Baseball playoff races

kirmit129 said:
Don't quote me on this coz I'm not sure about Yankee stadium but, at the time of Babe Ruth(and even up to Willie Mays), weren't the outfield fence further from the plate that it is now for all ballparks?

Most of the old ballyards shrank to some degree starting in the twenties, both to make more room for the stands, and because baseball was getting away from small ball since more and more fans wanted home runs. The bottom of the page on the link shows how Yankee Stadium's dimensions changed over time, left center field once being a near impossible to reach 500 feet from home plate.

http://www.baseball-statistics.com/Ballparks/NYY/
 
Ranger68 said:
For sheer baseball ability, I take A-Rod. No question about it.
For intangibles ...... I might take Pujols. Just because I think A-Rod's a dick.

Thanks for the stats-Good to see the comparison. I guess I weight the intangibles more heavily-that's why Pujols would be my choice. I be interested to see their Post Season stats tho. I believe Pujols outclass A-Rod on this one.
 
MLAM said:
Coors smoors...this is what I know:

ok, lets exagerate it a bit. I know that this is nerver going to happen but lets say there's a team that decides to shrink their playing field to 300ft center/250ft letf/250ft right. A player plays 20 seasons with this team. At the end of his career he has: 600HR/3000hits/350average. He never won a championship or made it to the playoffs. Are you going to say: Field dimension smimension... all I know is his stats?
 
MLAM said:
Coors smoors...this is what I know:

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG AVG
1279 4560 924 1535 373 24 271 915 2769 773 622 33 23 .433 .607 .337

...in EIGHT full seasons (because he only played 35 games in his first year)

Here is something else I know:

Born: 08/20/1973

...the guy just turn 32.

And here is the last thing I know:

List of players with 3000 Hits, 500 Home Runs, Career .300 average

Hank Aaron
Wille Mays

That is it.

Helton is more than half way to both 3000 hits and 500 HRs after 9 seasons, and he is only 32 years old.

Barring injury, gambling or steriods, the guy is going to the HOF. he might not get 95% of the vote due to Coors bias, but he is going in, first ballot.


No way, no how. Not first ballot, probably not ever.
You're saying a guy who's never finished higher than FIFTH in the MVP voting will be a first-ballot electee?!
I really doubt that.
The voters understand that Coors is the hitters park to end all hitters parks. People understand about park factors now like they didn't in the past.

Helton is NOT on track for the Hall, IMO. I don't think many of the voters will be fooled, either. The ONLY REASON he hits so well is Coors. Project his away numbers over a career and see what you get.
 
Ranger68 said:
Helton is NOT on track for the Hall, IMO. I don't think many of the voters will be fooled, either. The ONLY REASON he hits so well is Coors. Project his away numbers over a career and see what you get.

Well I think that the best way is to have Helton leave Colorato and play elswhere for 5 or 6 years. Even away there is the Coors field factor. A pitcher will not think in terms of Coors field numbers. He will think: "This guy bats 372 and then 336, hits 42HR and then 49HR, had 59 doubles and then 54 doubles, batted 146 runs in and then batted 147 runs in. I really have to be careful with him!" Next thing you know, he either walks him or throws him a hanging changeup trying to make the perfect pitch.
 
a gem by Oswalt, Lidge must feel relieved...turning point was the non-tag, but its over...

so White Sox/Astros, who ya got? I think they are 2 evenly matched teams, in almost every regard, it goes at least 6, but I aint predicting.

oddly enough, 3 starting pitchers for both teams used to be Yankees! :eek:
 
the_big_E said:
oddly enough, 3 starting pitchers for both teams used to be Yankees! :eek:

Yeah, and the big Achilles heel for the Yankees for the past few seasons has been their pitching. Sweetly ironic, isn't it?

In retrospect, one could have predicted this Chicago/Houston match-up, because both teams have starting rotations that are just meant for post-season baseball. After last year's WS, I think the Cardinals did all they could to shore up their rotation, but Houston's was just superior. I think the 'Stros have a bit more bullpen depth, and Chicago's bullpen, imo, is still largely untested in post season.
 
I'm saying....

Ranger68 said:
No way, no how. Not first ballot, probably not ever.
You're saying a guy who's never finished higher than FIFTH in the MVP voting will be a first-ballot electee?!
I really doubt that.
The voters understand that Coors is the hitters park to end all hitters parks. People understand about park factors now like they didn't in the past.

