Bell Crap Sh!t

Canadian law is crap - if this happened in the US the fine would have been a lot more than $21K. The fine is pocket change for Bell as indicated in the article they didn't even care.

http://ca.finance.yahoo.com/news/bell-tv-reprehensible-violating-mans-privacy-172111130.html

Would Canadian law award someone millions of dollars for spilling to coffee on herself holding the fast food company responsible? Sometimes the laws needs t catch up to he times. Interesting that the plaintive seem happier than you.
 
Would Canadian law award someone millions of dollars for spilling to coffee on herself holding the fast food company responsible? Sometimes the laws needs t catch up to he times. Interesting that the plaintive seem happier than you.

http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000002507537/scalded-by-coffee-then-news-media.html

Maybe we should stop using that case as the example of frivolous lawsuits, it seems to me the lady had a legitimate complaint. If she had never pursued action many more people would have suffered burns needlessly, she went to court to fight for a change that McDonald's should have made on their own when they knew how many people had suffered burns from the temperature they used to serve their coffee at.
 
http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000002507537/scalded-by-coffee-then-news-media.html

Maybe we should stop using that case as the example of frivolous lawsuits, it seems to me the lady had a legitimate complaint. If she had never pursued action many more people would have suffered burns needlessly, she went to court to fight for a change that McDonald's should have made on their own when they knew how many people had suffered burns from the temperature they used to serve their coffee at.

Also, at the end of the day she was not awarded "millions" of dollars.
 
Would Canadian law award someone millions of dollars for spilling to coffee on herself holding the fast food company responsible? Sometimes the laws needs t catch up to he times. Interesting that the plaintive seem happier than you.
Please know the facts of the case.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ruth.html?offset=100&max=100#comment-40289397

http://www.lectlaw.com/files/cur78.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald's_Restaurants

The nearly 700 other complaints McDonalds had prior to this, means that they were in legal terms "on notice," in other words they couldn't argue 'but we didn't know' because they did know.
 
Please buy our cold coffee. We know you like it very hot but we are afraid you may hurt yourself.
 
http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000002507537/scalded-by-coffee-then-news-media.html

Maybe we should stop using that case as the example of frivolous lawsuits, it seems to me the lady had a legitimate complaint. If she had never pursued action many more people would have suffered burns needlessly, she went to court to fight for a change that McDonald's should have made on their own when they knew how many people had suffered burns from the temperature they used to serve their coffee at.

I always thought that such awards were ridiculously high for what seems like a common sense issue.

Warnings on step ladders, etc. where a potential danger is not so evident is a great idea or reminder for consumer protection, but ridiculously high awards just raise our insurance premiums.
 
Please buy our cold coffee. We know you like it very hot but we are afraid you may hurt yourself.
Yes have our extremely hot coffee 17 C hotter than the typical cup of coffee and which will give you a third degree scald in 15 seconds.
 
Please know the facts of the case.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...ruth.html?offset=100&max=100#comment-40289397

http://www.lectlaw.com/files/cur78.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liebeck_v._McDonald's_Restaurants

The nearly 700 other complaints McDonalds had prior to this, means that they were in legal terms "on notice," in other words they couldn't argue 'but we didn't know' because they did know.

Did McDonnalds ever say they didn't know? That would be stupid. when you buy hot coffee you have to be careful. Not sure she was.

I do stand corrected on the amount though. Sad to hear of the abuse she and her daughter got after. People can be so childish and vicious.
 
http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000002507537/scalded-by-coffee-then-news-media.html

Maybe we should stop using that case as the example of frivolous lawsuits, it seems to me the lady had a legitimate complaint. If she had never pursued action many more people would have suffered burns needlessly, she went to court to fight for a change that McDonald's should have made on their own when they knew how many people had suffered burns from the temperature they used to serve their coffee at.

Agreed.... I will also add:

* that Mc D's had a policy then of free refills.... so they served their coffee intentionally at an undrinkable temperature, to reduce the number of free coffee's they'd have to give out.
* They did not put cream and sugar in the coffee..... rather, they handed you the cup, and cream and sugar separately. That forces you to open the coffee in your car and fix it yourself.
* Cup holders were not standard on cars then, hers did not have one. Most of us would put it between our legs to steady it to remove the lid.
* She was a passenger in the car.... and the car was parked.


And most importantly.....
* Originally she only asked that Mc D's pay for the Medical bills, which included 3 skin graphs. Yes.... the injury required 3 skin graphs. Mc D's offered her $700, which did not cover her medical bills.

When your take out order gives you injuries that require 3 skin graphs, it ceases to fit in the definition of frivolous.

I'd have to agree with Joe Pesci..... "They fuck you at the drive through!"

Edit: This didn't happen because a 15 yr old employee was lazy, or not trained correctly. This was the national coffee serving policy. They had received 700 complaints of previous burns ranging from moderate to serious. Corporate Mc D's knew, or should have known that this product could seriously hurt people. Could have been a child hitting it in their restaurant (kids n Mc D's.... as if!). Old man dropping the cup on his lap.... or an old lady trying to put her cream and sugar in it... in the car.
 
.... and Bell sucks. Should have been a bigger fine.


Cheers!
 
Did McDonnalds ever say they didn't know? That would be stupid. when you buy hot coffee you have to be careful.
So if you admit that they knew, what would be your defence for serving coffee 17 C hotter than the standard cup of coffee and indeed so hot that in only 15 seconds it can cause a third degree burn requiring skin grafts?

Pure and simple when you know the facts of the case, McDonald's conduct was outrageous!