Basement Drain Backup...

mookie

Member
Mar 16, 2005
31
0
6
We had quite a bit of rain in the GTA last night, and I found that our basement drains had backed up a bit... say a good 4' diameter of standing water. It eventually drained, and was left soaking up the wet carpet, drying the floor etc. Not too big a deal.

Unfortunately, I tossed all the wet rags/towels/sheets etc. into the washer last night....and I wake up this morning to a much bigger mess. I've now got probably 12'-15' dia. pool of water about a good 2inches deep at the drain etc. Obviously now, all the water from the washing just ended up in my basement. The carpets a write-off, it's soaking through stored items.. it's a disaster (relatively speaking).

In this scenario, is it still covered under insurance?!
 
We had quite a bit of rain in the GTA last night, and I found that our basement drains had backed up a bit... say a good 4' diameter of standing water. It eventually drained, and was left soaking up the wet carpet, drying the floor etc. Not too big a deal.

Unfortunately, I tossed all the wet rags/towels/sheets etc. into the washer last night....and I wake up this morning to a much bigger mess. I've now got probably 12'-15' dia. pool of water about a good 2inches deep at the drain etc. Obviously now, all the water from the washing just ended up in my basement. The carpets a write-off, it's soaking through stored items.. it's a disaster (relatively speaking).

In this scenario, is it still covered under insurance?!

Your insurance will cover it.
 
Your insurance will NOT always cover it.

You have to have the sewer back up rider on your policy and even then, they will only cover up to 50 grand in damage. (Which is peanuts if your drywall and appliances get wet.)

The floor drain in your basement is connected to the Sanitary Drain in the house. The Sanitary Drain in your house is connected to the Sanitary Sewer in the street. The fact that the Sanitary sewer is back flowing into your house is very unusual. It would mean that where you live has a "Combined Sewer".

Normally Storm Sewers (those sewers that pick up rainfall from the catch basins in the street, or perhaps rain water leaders) are SEPARATE from the Sainitary Sewer (Toilet, sinks, showers, floor drains, etc.) The logic is that when it rains, you do not experience exactly what you believe you experienced and also so as not to overwhelm the municiple sewage treatment plants.

Combined Sewers are the "old fashioned" way of doing it and what it means is that sanitary and storm effluent is "combined" in one sewer. You usually only see combined sewers in old neighbourhoods - like Bathurst area, Spadina, anything built before 1920. There are some combined systems up to about 1950 / 1960, but by 1960 they would have been phased out for sure.

So, do you you live in an old area??

If not, you have a blocked sewer in your house and not a backflow issue. Then you need Roto Rooter or similar to come and snake your drain and clean out roots, or check for a cave-in, etc. (with a camera).

In either case however, blocked sewer or combined sewer backflowing into your house - it's shit (i.e. feces) that flooded into your house. Do you really want to wash that????
 
If the water is indeed a backflow issue from a combined sewer (you could call the city to confirm that indeed you have a combined sewer on your street), then the issue is going to happen again.

You need a backflow preventor to be installed.

If not for the main sanitary drain in your house, then for the floor drain(s) at the least. (Keeping in mind that effluent can rise out of a basement shower drain, a basement toilet, or in really bad cases - basement sinks.)

Here you go.

http://www.backwater-valves.com/

http://joneakes.com/cgi-bin/getdetailscals.cgi?id=2071
 
Not as far as I am aware.

They have to be the type where the door in the unit is laying flat (i.e. open) and will only close when the water backs up. (They used to be the kind that were closed in one direction and the water running through the drain would open the door.)

They also have to be installed so that you can get at them (access opening in the floor) to be able to clean them every year or so.
 
If you haven't already done so, you may want to rearrange your eavestroughs so that rain water flows on to your front and back yards instead of into your house drain.
 
If you haven't already done so, you may want to rearrange your eavestroughs so that rain water flows on to your front and back yards instead of into your house drain.

The likely cause if you are in an older area of Toronto is from the combined sewers which overflow... if this is the case you will not benefit at all from disconnecting your eavestroughs from the downspouts that go into the municipal drains. In fact, if you do not have good site drainage you could cause your foundation to leak...

The industry best practice is to install a main floor drain backflow preventer as James T Kirk recommended. they are in no way prohibited, and in fact the city requires them to obtain building permits for certain areas of the city. In some parts of the City like Yonge and Sheppard where they have had ongoing issues that the city cannot yet fix the city pays for clean up under some circumstances... feel free to contact "water, waste water" at the city to enquire.

On the subject of downspouts, the city may still offer an incentive to owners to disconnect their downspouts from the municipal drains, but they must be properly sealed, and you would then need to properly deal with the run-off from your roof, which on many properties in older toronto is not possible...
 
We had quite a bit of rain in the GTA last night, and I found that our basement drains had backed up a bit... say a good 4' diameter of standing water. It eventually drained, and was left soaking up the wet carpet, drying the floor etc. Not too big a deal.

Unfortunately, I tossed all the wet rags/towels/sheets etc. into the washer last night....and I wake up this morning to a much bigger mess. I've now got probably 12'-15' dia. pool of water about a good 2inches deep at the drain etc. Obviously now, all the water from the washing just ended up in my basement. The carpets a write-off, it's soaking through stored items.. it's a disaster (relatively speaking).