Helton is NOT on track for the Hall, IMO. I don't think many of the voters will be fooled, either. The ONLY REASON he hits so well is Coors. Project his away numbers over a career and see what you get.

1) He has probably 50% of his career left to go. If the Rockies ever put together a contending playoff team that can challenge for a World Series, he will get more MVP votes. MVP tends to be a factor of playing on a winning team (not always) or playing in a media center outlet. The single exception to this that comes to mind was A-Rod in Texas...and frankly, A-Rod might be the ONLY guy in baseball whose media presence is bigger than the market he is playing in, so it didn't matter that he was playing for a lousy time in (relatively) obscure Dallas.

2) So you are telling me there is no one in the HOF who has never fihished higher than 5 in an MVP vote? Wade Boggs have any MVPs? (Ok...I just looked..he once finished FOURTH, despite playing for a consistently winning team in the NE US Media Corridor...and he went in FIRST BALLOT with over 90% of the vote, if I recall correctly)

There is also THIS:

Black Ink: Batting - 16 (138) (Average HOFer ~ 27)
Gray Ink: Batting - 133 (126) (Average HOFer ~ 144)
HOF Standards: Batting - 41.0 (134) (Average HOFer ~ 50)
HOF Monitor: Batting - 158.0 (65) (Likely HOFer > 100)

Remember, we are talking about a guy who is perhaps half done in his career. He is more than half way to each of the HOF bench marks, with 9 to 10 seasons left to go.

Yes damn it, I'm saying that if Todd Helton continues to be Todd Helton, he is going into the HOF. No way on EARTH they keep out a guy with either 3000 hits or 500 home runs, and he is on pace for BOTH.

Not that I don't worship your baseball knowledge otherwise... :D
 
Last edited:
Nope...

kirmit129 said:
ok, lets exagerate it a bit. I know that this is nerver going to happen but lets say there's a team that decides to shrink their playing field to 300ft center/250ft letf/250ft right. A player plays 20 seasons with this team. At the end of his career he has: 600HR/3000hits/350average. He never won a championship or made it to the playoffs. Are you going to say: Field dimension smimension... all I know is his stats?

...but I don't think the Coors factor, while real, is THAT exaggerated.

Remember, a player plays HALF his games somewhere else.

So, what is the line you ask? I think natural selection prevails...no one would build a park like you describe because their own pitching would get killed as well. The builders of Coors didn't INTEND for it to be a hitters paradise...it just ended up that way.
 
i did some crude math....

Ranger68 said:
Coors helps out batting average IMMENSELY.

Helton, 2005: Home .353; Away .287.
Helton, 2004: Home .368; Away .326.
Helton, 2003: Home .391; Away .324.
Helton, 2002: Home .378; Away .281.
Helton, 2001: Home .384; Away .286.

Those are differences of 66, 42, 67, 97, and 98 points.

...and based on this it looks like Helton could be a career .300 hitter ON THE ROAD.

Now, if you also tell me that his road stats put him on a pace to hit, lets say,...200 HRs for his career....that would make him a .300 Avg / 400 HR guy, regardless of the park he is playing in. Those would be HOF stats my friend...
 
MLAM said:
...and based on this it looks like Helton could be a career .300 hitter ON THE ROAD.

Now, if you also tell me that his road stats put him on a pace to hit, lets say,...200 HRs for his career....that would make him a .300 Avg / 400 HR guy, regardless of the park he is playing in. Those would be HOF stats my friend...

So how come Andre Dawson is not in the HOF? 279 Avg/ 438HR/ 314 Stolen bases/ 1 MVP/ Finished second twice for MVP/ 8 Gold gloves/ Led the league twice in total bases. If it weren't for injuries problems in his prime and at the end of his career, I'm sure that he'll be a 400HR/400SB guy.
 
First...

kirmit129 said:
So how come Andre Dawson is not in the HOF? 279 Avg/ 438HR/ 314 Stolen bases/ 1 MVP/ Finished second twice for MVP/ 8 Gold gloves/ Led the league twice in total bases. If it weren't for injuries problems in his prime and at the end of his career, I'm sure that he'll be a 400HR/400SB guy.

