Ban the seal hunt

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Seal hunt is just too hot to handle
Diane Francis, Financial Post
Published: Tuesday, August 04, 2009

The needless slaughter of baby seals in Newfoundland every year is a national embarrassment and disgrace.

Canadian politicians have been incapable of ending this primitive practice -- the largest killing of marine mammals in the world -- even as damage to the country's reputation, some businesses and the image of the 2010 Olympics grows.

Animal-rights activists have elicited condemnations from the U. S. Senate, President Barack Obama and the European Union, which just imposed a ban on seal imports. Ottawa is appealing the ban to the World Trade Organization at a cost of taxpayers of $10-million. This waste to backstop an unjustifiable and puny business of $1-million a year.

The Human Society of the United States, and global affiliates, are now promoting the boycott of all Canadian seafood.

"Why seafood? Because seal hunting is an off-season activity conducted by fishers from Canada's East Coast," reads the Society's website. "They earn a small fraction of their incomes from sealing -- primarily from the sale of seal pelts to European fashion markets. But the vast majority of the sealers' incomes are from commercial fisheries. Canadian seafood exports to the United States contribute US$2.4-billion annually to the Canadian economy -- dwarfing the few million dollars [estimated $1-million this year] provided by the seal hunt. The connection between the commercial fishing industry and the seal hunt in Canada gives consumers all over the world the power to end this cruel and brutal slaughter."

Another group, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA), is targeting the Olympics.

"Every year, the Canadian government allows sealers to beat and skin hundreds of thousands of seals, many of whom are only weeks old. These baby seals are shot or bludgeoned to death. Veterinarians and Fisheries and Oceans Canada officers have found that the young seals' skulls are often not adequately crushed, which can lead to a prolonged death," reads its website.

A year ago, the group approached U. S. Airways to plaster its airplanes with the "Olympic Shame" message. The airline rejected the proposal.

In January, the group unveiled a violent parody of the Vancouver 2010 Inukshuk logo, battering a blood-soaked baby seal. In June, it unveiled a campaign portraying the Vancouver Games mascots -- Miga, Quatchi and Sumi--as savage seal killers.

This week, PETA approached the Vancouver Olympic Committee to buy some of its surplus billboard, noting that it is having difficulty selling advertising space in the Lower Mainland. It pledged to buy $38-million worth of space, but the recession has meant $12-million remains unsold.

This will be rejected by the committee which will become an issue around the world. And it's all unnecessary.

Ottawa should outlaw this slaughter immediately. Canada is not some Third World nation and Newfoundland is now a rich province that can afford to clean up its act. Even abattoirs are required to euthanize painlessly, which makes this abuse intolerable to anyone who understands it.

A poll would reveal strong disapproval in Canada. Canadians should demand a ban against all seal hunting. Politicians should take note.
 
Absolutely disgraceful. I love this country but this is definitely one of the worst points about living here and it is sickening.
 
lawyerman said:
Absolutely disgraceful. I love this country but this is definitely one of the worst points about living here and it is sickening.

And monumentally stupid, as the financial post columnist points out.
 
if only there were such strong global public opposition to things that actually mattered...
-darfur?
-genocide in rwanda?
-10s of thousands of children needlessly dying every day?

they're only seals
 
eu can,t access to hunt these mammals cause their within our 200 mile limit.if the seals were outside of the 200 mile limit eu would not ( in my opion ) have such a ban.they already come here to over fish our waters and get away with it.
 
What's disgraceful is how the GG ate seal meat in Nunavut and made a big show of it ... insinuating the government was supporting the subsistence hunting of inuit peoples and not the commercial hunting by newfies.
 