In this scenario, is it still covered under insurance?!

Dunno about the insurance... you'd have to call... might be an issue with the fact you had a backup, then ran the washer w/o finding out what the problem was.

On to the problem tho'

Since you didn't complain about sewage backing up into your house (it would smell quite bad) I suspect the problem is not from the city sewers backing up into your house.

1) Do your eavestroughs drain into your house drain? Bad idea... all the gravel from your shingles ends up in your drains
2) Is there any trees near where the drains run.... the roots of a tree can extend 50% farther than the diameter of the tree's branches. and roots love sewer pipes... especially the old clay ones.
3) Do you live in an older home?
4) has there been construction around your property?
5) are the ladies in the house disposing of their hygene products down the toilet? (Sewer cleaners refer to these as "white rats" and say they do a wonderful job of blocking pipes.)

You definitely should invest in having someone come out and look at your pipes. Most good companies have the means to send a camera down so you can see exactly what is going on. I'm guessing your insurance company will insist on this.
 
Last edited:
Since you didn't complain about sewage backing up into your house (it would smell quite bad) I suspect the problem is not from the city sewers backing up into your house.

Sorry to disagree, but the vast majority of the times when the sewers back up under strom conditions the rain water dilutes things so much you do not notice smells from the waste and in older parts of toronto it is the number one cause of flooding. The biggest indicator of cause here is the conditions during the back up which was sustained late winter rains,... frozen ground will not absorb rainwater creating high levels of run off and sewer back ups.
 
Last edited:
Sorry to disagree, but the vast majority of the times when the sewers back up under strom conditions the rain water dilutes things so much you do not notice smells from the waste and in older parts of toronto it is the number one cause of flooding. The biggest indicator of cause here is the conditions during the back up which was sustained late winter rains,... frozen ground will not absorb rainwater creating high levels of run off and sewer back ups.

You raise valid points. Fortunately I don't have excessive experience with sewer backups. The other reason I suspect it may be a problem with his drain and not the city lines is that the original flood went down, yet when he did the laundry it flooded back up again.....

Okay another question for the OP... so have you talked to your neighbours to see if they had any problems at the same time?
 
A possibility to be sure.... not sure how many of those would still be kicking around. No I was going along with the posters who are favouring a city sewer main backup. If that were the case I doubt the OP would be the only one with flooding problems that night.
 
Fellas,
Thanks for all the input. Just a few answers just to fill in the blanks:
- I do live in an older mature neighbourhood, but am not sure whether the area is a Combined Sewer or separate
- my eaves do not tie into the storm, but rather drain out to the surface and away from the home
- I am looking at installing a backflow preventer for the main line (i was told to expect a cost of $2500 to install by a contractor)
- my neighbours were not affected as far as I can tell... and that makes sense from what was found

On to the situation.. I brought in a plumber to snake the basement drain and allow the water to drain away. Upon popping off the drain and valve device the back pressure forced the nasty water up.. As previously posted by Hesitant, the rain likely diluted any smell or appearance of sewage, but once the rubber valve plug thing was removed we were clearly ankle high in shitty water. Anyways, the plumber cleared it, sent a camera down etc. found a 10' section of pipe that had dropped a bit and likely got blocked.

The damage:
- a great deal of content; shit stains on everything. nice.
- about 800sf of carpeted area (including the kids play room & storage area)
- about 450sf of raised subfloor with carpet (my man-cave); with built-in cabinets that will have to come out to remove subflooring
- all the drywall has been cut back (up 3')
- all the content will be documented for claims

Got in touch with Insurance today to confirm that it is covered, but I'm really NOT happy with my deductible. Obviously no one to blame but myself for not keeping on top of it. Apparently it's based on a percentage. Probably wasn't a big deal when I signed up, but as I continued to do home improvements and the replacement value of the home increased the percentage stayed the same, but deductible crept up (now at $7000)

In speaking with my Insurance Agent, he told me NOT to mention anything about tree roots to the Claims people. He didn't elaborate, and I didn't ask why... but I am curious.

Fortunately, this all happened just as we were vacating the home for some significant renovations on the main floor.

My contractor is adamant that we're not in a neighbourhood with combined sewer... but I can't confirm. They were looking for two Main's (one for Sanitary, one for Storm), but clearly there's only one Main coming into the house.

Thanks again for all your input. I should have checked in earlier....
 
Last edited:
My contractor is adamant that we're not in a neighbourhood with combined sewer... but I can't confirm. They were looking for two Main's (one for Sanitary, one for Storm), but clearly there's only one Main coming into the house.

....

You can call the city.

Or look on the road - is there 1 line of manholes going down the street or 2?
 
Get the drain scoped qiuckly to find out if the issue is yours or the city.
If it's yours it may be on your insurance, you need to check.
If it's the city's problem call them immediately.
 
And while re-decorating is still an open topic: almost anything is better than broadloom for basement floors. Area rugs you can have dried and cleaned, if you must have carpet. But basement floors are waters' last stop on the way to the sewer (from the washer, the overflowing sink upstairs, etc) and the first stop after the sewer. As you know.