Andre Dawson SHOULD be in the HOF. See previous rants from me on this.

2nd - .279 is not .300.

As previously posted, there are only 12 people with career averages over .300 and more than 400 home runs. Of those retired (8), every one of them is in the HOF. Of those not yet retired (4), 2 are locks, another is a much more than likely, and the fourth will probbaly make it despite spending most of his career as a DH. (See previous post in this thread).

3000. 500. .300/400. Those are the magic numbers. NO ONE (eligable) to date with one of those numbers is not in the hall, and the ONLY ones in doubt (currently) have been tripped up by gambling or steriods.
 
kirmit129 said:
Even away there is the Coors field factor. A pitcher will not think in terms of Coors field numbers. He will think: "This guy bats 372 and then 336, hits 42HR and then 49HR, had 59 doubles and then 54 doubles, batted 146 runs in and then batted 147 runs in. I really have to be careful with him!" Next thing you know, he either walks him or throws him a hanging changeup trying to make the perfect pitch.

But his numbers away from Coors don't support that hypothesis very strongly.
 
the_big_E said:
a gem by Oswalt, Lidge must feel relieved...turning point was the non-tag, but its over...

so White Sox/Astros, who ya got? I think they are 2 evenly matched teams, in almost every regard, it goes at least 6, but I aint predicting.

oddly enough, 3 starting pitchers for both teams used to be Yankees! :eek:

Both team have solid pitching. The ChiSox were better for longer this year.
I'll have to look hard at the teams.
 
MLAM said:
1) He has probably 50% of his career left to go. If the Rockies ever put together a contending playoff team that can challenge for a World Series, he will get more MVP votes. MVP tends to be a factor of playing on a winning team (not always) or playing in a media center outlet. The single exception to this that comes to mind was A-Rod in Texas...and frankly, A-Rod might be the ONLY guy in baseball whose media presence is bigger than the market he is playing in, so it didn't matter that he was playing for a lousy time in (relatively) obscure Dallas.

No, there are lots of exceptions.

MLAM said:
2) So you are telling me there is no one in the HOF who has never fihished higher than 5 in an MVP vote? Wade Boggs have any MVPs? (Ok...I just looked..he once finished FOURTH, despite playing for a consistently winning team in the NE US Media Corridor...and he went in FIRST BALLOT with over 90% of the vote, if I recall correctly)

Well, if you haven't finished very high in the MVP voting, you're not going to be a first-ballot electee unless you've got a lot of league-leading totals. Boggs led the league in BATTING AVERAGE five times. That's a big one. Huge.
Helton has led the league in average once and RBI once.
If he wants to be a first-ballot electee, he's got a long ways to go, ESPECIALLY since his numbers will be taken with a LARGE GRAIN OF SALT by MANY voters.

(Oh, and playing in "the media centers" actually HURTS MVP voting, and voting for all awards. Bill James studied this a decade ago.)

MLAM said:
There is also THIS:

Black Ink: Batting - 16 (138) (Average HOFer ~ 27)
Gray Ink: Batting - 133 (126) (Average HOFer ~ 144)
HOF Standards: Batting - 41.0 (134) (Average HOFer ~ 50)
HOF Monitor: Batting - 158.0 (65) (Likely HOFer > 100)

Yeah, I've looked. None of these numbers account for park factor, which despite your protestations, have most certainly affected MVP voting to this point, and will affect his chances - how people look at his numbers. Anyway, at this point, he's not a Hall of Famer. He is, according to the Monitor, on track. I think he's NOT because people will account for park factor. I think he's CERTAINLY NOT a first-ballot electee. One look at his career away numbers will tell you that.

MLAM said:
Remember, we are talking about a guy who is perhaps half done in his career. He is more thatn half way to each of the HOF bench marks, with 9 to 10 seasons left to go.

Yes damn it, I'm saying that if Todd Helton continues to be Todd Helton, he is going into the HOF. No way on EARTH they keep out a guy with either 3000 hits or 500 home runs, and he is on pace for BOTH.

I wouldn't put him in, personally, but I think he probably WILL get in - possibly via the Veterans' Committee - let's just say that.
I repeat that he will not and should not be a first-ballot electee.

Are you arguing that he SHOULD get in on the first-ballot, or he WILL get in on the first ballot? There's a difference.
 
