Roast your own beans! Buy green beans at the Merchants of Green Coffee (Matilda Street near DVP, north off Queen East before Broadview) and roast them in an old hot-air popcorn popper. Just google how to do that properly. Very easy.
If you're not into roasting your own, I've found Van Houtte Colombian Beans pretty good for everyday use. Yeah I know, they're not fair trade, but they're good. The key is not to percolate or drip. Use a French Press. Seriously. That little bit of "sediment", for want of a nicer word, adds body and richness to the cup. Oh, and of course, grind just before using. Use a mill type grinder, not a blade type.
I can't buy a coffee outside the house anymore--my home brew is just so good it puts Starbucks, Second Cup, Timothy's and even the independents like Alternative Grounds, etc.. to shame. I use the smallest French Press, about $12 at Kitchen Stuff Plus and have one perfect cup every day.