Marcel Dionne, Danny Gare, Jean Pronovost, Jim Watson, Lanny McDonald, Rene Robert, Steve Shutt, Richard Martin, Bob Gainey, Phil Esposito, Carol Vadnais, Darryl Sittler, Reg Leach, Bill Barber, Paul Shmyr, Dan Maloney, Denis Potvin, Guy Lapointe, Peter Mahovlich, Gilbert Perreault, Serge Savard, Larry Robinson, Gerry Cheevers, Roggie Vachon, Bobby Clarke, Bobby Hull, Guy Lafleur, Glenn "Chico" Resch, Dan "The King" Bouchard, and of course, Bobby Orr
 
gretk

Hockey is a team game. So who would you pick as your centerman if you could hand select his wingers? Sum of the parts would be higher with Gretzky than with Mario.

Mario was the most skilled player but the season isn't a skills competition or a highlight reel. Gretsky had all the intangibles and a competitive fire much like tiger where if you doubted him it triggered something in him and he elevated his play.

Didn't get to see Orr play except in highlight reels where its obvious he was a great skater. But I think due to his speed I don't recall any Denny Savard type stickhandling cuase when your blowing by opposing players like pylons there no need to. I do though have to discount the merits of a player that played when players were alot smaller and less well-conditioned. ie. smoking in the dressing room. Rebutals are welcome as I'd like to hear some comments from the old school. (Anything except watered down talent because the addition of Russian and European players has elevated the game.)
 
Orr or Gretzky??

the rusty tromb said:
Nobody even close? Have you ever heard of a guy by the name of Wayne Gretzky? Orr was great, but didn't accomplish a fraction of what Gretzky accomplished. Please explain how Orr is better than Gretzky.

Here's a different way to look at it.. If you could have only one player on the ice repeated five times example 5 Orr's 5 Gretzky's 5 Mario's Orr would rule
In his prime he dominated Offensively, he fought, he blocked shots, killed penalties, I have clip of him down 5 on his 3 where he picks up the puck and skates circles around the 5 opposing players and killed at least 30 to 45 seconds himself.
If you haven't done it pick up one of his old vidoe's he was truly amazing.

Taking nothing away from Wayne or Mario Gordy the list goes on and on but, as a complete player that dominated ALL aspects of the game I believe Orr to be the best of all time

Flex
 
You guys have no idea of what you are talking about.

Eddie Shack -Toronto Maple Leafs, ya know "Clear the Track, here comes Shack".

Best two way player, Christmas Tree Seller and he had a nose for value....
 
Malibook said:
I never considered Wayne to be a sniper.

Well, he still holds the records for most goals (92) in a season.

I would bet most who don't think Orr was the best probably were too young enough to see him play in his prime.