Basa Fish - the Government

Mable

Active member
Sep 20, 2004
1,374
11
38
So, I came across this fish in the market and purchased it. Comes frozen with 2 large fillets in a 400g package. $2.89 for the package. Cheap!! And great. Better than cod, sole, even tastier than halibut. So, I research this and find out that are allegations that it may not be healthy as it comes from Vietnam and might not be properly farmed. I write to the proper department in gov"t and ask the obvious questions regarding safety. I get a 2 page response of impenetrable nonsense and am no further off. All to ask. does anyone else out there have any information in this fish?
 
Sounds like one of those 'Who the Devil knows.'

In the U.K. tests commissioned by the supermarket chains Asda and Tesco found no toxic contaminants. The BBC watchdog confirmed this six years ago https://web.archive.org/web/2011071...hdog/2009/04/a_fish_called_river_cobbler.html The Australian Quarantine and Inspection Service found trace levels of of malachite green, but no other contaminants https://web.archive.org/web/2011042...ion/publications/surveyofchemicalresi3107.cfm

However, on the other hand OceanWise, which is associated with the Vancouver Aquarium, and the Monterey Bay Aquarium list Basa as "red flag/"avoid." However, this does seem to be more an environmental rather than a pollution issue.

That said I only know what I read.
 
I buy it, but I don't eat fish often. Seems to me everything is polluted nowadays, they discovered wild salmon had tape worm in some parts of the pacific.
I think the US catfish farmers made a stink because the market got flooded with cheap catfish, I'm sure some of the stories are made up by shills of the farmers. You can say the same for farmed salmon, many recommend not eating it because of the conditions.
But its good eating, the US catfish seems more firm.
 
Most stores don't label the fish as farmed or wild. I went to an Asian fish market and asked and they said they don't even know ( or did they not understand my question).
 
Ive been eating Basa for years because its cheap and not a bad source of protein. But a friend of mine was in Vietnam and described hot it was farmed and harvested and Ill never touch it again.
 
basa and tilapia are garbage, no proper conditions or testing, and the nutrition is questionable

Why buy foreign mass produced fish when we have our own fish right here at home?
 
Thanks for the information and responses. Looks like I will continue with it unless I find some study that condemns it.

To Mazzi: It is not so much the price, which is terrific, but the fish is so damn tasty and easy to cook with. I made a Moroccan tajine with it the other day and it was out of this world.
 
Why buy foreign mass produced fish when we have our own fish right here at home?
Some of our fish like Atlantic salmon are farmed and not caught in the wild. Also, I would not eat river or lake fish due to more contaminants than ocean fish.
 
The fish market is a scam, once the fish is fillet, the consumer is in the dark. Fish farms abroad allow retail and wholesale places to make good profit as opposed to expense caught fish. A recent study found that 70% of the salmon sold in NYC at the retail level advertised as " Wild Pacific" was from Asian fish farms. Some of the fish came from China but was brought into America as being product of Thailand or Vietnam.
 
The reason farmed seafood is not good for is is because they are crammed into pen where the eat, sleep and shit. The sea framers expect the tides to come in and sweep out the crap, which happens not often enough. The sea creatures in the pens eat their own crap. Some farmed fish are farmed in ponds, which means that the water is on;ly as clean as the crap filters.
 
The reason farmed seafood is not good for is is because they are crammed into pen where the eat, sleep and shit. The sea framers expect the tides to come in and sweep out the crap, which happens not often enough. The sea creatures in the pens eat their own crap. Some farmed fish are farmed in ponds, which means that the water is on;ly as clean as the crap filters.

Lots of people don't realize that some shrimp is also farmed. I try to buy the wild one.
 
The fish market is a scam, once the fish is fillet, the consumer is in the dark. Fish farms abroad allow retail and wholesale places to make good profit as opposed to expense caught fish. A recent study found that 70% of the salmon sold in NYC at the retail level advertised as " Wild Pacific" was from Asian fish farms. Some of the fish came from China but was brought into America as being product of Thailand or Vietnam.

Korea is the only asian country to have salmon farms. Chile also has lots of salmon farms but the quality and the fat content is below the one produced here.