Baseball playoff races

A-Rod or Pujols

Given a choice between Pujols or A-Rod to build a team around-Master P gets my vote. By career end he may well be considered the greatest of all. Until then, I'll enjoy and marvel at his exploits.

Damn I thought that HR was going to go through the freakin wall!
 
Pujols is the man A-rod cant even hold his jock. I jumped out of my chair when Albert cranked it . I am sure glad he did so i get to see the Redbirds one more time in Busch stadium. I am sure gonna miss that park. I have had a lot of good times and memories there but my favorite one has got to be The Wizards home run in the 85 playoffs against the dodgers. GO CARDS !
 
MLAM said:
...and it doesn't help that they are heading for St. Louis, where they blew a 3-2 series lead last year.

Meanwhile, my Sox sit and wait - get their pitchers rested and the rotation set.

Go Cards for Game 6...and then I will have to give thought to who I rather see the Sox face. :D
I have always been die hard Redbird fan and a White Sox fan in the AL. IM gonna have to root for the Birds, but if they dont make it, its GO SOX.
 
Really?

kwong_1978 said:
Given a choice between Pujols or A-Rod to build a team around-Master P gets my vote. By career end he may well be considered the greatest of all. Until then, I'll enjoy and marvel at his exploits.

Damn I thought that HR was going to go through the freakin wall!

Albert Pujols

SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS

2001 StL 161 590 112 194 47 4 37 130 69 93 1 3 .329 .403 .610 1.013
2002 StL 157 590 118 185 40 2 34 127 72 69 2 4 .314 .394 .561 .955
2003 StL 157 591 137 212 51 1 43 124 79 65 5 1 .359 .439 .667 1.106
2004 StL 154 592 133 196 51 2 46 123 84 52 5 5 .331 .415 .657 1.072
2005 StL 161 591 129 195 38 2 41 117 97 65 16 2 .330 .430 .609 1.039


Alex Rodriguez

SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS

2001 Tex 162 632 133 201 34 1 52 135 75 131 18 3 .318 .399 .622 1.021
2002 Tex 162 624 125 187 27 2 57 142 87 122 9 4 .300 .392 .623 1.015
2003 Tex 161 607 124 181 30 6 47 118 87 126 17 3 .298 .396 .600 .996
2004 NYY 155 601 112 172 24 2 36 106 80 131 28 4 .286 .375 .512 .887
2005 NYY 162 605 124 194 29 1 48 130 91 139 21 6 .321 .421 .610 1.031

The betting stats are close...Pujos appears to be the better hitter for average - a more disciplined hitter. Fewer strikeouts. Rodriguez (perhaps a bit suprisingly) appears to have a small edge regarding power. Both these mofo can hit though. I might give the slight edge to Albert just because he commits fewer outs.

This is the thing however - Albert is a hell of a hitter, but he is also a first baseman. You aren't going to find a better hitting first baseman, but you will find some who can hit pretty damn good (There this guy no one talks about - Todd Helton, who comes to mind. Check out his stats sometime). Albert is a decent fielding first baseman...getting better...but not a Gold Glover. Albert surprised people with his speed this season, but I think people will be watching him from now on. Don't look for 16 steals a year going forward.

A-Rod is a 3rd baseman, and for any other team besides the NYY, he is a shortstop. A GOLD GLOVE winning shortstop (and he might have a Gold Glove coming for his work at 3rd this year). Try finding anyone who plays either of those positions whose numbers look even REMOTELY like those above. A-Rod is a former 40-40 guy who can steal 20+ any season he wants...check out that steal percentage...the guy is +75% successful, even though team know he is a threat.

So...when you are "building a team"...do you take a guy who is the best in the league at his position - but who has peers nearly as good? Do you take a guy who is GREAT at one thing, but average at the other aspects of the game?

Or do you take a guy who has NO PEER at his position - no one even close? A guy who is a true 5 tool player...Hits for average, hits for power, speed on the bases, fields his position, strong arm?

