BBQ : Gas vs. charcoal

Ceiling Cat

Well-known member
Feb 25, 2009
30,276
2,688
113
I use to use a gas BBQ, but I found it dried the meat if you do not use the BBQ properly.
Now I am a charcoal guy with a twist. I pan fry the meat till it is almost done, then I put it over a charcoal BBQ fo a minute or two a side. You get perfectly done meat that is not dried out, with a slight charcoal smoke flavor. ( Add hickory or other woods if you like ) The quick charcoal grilling drips any excess oil off the meat. Are you a gas or charcoal guy?
 
Last edited:
Actually, I'm a pellet guy. Bought a Traeger about 2 years ago out of necessity... to save my manly honour since the wife is better on the gas grill than I. Best investment I ever made. Everything comes off the grill better, with the exception of steak. Can't get it high enough in temperature for the sear. But the ribs are always fall off the bone perfect. And it's easy to use, which helps an idiot like me. Currently looking into another pellet grill called the Louisiana. Evidently you can get high enough temperature to sear. Anyone heard anything?
 
I use to use a gas BBQ, but I found it dried the meat if you do not use the BBQ properly.
Now I am a charcoal guy with a twist. I pan fry the meat till it is almost done, then I put it over a charcoal BBQ fo a minute or two a side. You get perfectly done meat that is not dried out, with a slight charcoal smoke flavor. ( Add hickory or other woods if you like ) The quick charcoal grilling drips any excess oil off the meat. Are you a gas or charcoal guy?

That is the silliest BBQ technique I have ever heard. Your joking right?
 
You know that charcoal and gas dries the meat, pan fried meat retains the moisture. The quick charcoal grilling removes the oil and gives the meat a smokey and charcoal aroma.
 
I use charcoal on a ceramic BBQ. If you want your meat moist, there isn't any better way to do it. Whether you want to sear at high heat or cook low and slow, it does it all. Popular brand names are Grill Dome and the Big Green Egg. Do a search, they're refined versions of ancient Japanese ovens.
 
Actually I use both..sometimes simultaneously.
Get yourself a Napolean BBQ, which is a gas BBQ with optional charcoal trays.

You CC, are doing it completely backwards
You want to sear the meat over the red-hot charcoal, to seal in the juices.
Then move the meat to the gas or lower heat area to finish cooking.

Gas BBQs can dry the meat if they do not get hot enough...and most don't get hot enough.
 
You know that charcoal and gas dries the meat, pan fried meat retains the moisture. The quick charcoal grilling removes the oil and gives the meat a smokey and charcoal aroma.

So every restaurant is doing it wrong and your doing it right. It's not the BBQ drying out the meat it's the guy who doesn't know how to cook that's the problem. Perhaps some cooking lessons would help.
 
All I can say is try it if you do not believe me. You can sear meat in a pan with oil. You have to put the meat over the charcoal when it is almost done but not quit. The oil drip off the meat, and the charcoal gives it a charcoal taste.
 
I use a Weber natural gas grill - there's a world of difference between it and the crap propane grills I used to buy. Searing, maintaining juices, no problem. CC - good luck with your technique. I'll stick with the tried and true.

I'll google the pellet grill technique. Sounds interesting.
 
Charcoal all the way. I've never bothered with propane or natural gas. If you're going to barbeque, then barbeque. Don't care how fancy a propane or NG barbeque is, it's not the same.

I even switched from brickettes to lump charcoal and it tastes noticeably better.

I have a Weber Charcoal barbeque that has this propane flane thrower in the bottom. You use it to light the charcoal, then turn off the propane once it's going. Works like a charm.
 
I use a Pellet BBQ and it is an amazing BBQ. The flavor is great and the BBQ is very user friendly. Low mess easy cleanup.
 
All I can say is try it if you do not believe me. You can sear meat in a pan with oil. You have to put the meat over the charcoal when it is almost done but not quit. The oil drip off the meat, and the charcoal gives it a charcoal taste.

It must be quite a show when you cook steaks. Start up the charcoal BBQ then go inside and cook the steaks on the stove. The oil would drip off the steaks if they sat on a rack in the stove. The steaks can't be on long enough to absorb any smoke flavor.

You should go and take a BBQ course at: http://www.divaq.ca

She has won many BBQ awards and I have heard from friends the course is great. It's 75 bucks.
 
You CC, are doing it completely backwards
You want to sear the meat over the red-hot charcoal, to seal in the juices.
Then move the meat to the gas or lower heat area to finish cooking.

Gas BBQs can dry the meat if they do not get hot enough...and most don't get hot enough.

I agree. This is exactly how I cook on the deck, and it works great for me.

R2R
 
It must be quite a show when you cook steaks. Start up the charcoal BBQ then go inside and cook the steaks on the stove. The oil would drip off the steaks if they sat on a rack in the stove. The steaks can't be on long enough to absorb any smoke flavor.

You should go and take a BBQ course at: http://www.divaq.ca

She has won many BBQ awards and I have heard from friends the course is great. It's 75 bucks.

I have done it myself, you use the charcoal heat to fry the steaks. When you slap the steaks on the charcoal grill the oil dripping off the steak and jitting the coals gives you a lot of smokey flavor.
 
I use to use a gas BBQ, but I found it dried the meat if you do not use the BBQ properly. ...

Why don't you just use the BBQ properly then?
 
You know that charcoal and gas dries the meat, pan fried meat retains the moisture. The quick charcoal grilling removes the oil and gives the meat a smokey and charcoal aroma.


I don't know this at all. Frying pans are a dry heat. Charcoal and especially gas generate a lot of H2O during combustion. They are moist heat.

If you sear your steaks quickly on a very hot BBQ grill you will not have a drying out problem. If you are drying out your meat you are doing some combination of buying the wrong cut/quality, cooking too long or too slowly. If you like the taste of real wood smoke but don't like the hassle of charcoal you can put wood chips in the BBQ or in a firebox under the grill and over the burner.
 
I thought this was a charcoal vs gas poll... not a technique critique, but anyways..

Charcoal rocks for getting hot enough to sear the steaks as they hit the grill. Gas BBQ's are usually limited to 40,000 BTU's over the cooking area, the result of that is a larger cooking arewa actually has a lower BTU / square inch ratio. Key to searing a steak on a gas BBQ is leaving the lid down and pre-heating, that raises the temperature of the grilling bars to the point where they sear the meat as it hits the grill ( that`s why cast iron grills sear the best, like a Webber, as opposed to a ceramic coated rod type, the mass of the cast iron holds enough thermal energy to sear).

Pre searing the steaks is an acceptable method if you`re trying to seal a thinner cut of meat, but that`s where the side burner comes into play, especially if you`re cooking more than just steaks and can`t drop the lid and pre heat the grills. I`ve found the best method for a pre sear is to use the side burner to heat a lightly oiled pan until it just starts to smoke, and then give each side of the steak about five seconds of contact time and then onto the grill... NOT pre cook it until almost donte and then finish it... lol...
 
The other bennefit to Charcoal that no-one has mentioned is that it slows you down.

Unlike gas which fires right up and away you go, Charcoal forces you to wait. You light you fire, you pull out a chair, you read the paper, shoot the shit with the neighbour, look around the yard, maybe get head from the old lady, whatever. When the coals turn white, you cook. It is the order of things.

In our busy electronically wired email world, Charcoal takes us back to a more simple time. Man, fire, food.

Real men use charcoal.