Genesis with Gabriel is amazing. No, not typical pop music. That’s why it’s great.
Gabriel’s solo stuff I am a massive fan of.
Phil Collins era…. Over played and too commercial. It’s not terrible, but nothing he sings is on any of my playlists.
Rick Beato on his YouTube channel did a random assembly of the top ten songs on Apple and Spotify on separate videos. He has an incredible ear, and can break songs down. Every song, be it pop, country, or Rap, was using the same chord structure. 1, 4, 5, and 6.
(There are 7 chords on a key, and these chords sound sweet. Think of Boston, More than a feeling. Those 4 chords.)
The Beatles had 27 #1’s, and only used that chord structure in one them. I doubt anything Genesis did with Gabriel remotely had revolved on those 4 chords.
Music today is garbage because there is 0 creativity. Record execs just demanding mass consumable hits.