Actually, we already know the answer to this question (kind of). Albert Pujos has never been a free agent, but this guy has been:

Manny Ramirez

SEASON TEAM G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS

2001 Bos 142 529 93 162 33 2 41 125 81 147 0 1 .306 .405 .609 1.014
2002 Bos 120 436 84 152 31 0 33 107 73 85 0 0 .349 .450 .647 1.097
2003 Bos 154 569 117 185 36 1 37 104 97 94 3 1 .325 .427 .587 1.014
2004 Bos 152 568 108 175 44 0 43 130 82 124 2 4 .308 .397 .613 1.010
2005 Bos 152 554 112 162 30 1 45 144 80 119 1 0 .292 .388 .594 .982

Another example of a fucking hitting machine...who is less than stellar with the glove or on the bases.

So...when he and A-Rod were both on the market, Manny got a shit load of money...an insane amount, thanks to the level of interest teams had in him. He is the 2nd highest paid player in baseball.

But guess who is number one? And guess why?

If I am "building a team", A-Rod is my pick, and you can have anybody else you want after I take him...
 
Last edited:
It's been said and I'll mention it again. Helton spent his entire career in Colorado in the hitter friendly Coors field. Don't get me wrong. I think that he's a terrific player. However, there will always be an interrogation mark besides his name. I will even say that it's also true for Larry Walker. He's a great player. However, one would wonder if he would have won 3 batting titles or even won an MVP if he had played elsewhere.


Colorado had players putting huge numbers(Dante Bichette, Vinny Castilla, Todd Helton, Larry walker, Ellis Burks, Andre Galaraga) but never made it to the playoffs. Look what happens to these players when they leave Coors field. Better yet, look at the pitchers who enter Coors field. They go in full of confidence but leave with their heads down. (Mike Hampton as a good example)


btw, just curious, who thinks that Larry Walker deserves to be in the Hall of fame? Also, who thinks that Todd Helton is a deserving future Hall of Famer?
 
For sheer baseball ability, I take A-Rod. No question about it.
For intangibles ...... I might take Pujols. Just because I think A-Rod's a dick.
But A-Rod's the better player, no question about it. Position matters.

I think Walker probably goes to the Hall, eventually.
Helton MAY BE on track - but he's a tougher call than Walker, because he hasn't played anywhere other than Coors. Walker put up excellent numbers in parks outside of Colorado. Helton hasn't played anywhere else as a home park, and his split stats, naturally, show a DECIDED edge at Coors. The Gold Gloves help, but he's never been very high on the MVP radar, which hurts A LOT.
If I had to guess now, I'd say Walker gets in, but Helton doesn't.
 
Hmmm...

kirmit129 said:
Helton spent his entire career in Colorado in the hitter friendly Coors field. Don't get me wrong. I think that he's a terrific player. However, there will always be an interrogation mark besides his name. I will even say that it's also true for Larry Walker. He's a great player. However, one would wonder if he would have won 3 batting titles or even won an MVP if he had played elsewhere.

btw, just curious, who thinks that Larry Walker deserves to be in the Hall of fame? Also, who thinks that Todd Helton is a deserving future Hall of Famer?

I'm not an expert, and I'd love to hear a couple experts debate it, but I not so sure playing in Coors boosts a guys AVERAGE that much. I'd like to see some home vs. road stats for Helton - I know they are out there, and I know so of you guys who "live in your mom's basement" can dig them up.

Is Larry Walker a HOF player? Damn....its close. He doesn't have any of the "magic" numbers - no 3000 hits (not even close), no 500 HR (not even 400). And he has no World Series heroics or even a ring to help him on the intangables. He is a career .300 hitter though and he does have an MVP award (a lot of good that is doing Andre Dawson however, who SHOULD be there...). But that came at the aforementioned Coors Field. Hmm....

