Baseball question

champ said:
Hey Johnny,

I already mentioned Valenzuela and the screwball.

You're not such a "ENCYCLOPEDIA" after all.

Look back at your posts, champ, you mentioned Koufax and not Valenzuela. And I never said I was an "ENCYCLOPEDIA".
 
galt said:
ok...i'm going to take a guess at an answer to Big_E's question and i may be way off base here (no pun intended)...but does the acceptance of the lefty lefty match up really only come into play with runners on?

If you pitch inside and bust a batter in around the hands as a lefty you should have a short hopper to first and a potential double play. whereas it's a much longer throw in a rightie rightie situation cause the ball goes down the third base line.

Should you pitch outside, a power hitter may be able to push the ball deep, a lefty batter will push the ball down the third base line this makes the throw to third much easier should a runner try to advance from second on a sac fly. This throw becomes much tougher should a righthhanded batter push the ball out along first base.

I think these two things coupled with a lefty piticher's ability to keep runners at first close makes the lefty pitcher, lefty batter more acceptable than a right handed pitcher, right handed batter.

these are just guesses so flame away

Same-sided batters hit worse in all situations.
 
Gents,

I owe Johnny an apolgy . I took a run at him for the "Pee Wee" comment. Sorry Johnny. I lost my head.

But ... in my second "rant" I mentioned Valenzuela / Candiotti and the screwball.

Doesn't make my "shot" right though.

Won't happen again.
 
Hey Guys,

We have divergant opinions here. Each of them has it's merits.

The data is available to put this to rest. Who wants to put it together.

I think if we analyse the top 100 right handed and top 100 left handed hitters versus their oposites and their like sides we will have our answer.

I still think that the hitter has a tougher time against the opposite and an easier time against the pitcher pitching form their side.

Let's let the facts speak for themselves.
 
I'll post the results if you want. Why limit it to the top 100 hitters, though?

Anyway, I'll post the stats, since I guess they need posting ...... God knows why. You'd think a hundred years of coaches might know what they were doing .......
 
From Bill James:

1. How many players hit better the way they should? Over a period of enough time, in excess of 95% or players will hit better with than against the platoon advantage.

2. How large are the differences? The normal platoon difference (in the period of time studied - from the 1988 Baseball Abstract) was 24 points in batting average, 53 points in slugging percentage and 34 points in on-base percentage.

3. Do power hitters tend to have large platoon differentials? No.

4. Do poor hitters tend to have larger platoon differentials than good hitters? No.

5. Do high-average hitters have smaller platoon advantages than low-average hitters? No.

6. Do players who strike out a lot have large platoon differentials? No.

7. Do players who walk a lot have large platoon splits? Very slightly larger, perhaps.

8. Do young players have larger platoon advantages than older players? No. If anything, the reverse is true.

9. Are there any players who truly do not hit any better, over a period of years, when they have the platoon advantage? There may be a couple (Robin Yount and Juan Samuel, in the '88 study). Virtually every hitter, over time, is better when he has the edge.

"The most important conclusion of the platoon study is that the platoon differential is not a "weakness" peculiar to some types of players, but is simply a condition of the game: almost every hitter and every type of hitter hits better over a period of time with than against the platoon advantage - good hitters, poor hitters, young and old, left and right, high-average hitters and power hitters. Although many people believe that we are "manufacturing" platoon players by not letting left-handers hit against left-handed pitchers, this clearly is not true, as is evident in the fact that the best hitters in the game, who have never been platooned, still universally hit better when facing a pitcher against whom they have an "advantage"."

How's that?
 
To answer the initial question, Big_E, managers focus on both matchups, but there are so many more righty hitters and pitchers available that they end up spending more time trying to get the lefty vs. lefty matchup out there. The righty-righty matchups just happen. Any manager worth his salt will realize that it's the same from both sides of the plate - that is, the advantage of the righty-righty matchup is the same as the lefty-lefty one.
 
champ said:
Gents,

I owe Johnny an apolgy . I took a run at him for the "Pee Wee" comment. Sorry Johnny. I lost my head.

But ... in my second "rant" I mentioned Valenzuela / Candiotti and the screwball.

Doesn't make my "shot" right though.

Won't happen again.

It's cool, no harm done.
 
I hope everything's clear about the platoon advantage, now, and we can move on from taking shots to looking at the facts.