Bands You Just Don't Get


musically i may be off the wall and weird....but i would rather listen to Roy and this song 5 times over than give Strawberry Fields 30 seconds of my time.............hey thats how i roll
 

musically i may be off the wall and weird....but i would rather listen to Roy and this song 5 times over than give Strawberry Fields 30 seconds of my time.............hey thats how i roll
I enjoy oranges more myself, but will enjoy an apple from time to time as well. Wouldn't enjoy a steady diet of either...
 
  • Like
Reactions: ogibowt
How about Art Garfunkel? After he and Paul Simon (musical genius, few can dispute) split up he faded into well deserved obscurity. I never reall7y got The Grateful Dead, either...
Art had some solo hits in the 70s and remained a big star in England. His voice is quite angelic and he sings some of the prettiest S&G songs like April Come She Will, For Emily..., and of course Bridge Over Troubled Water.
The Dead have their moments. They're not really this tripped out band that some folks think they are. The studio albums are more blues, country and folk influenced. AMERICAN BEAUTY is a truly beautiful album.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
The Gabriel Genesis version is pretty boring and meandering but that's 70s Prog Rock for ya. The Gabriel solo stuff did nothing for me either...I really don't enjoy his voice.
The Collins-fronted Genesis is way better ...some truly great pop music there. Phil Collins solo also had some enjoyable hits.
One band I never got was REM. How the hell did they become so popular at one point?
Man, it's funny, but. I'm the polar opposite of you.

REM is fucking amazing, Gabriel has one of the best voices in the business and it hugely talented and creative.

Collins is crap, with banal popy music that bores me to tears. Especially all his sad music. Kill me now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
I don't get Captain Beefheart.
Beefheart was an odd fellow. I/we had difficulty in selecting a genre for his music. Then a fellow classmate from decades go said "Cajun Blues". hmmmm
CB was never my cup of tea, however with the right drugs and the right time and place it may work for you or not.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Robert Mugabe
Genesis with Gabriel is amazing. No, not typical pop music. That’s why it’s great.

Gabriel’s solo stuff I am a massive fan of.

Phil Collins era…. Over played and too commercial. It’s not terrible, but nothing he sings is on any of my playlists.

Rick Beato on his YouTube channel did a random assembly of the top ten songs on Apple and Spotify on separate videos. He has an incredible ear, and can break songs down. Every song, be it pop, country, or Rap, was using the same chord structure. 1, 4, 5, and 6.

(There are 7 chords on a key, and these chords sound sweet. Think of Boston, More than a feeling. Those 4 chords.)

The Beatles had 27 #1’s, and only used that chord structure in one them. I doubt anything Genesis did with Gabriel remotely had revolved on those 4 chords.

Music today is garbage because there is 0 creativity. Record execs just demanding mass consumable hits.

Justin Bieber is actually kicking ass commercially. Should be dead and gone, but there he is. What with Bieberbits, he is still making a friggin great living. Rick Beatto is great.
 
How about Art Garfunkel? After he and Paul Simon (musical genius, few can dispute) split up he faded into well deserved obscurity. I never reall7y got The Grateful Dead, either...
American Beauty is certainly a top 10 all time US rock album. Workingman's Dead has a couple of decent songs.


Or....

Got a wife in Chino, friend, and one in Cherokee/

First one says she got my child, but it don't look like me....

Or...

"She can dance a Cajun rhythm/
Just like a Willys in 4-wheel drive... "
 
The Gabriel Genesis version is pretty boring and meandering but that's 70s Prog Rock for ya. The Gabriel solo stuff did nothing for me either...I really don't enjoy his voice.
The Collins-fronted Genesis is way better ...some truly great pop music there. Phil Collins solo also had some enjoyable hits.
One band I never got was REM. How the hell did they become so popular at one point?
The early albums are pretty good.

 

musically i may be off the wall and weird....but i would rather listen to Roy and this song 5 times over than give Strawberry Fields 30 seconds of my time.............hey thats how i roll

That's amazing, always thought it was a CCR song. First vinyl album I ever bought.

 
  • Like
Reactions: ogibowt
Nearly everything rap or hip-hop......

With the possible exceptions of Eminem and certain comedy covers (on Dr. Demento), most rap is bereft of any artistic merit of any kind.....reminds me of raw manure.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: ptp
Before they shot me up full of Delaudid in the Cardo Ward, I didn't care much for Strawberry Fields Forever either...now it's John Lennon at his most revelatory.


I remember driving my daughter somewhere when she about 10 or 12, and Strawberry Fields came on the radio. I told here to listen carefully to each verse… then after the first 2, I asked her to tell me what they were singing about. This blank stare… slowing turning to a smirk… “dad, I have no idea”.