I once did take the time to do a bit of research when we were having the Jim Rice debate, and it turns out Mr. Rice came just a handful of HRs & Basehits short of being one of only a handful of guys with more than 400HRs and a .300+ career batting average. Its a short list - only 12 guys are on it, and all of those who are retired are in the HOF...Aaron, Ruth, Mays, Foxx, Williams, Ott, Gehrig, Musial. Of the remaining guys (Bonds, Frank Thomas, Ramirez, A-Rod), there is no question two of the 4 are going, and Ramirez is probably a lock too. I didn't do the math, but Rice was a career .298 hitter with 382 career HR. Seems to me that if he hits 18 more homers (one per season roughly) and makes 18 fewer outs, he is in the HOF (again, I didn't do the math vis-vie number of additonal hits required to put him over .300).

Larry Walker has a career .313 average and 383 HRs.

I say Larry gets my sympathy (injuries, lousy teams, always played hard), and certainly was a great all around player (speed, glove, great arm) who played hard, he doesn't get my vote unless he has 17 more HRs in him. If I am Lary Walker, I'm playing one more season to make sure...

Insofar as Helton? The guy has +1500 hits in only 9 seasons, and he just turned 32. His career average is over .330 - top 20 all time. His career sluging is over .600 - top TEN all time. Same with his .OBP of .433- top ten all time. Coors or no Coors, when you add his 271 HRs in 9 seasons, this guy is on his way to perhaps being the best all aroud hitter in baseball history since the Ruth / Gerhig era...3000 hits, 500 HR, .300 avg. Now THERE is a fucking short list....Aaron...Ruth...Mays. Period.
 
No need to live in "mom's basement" to get these stats. Just an Internet connection (which everyone on this board has, right? ;) ......) or a decent library. Oh, and the ability to understand math - or, at least, how to subtract two numbers. (I know there are some of you out there who clearly are numbers-challenged. Not talking to you here, MLAM ......)

Coors helps out batting average IMMENSELY.

Helton, 2005: Home .353; Away .287.
Helton, 2004: Home .368; Away .326.
Helton, 2003: Home .391; Away .324.
Helton, 2002: Home .378; Away .281.
Helton, 2001: Home .384; Away .286.

Those are differences of 66, 42, 67, 97, and 98 points.

BTW, MLAM, I agree with your analysis that Pujols is a better hitter than A-Rod, but by a very slim margin. Nice job.
 
Love ya dude...

Ranger68 said:
No need to live in "mom's basement" to get these stats. Just an Internet connection (which everyone on this board has, right? ......) or a decent library. Oh, and the ability to understand math - or, at least, how to subtract two numbers. (I know there are some of you out there who clearly are numbers-challenged. Not talking to you here, MLAM ......)

Coors helps out batting average IMMENSELY.

Helton, 2005: Home .353; Away .287.
Helton, 2004: Home .368; Away .326.
Helton, 2003: Home .391; Away .324.
Helton, 2002: Home .378; Away .281.
Helton, 2001: Home .384; Away .286.

Those are differences of 66, 42, 67, 97, and 98 points.

BTW, MLAM, I agree with your analysis that Pujols is a better hitter than A-Rod, but by a very slim margin. Nice job.

..but I knew Helton was a better hitter at home (the splits are easy to find). LOTS of guys, some in the HOF, are better hitters at home for average. Getting some pussy the night before does wonders for a guy....LOL :D

My question was...OVERALL...how much better do ALL players hit for average at Coors. Before we can say that Coors is a distorter of batting averages, we need to see the stats, for home AND away players. Because EVERYBODY hits better at home, and just because a guy hits LOTS better, doesn't mean it is the park. It could be those blow jobs....

And before anybody counter posts, we are talking BATTING AVERAGE here. We all know Coors is a launching pad for homers...but do guys actually hit significantly better @ Coors than they would be expected to at any home park?
 
Ah.