MLAM said:
...but I don't think the Coors factor, while real, is THAT exaggerated.

Remember, a player plays HALF his games somewhere else.

So, what is the line you ask? I think natural selection prevails...no one would build a park like you describe because their own pitching would get killed as well. The builders of Coors didn't INTEND for it to be a hitters paradise...it just ended up that way.

There is no way to play baseball in Denver without it being a hitters' paradise. If you build it small, guys will hit ninety homeruns. If you build it big, like they did, guys will hit .350 consistently, and still dong 40.

Look at Helton's away numbers and tell me that Coors is exaggerated. In fact, I'll do it for you. Here are full-season projections of his numbers if he played all his games away from Coors:

2001: .286 BA, .987 OPS, 44 HR, 124 RBI
2002: .281 BA, .875 OPS, 24 HR, 88 RBI
2003: .324 BA, .949 OPS, 20 HR, 90 RBI
2004: .326 BA, .991 OPS, 22 HR, 72 RBI
2005: .287 BA, .871 OPS, 14 HR, 54 RBI
CAR: .297 BA, .915 OPS, 206 HR, 700 RBI, 1328 H

Actual career numbers: .337 BA, 1.040 OPS, 271 HR, 915 RBI, 1535 H

I just don't think that those away numbers are worthy of the Hall of Fame, for a firstbaseman. A weak .300 BA and 400 HR puts him in line with the Orlando Cepeda's and Tony Perez's of the world - that's VC territory. And I'm telling you that voters will likely punish him MORE than he deserves for playing in Coors.

But, time will tell.
 
MLAM said:
Andre Dawson SHOULD be in the HOF. See previous rants from me on this.

2nd - .279 is not .300.

As previously posted, there are only 12 people with career averages over .300 and more than 400 home runs. Of those retired (8), every one of them is in the HOF. Of those not yet retired (4), 2 are locks, another is a much more than likely, and the fourth will probbaly make it despite spending most of his career as a DH. (See previous post in this thread).

3000. 500. .300/400. Those are the magic numbers. NO ONE (eligable) to date with one of those numbers is not in the hall, and the ONLY ones in doubt (currently) have been tripped up by gambling or steriods.

Helton's career average away from Coors isn't .300 - it's .297.
BIG difference.
;)

Coors skews data. People understand this. 500 HR and 300 hits playing sixteen to twenty years in Coors isn't like doing it elsewhere. Period.
 
I'm loving this!!!

No, there are lots of exceptions.

Really? name some (no honest, I'm not being a smart ass - I;m just curious who these guys are...)


(Oh, and playing in "the media centers" actually HURTS MVP voting, and voting for all awards. Bill James studied this a decade ago.)

REALLY! I would have thought otherwise (I think both Sandburg and Dawson can thank their MVP awards to being on WGN), but WTF do I know. That is very interesting, and I have no problem believing Bill james (or you for that matter Ranger - I worship your baeball knowledge)

Are you arguing that he SHOULD get in on the first-ballot, or he WILL get in on the first ballot? There's a difference.

Both.

I'm saying there is NO ONE currently with stats like THIS for their career:

.297-AVG 412-HR 1400-RBI 2650-Hits .915-OPS

...who ISN'T in the HOF, regardless of position. I admit - these stats make him a boderline choice. But, these won't be his stats - these are just the road figures projected for an entire career. He will end up with over 3000 hits, and 500 HRs. And I don't see such a guy not getting 75% of the vote THE FIRST TIME.

But like you said, time will tell.

Now, can I tell you how great it is to find someone who loves baseball as much as me...LOL :D
 
LOL
Baseball's great for debates, isn't it? :D

Time constraints this evening prevent me from properly addressing your last post, but in the words of MacArthur, "I shall return".
 
MLAM said:
He will end up with over 3000 hits, and 500 HRs. And I don't see such a guy not getting 75% of the vote THE FIRST TIME.

I said it before and I'll say it again... if Helton reaches the magic numbers of 3000 hits and/or 500 homers, he gets into the HOF, probably on the first ballot.

I totally understand that parks can bias statistics. But still, how many guys have played in a Rockies' uniform? It's not like every one of them has put up numbers like Helton. The guy can hit. Sure, he gets a boost from playing at Coors, but I think if you can do it for 15-20 years, that counts for something.