Really?
kwong_1978 said:
Given a choice between Pujols or A-Rod to build a team around-Master P gets my vote. By career end he may well be considered the greatest of all. Until then, I'll enjoy and marvel at his exploits.
Damn I thought that HR was going to go through the freakin wall!
Albert Pujols
SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
2001 StL 161 590 112 194 47 4 37 130 69 93 1 3 .329 .403 .610 1.013
2002 StL 157 590 118 185 40 2 34 127 72 69 2 4 .314 .394 .561 .955
2003 StL 157 591 137 212 51 1 43 124 79 65 5 1 .359 .439 .667 1.106
2004 StL 154 592 133 196 51 2 46 123 84 52 5 5 .331 .415 .657 1.072
2005 StL 161 591 129 195 38 2 41 117 97 65 16 2 .330 .430 .609 1.039
Alex Rodriguez
SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
2001 Tex 162 632 133 201 34 1 52 135 75 131 18 3 .318 .399 .622 1.021
2002 Tex 162 624 125 187 27 2 57 142 87 122 9 4 .300 .392 .623 1.015
2003 Tex 161 607 124 181 30 6 47 118 87 126 17 3 .298 .396 .600 .996
2004 NYY 155 601 112 172 24 2 36 106 80 131 28 4 .286 .375 .512 .887
2005 NYY 162 605 124 194 29 1 48 130 91 139 21 6 .321 .421 .610 1.031
The betting stats are close...Pujos appears to be the better hitter for average - a more disciplined hitter. Fewer strikeouts. Rodriguez (perhaps a bit suprisingly) appears to have a small edge regarding power. Both these mofo can hit though. I might give the slight edge to Albert just because he commits fewer outs.
This is the thing however - Albert is a hell of a hitter, but he is also a first baseman. You aren't going to find a better hitting first baseman, but you will find some who can hit pretty damn good (There this guy no one talks about - Todd Helton, who comes to mind. Check out his stats sometime). Albert is a decent fielding first baseman...getting better...but not a Gold Glover. Albert surprised people with his speed this season, but I think people will be watching him from now on. Don't look for 16 steals a year going forward.
A-Rod is a 3rd baseman, and for any other team besides the NYY, he is a shortstop. A GOLD GLOVE winning shortstop (and he might have a Gold Glove coming for his work at 3rd this year). Try finding anyone who plays either of those positions whose numbers look even REMOTELY like those above. A-Rod is a former 40-40 guy who can steal 20+ any season he wants...check out that steal percentage...the guy is +75% successful, even though team know he is a threat.
So...when you are "building a team"...do you take a guy who is the best in the league at his position - but who has peers nearly as good? Do you take a guy who is GREAT at one thing, but average at the other aspects of the game?
Or do you take a guy who has NO PEER at his position - no one even close? A guy who is a true 5 tool player...Hits for average, hits for power, speed on the bases, fields his position, strong arm?
Actually, we already know the answer to this question (kind of). Albert Pujos has never been a free agent, but this guy has been:
Manny Ramirez
SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS
2001 Bos 142 529 93 162 33 2 41 125 81 147 0 1 .306 .405 .609 1.014
2002 Bos 120 436 84 152 31 0 33 107 73 85 0 0 .349 .450 .647 1.097
2003 Bos 154 569 117 185 36 1 37 104 97 94 3 1 .325 .427 .587 1.014
2004 Bos 152 568 108 175 44 0 43 130 82 124 2 4 .308 .397 .613 1.010
2005 Bos 152 554 112 162 30 1 45 144 80 119 1 0 .292 .388 .594 .982
Another example of a fucking hitting machine...who is less than stellar with the glove or on the bases.
So...when he and A-Rod were both on the market, Manny got a shit load of money...an insane amount, thanks to the level of interest teams had in him. He is the 2nd highest paid player in baseball.
But guess who is number one? And guess why?
If I am "building a team", A-Rod is my pick, and you can have anybody else you want after I take him...