Here ya go. :)

Coors Field, 2005: Hit-factor 1.270
Coors Field, 2004: Hit-factor 1.240
Coors Field, 2003: Hit-factor 1.232

This is a SERIOUS hitters' park. LOL
 
Don't forget that Hitters confidence is boosted at Coors field as well. Hence, on the road, it helps. I can remember a few players that had a decent year after leaving Coors field and then slowly declined. Vice versa, I remember pitchers having a year or two of trouble after leaving Coords field.


Ranger, can you find Mike Hampton's pitching statistics at home and his statistics away when he pitched for Colorado?
 
It's an interesting debate, because obviously, ballpark effects have always existed, and my thought on it is, if a player amasses enough numbers, the HOF voters will dismiss ballpark effects. For example, Mel Ott hit 511 homers lifetime, playing in the Polo Grounds for his entire career, with its extremely short right field porch. But he hit the magic 500, so he's been a HOF'er since 1951. Tell me Babe Ruth didn't get some assistance playing in Yankee Stadium. That short right field porch was built with Ruth in mind. But clearly, Ruth hit enough homers, both there and elsewhere, that the notion of ballpark effects is a non-issue.

As far as Larry Walker/Todd Helton HOF debate goes, the 5 players to which Walker is most similar statistically, are Duke Snider, Ellis Burks, Joe DiMaggio, Johnny Mize, and Frank Thomas. Snider, DiMaggio, and Mize are in the Hall, and I think Thomas is a reasonable candidate. The 5 players to which Helton is most similar statistically, through age 31, are Jeff Bagwell, Frank Thomas, Hank Greenberg, Chuck Klein, and Joe DiMaggio. Greenberg, Klein, and DiMaggio are in the Hall and like Thomas, I think Bagwell is a reasonable candidate. This suggests to me that both players have a decent shot at the Hall, although obviously Helton has a few more years left to put up some numbers.
 
kirmit129 said:
Don't forget that Hitters confidence is boosted at Coors field as well. Hence, on the road, it helps. I can remember a few players that had a decent year after leaving Coors field and then slowly declined. Vice versa, I remember pitchers having a year or two of trouble after leaving Coords field.

Ranger, can you find Mike Hampton's pitching statistics at home and his statistics away when he pitched for Colorado?

That would be an interesting study - do hitters tend to do better than you would expect for a few years after *leaving* Coors?

Hampton, 2002: Home 11 GS, 69.2 IP, 7 HR, 35 BB, 36 K, 5.68 ERA, 1.64 WHIP;
Hampton, 2002: Away 19 GS, 109.0 IP, 17 HR, 56 BB, 38 K, 6.44 ERA, 1.88 WHIP

Hampton was wall-to-wall TERRIBLE away from Coors that year, and was pretty bad at home, too - but only about as bad as you'd expect him to be.

Hampton, 2001: Home 15 GS, 93.2 IP, 15 HR, 48 BB, 53 K, 5.77 ERA, 1.70 WHIP
Hampton, 2001: Away 17 GS, 109.1 IP, 16 HR, 37 BB, 69 K, 5.10 ERA, 1.48 WHIP

He also wasn't very good in 2001, but at least he pitched only about as bad on the road as he did at home. By adjusted ERA, he was only a slightly below average pitcher in 2001 - this should tell you how hard it is to pitch in Denver.

His strikeout totals continue to drop, and he's rapidly losing effectiveness as a result. He's always been too wild. It's anyone's guess as to how he'll be when he comes back from his elbow surgery - I wouldn't want to gamble on him. He's always been overpaid anyway.
 
homonger said:
It's an interesting debate, because obviously, ballpark effects have always existed, and my thought on it is, if a player amasses enough numbers, the HOF voters will dismiss ballpark effects. For example, Mel Ott hit 511 homers lifetime, playing in the Polo Grounds for his entire career, with its extremely short right field porch. But he hit the magic 500, so he's been a HOF'er since 1951. Tell me Babe Ruth didn't get some assistance playing in Yankee Stadium. That short right field porch was built with Ruth in mind. But clearly, Ruth hit enough homers, both there and elsewhere, that the notion of ballpark effects is a non-issue.