Excellent point train! The seal hunt wouldn't even be an issue if the dam things weren't so cute. :rolleyes:
 
Animal-rights activists have elicited condemnations from the U. S. Senate, President Barack Obama and the European Union, which just imposed a ban on seal imports. Ottawa is appealing the ban to the World Trade Organization at a cost of taxpayers of $10-million. This waste to backstop an unjustifiable and puny business of $1-million a year.
The Newfoundland government claims the sealing industry is worth about $55 million not $1 million. Even the Humane Society states "revenues from sealing account for less than 1% of the Gross Domestic Product [of Newfoundland]". The 2008 GDP of Newfoundland was $31.458B with 1% of that being $315M. So yes, $55M is less than $315M. Congratulations for the Humane Society for mastering grade one mathematics.

The reason they say "less than 1%" is to make the financial impact of the industry seem insignificant but $55M is far from insignificant to the people in the industry. And just because it is less than 1% of your GDP does not mean it is trivial to just close an entire industry.

A better approach could be to ensure that the hunt is performed humanely and charge back the cost of the regulation to the industry itself. That way the cost of the product will better reflect the "cost to society". Then you let consumers decide if they want to continue to purchase the product.

You could even require that for every pelt they bring in they have to use/sell say 75% of the carcass. If they don't then the quota for the next hunt is adjusted accordingly which would encourage responsible hunting.
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Excellent point train! The seal hunt wouldn't even be an issue if the dam things weren't so cute.
If they looked like lobsters they'd be on restaurant menus.:D

Sealers aren't even allowed to kill the cute white ones, I'm sure for that reason. However, they are allowed to kill them as they start to shed their first coat which is only at 12-14 days old. I don't think they should be allowed to hunt them that young. If they stopped hunting the young, cute ones and hunted more humanely the image of the industry would change dramatically.
 
The end of the seal hunt is a foregone conclusion.

The gov't is simply wasting tax dollars in order to pander to a few Atlantic Candadians (who probably don't even vote anyway.)
 
http://www.boycott-canada.com/what/seafood.htm

Boycott Canadian Fish and Seafood Products
The sealers themselves are, for the most part, fishermen. The main part of their income is from the sale (and export) of fish and seafood products and the UK is an important customer for these products. Whereas income from the seal hunt is insignificant to Canada, the UK imports over £50 million of seafood from Canada each year.

It is the connection between commercial fisheries and the seal hunt and the economics of both industries which make a boycott of Canadian seafood products a logical step in ending the annual hunt. And it is British consumers and businesses that purchase Canadian seafood who have the power to convince the Canadian government and individual fishermen to stop the slaughter.

It is our firm opinion that only outside economic pressure can now help the seals and we have joined together with an international coalition of animal welfare groups to orchestrate a boycott of Canadian fish and seafood products. We are therefore asking the public, retailers and importers in the UK not to buy Canadian seafood and fish products as they are produced by the same people who are killing the seals. A similar campaign run by the HSUS in America has had great success with thousands of individuals and hundreds of stores and businesses pledging to avoid Canadian seafood.

By boycotting Canadian fish and seafood products you send an important message back to those directly involved in the slaughter of the seals.

Tips to help you identify Canadian seafood
Shopping
Read the label
Some products are clearly identified as Canadian by the large maple leaf symbol, but make sure you also read the product information. If in doubt ask the manager or member of staff for the country of origin. Also see our Supermarket Guide.

Eating out
Talk to the Waiter
Always ask your waiter where their seafood originates from if not identified on the menu.

Explain why
Whenever you decide not to purchase Canadian seafood, explain that you are doing so in protest at Canada’s seal hunt, and ask the supermarket, shop, market, or restaurant manager or owner to join you.

Let Canada Know
Please tell James Scott Peterson, Canada’s International Trade Minister that you are choosing to boycott Canadian seafood products until the commercial seal hunt is ended for good. Direct your letters and e-mails to:

The Honourable James Scott Peterson, Minister, c/o Canadian High Commission, 1 Grosvenor Square, London, W1K 4AB.

Read the Supermarket Guide: what they say and what not to buy.

What Products to Avoid
Some of the common seafoods imported from Canada are lobster, prawns and salmon (tinned or fresh). Most tinned Salmon from Canada has been very thoughtfully branded with the shape of a maple leaf, which is helpful in identifying what products to avoid!