As far as Larry Walker/Todd Helton HOF debate goes, the 5 players to which Walker is most similar statistically, are Duke Snider, Ellis Burks, Joe DiMaggio, Johnny Mize, and Frank Thomas. Snider, DiMaggio, and Mize are in the Hall, and I think Thomas is a reasonable candidate. The 5 players to which Helton is most similar statistically, through age 31, are Jeff Bagwell, Frank Thomas, Hank Greenberg, Chuck Klein, and Joe DiMaggio. Greenberg, Klein, and DiMaggio are in the Hall and like Thomas, I think Bagwell is a reasonable candidate. This suggests to me that both players have a decent shot at the Hall, although obviously Helton has a few more years left to put up some numbers.


I don't think HoF voters can *totally* exclude park factor, as it has clearly and demonstrably affected MVP voting, which becomes a prime factor in voting trends.

Helton is nowhere NEAR the calibre of the players to which he's most similar - this is one of those cases where similarity scores must be taken with a HUGE grain of salt, as they DON'T account for park effects. Helton, playing his whole career in Coors, certainly has amassed gaudy numbers - hell, look whose company he's in. But, he hasn't finished higher than 5th in the MVP voting. I think the voters know that his numbers are HUGELY inflated playing in Coors, and his lack of performance in MVP voting will not bode well for his being selected to the HoF. If you compared home and road numbers for those "most similar players", I think you'd be shocked. Well, no, you wouldn't. But it would be a pretty stark comparison.

Not to mention, by age 31, Greenberg had won the MVP twice (and finished third twice), Klein had won once (and finished second twice), and Joe Dimaggio had won twice (with a second and a third).

Similarity scores compares career totals with no correction for era or park. It's not reasonable to compare Todd Helton with Joe Dimaggio just because his numbers are monstrously inflated playing in Coors. Nobody else buys it either.
 
homonger said:
Tell me Babe Ruth didn't get some assistance playing in Yankee Stadium. That short right field porch was built with Ruth in mind. But clearly, Ruth hit enough homers, both there and elsewhere, that the notion of ballpark effects is a non-issue.

Don't quote me on this coz I'm not sure about Yankee stadium but, at the time of Babe Ruth(and even up to Willie Mays), weren't the outfield fence further from the plate that it is now for all ballparks?
 
Ranger68 said:
Not to mention, by age 31, Greenberg had won the MVP twice (and finished third twice), Klein had won once (and finished second twice), and Joe Dimaggio had won twice (with a second and a third).

Similarity scores compares career totals with no correction for era or park. It's not reasonable to compare Todd Helton with Joe Dimaggio just because his numbers are monstrously inflated playing in Coors. Nobody else buys it either.

Excellent points. For what it's worth, I did notice that the similarity scores for both Walker and Helton were not exceptionally strong, the players I mentioned just happened to be the most similar.

I totally agree that similarity scores are a very rough tool, and should be used really just for fun (like Bill James' "My Favorite Toy"). I just threw them out there to provide some perspective on the Walker/Helton HOF debate.

However, on the issue of whether or not HOF voters can totally "dismiss" park effects, I remain unconvinced as to how much a voter could deny HOF entry to a player who has amassed gargantuan numbers, even if they did play in a little bandbox of a park. Which is my point about Ott, and to a lesser extent, Ruth. They had enormous numbers, HOF numbers. Maybe voters back then were less sophisticated, but based on the numbers alone, they could not be denied entrance to the Hall. I'm not saying Helton is at that level, but my point is, if he gets to any of the magic numbers, I don't see how he could be denied entry, no matter where he played.
 
Ranger68 said:
That would be an interesting study - do hitters tend to do better than you would expect for a few years after *leaving* Coors?

Hampton, 2002: Home 11 GS, 69.2 IP, 7 HR, 35 BB, 36 K, 5.68 ERA, 1.64 WHIP;
Hampton, 2002: Away 19 GS, 109.0 IP, 17 HR, 56 BB, 38 K, 6.44 ERA, 1.88 WHIP

Hampton was wall-to-wall TERRIBLE away from Coors that year, and was pretty bad at home, too - but only about as bad as you'd expect him to be.

Hampton, 2001: Home 15 GS, 93.2 IP, 15 HR, 48 BB, 53 K, 5.77 ERA, 1.70 WHIP
Hampton, 2001: Away 17 GS, 109.1 IP, 16 HR, 37 BB, 69 K, 5.10 ERA, 1.48 WHIP

He also wasn't very good in 2001, but at least he pitched only about as bad on the road as he did at home. By adjusted ERA, he was only a slightly below average pitcher in 2001 - this should tell you how hard it is to pitch in Denver.

His strikeout totals continue to drop, and he's rapidly losing effectiveness as a result. He's always been too wild. It's anyone's guess as to how he'll be when he comes back from his elbow surgery - I wouldn't want to gamble on him. He's always been overpaid anyway.

I think Hampton was lousy coz he lost his confidence playing in Coors field. Look at his stats after leaving Colorado. Last year was average, the year before was good, but this year he has a more than decent era of 3.50 playing through several injuries.
 
I love exploring Similarity Scores. It's a good predictive tool for future performance.

As I said earlier, I think Walker should get in, but not Helton (projecting forward).

Actually, I wouldn't mind Larry coming here next year to finish off his career. :)
 
kirmit129 said:
I think Hampton was lousy coz he lost his confidence playing in Coors field. Look at his stats after leaving Colorado. Last year was average, the year before was good, but this year he has a more than decent era of 3.50 playing through several injuries.

His strikeout numbers declined before and after the move in a rather steady manner, though. I'd think this was the cause of his (and most pitchers') problems, rather than where he played. Both full years in Atlanta were mediocre at best.

In terms of strikeouts, his numbers, right up to the injury, began declining precipitously - from heading to Coors field, but through all three seasons in Atlanta, and including his last season which was probably fluky. In any case, it wasn't a full sample, so we should take it with a grain of salt. It might have ended up as mediocre as the others.

He's always been overpaid. Badly overpaid.
 
I'm with you...

homonger said:
Excellent points. For what it's worth, I did notice that the similarity scores for both Walker and Helton were not exceptionally strong, the players I mentioned just happened to be the most similar.

I totally agree that similarity scores are a very rough tool, and should be used really just for fun (like Bill James' "My Favorite Toy"). I just threw them out there to provide some perspective on the Walker/Helton HOF debate.

However, on the issue of whether or not HOF voters can totally "dismiss" park effects, I remain unconvinced as to how much a voter could deny HOF entry to a player who has amassed gargantuan numbers, even if they did play in a little bandbox of a park. Which is my point about Ott, and to a lesser extent, Ruth. They had enormous numbers, HOF numbers. Maybe voters back then were less sophisticated, but based on the numbers alone, they could not be denied entrance to the Hall. I'm not saying Helton is at that level, but my point is, if he gets to any of the magic numbers, I don't see how he could be denied entry, no matter where he played.

Coors smoors...this is what I know:

G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI TB BB SO SB CS OBP SLG AVG
1279 4560 924 1535 373 24 271 915 2769 773 622 33 23 .433 .607 .337

...in EIGHT full seasons (because he only played 35 games in his first year)

Here is something else I know:

Born: 08/20/1973

...the guy just turn 32.

And here is the last thing I know:

List of players with 3000 Hits, 500 Home Runs, Career .300 average

Hank Aaron
Wille Mays

That is it.

Helton is more than half way to both 3000 hits and 500 HRs after 9 seasons, and he is only 32 years old.

Barring injury, gambling or steriods, the guy is going to the HOF. he might not get 95% of the vote due to Coors bias, but he is going in, first ballot.