The answer on my submission to the RCMP as to why I needed an "assault type rifle" (it's not called that) was "target practice" though I equally could have put down "collector" as I would meet the criteria of a collector (a demonstrated interest in the history of that type of firearm etc.)
Extending that sort of regime to all rifles was essentially what the long gun registry went after, and the primary reason why it failed was that it's just not relevant or useful. So few crimes are committed with rifles that there's no point in spending all the money and engaging all the police resources required to keep track of them. Having police review and approve transfers is not for free, much less engaging investigative resources sufficient to keep people honest--taxpayers pay for it, and when there isn't any value there, taxpayers get grumpy.
It is worth pointing out that it was primarily taxpayer lobby groups that killed the gun registry, the actual gun lobby groups themselves did not bring nearly as much in the way of resources to that fight as the Canadian Taxpayers Federation etc. did
Actually the long gun registry 'failed' because Harper refused to enforce the laws practically from the moment he was first appointed PM. It thus became increasingly out of date, although police still found it better than nothing and well worth the few million a year it cost once it was running. One could also say it failed because many Canadian gun-owners saw themselves as NRA wannabes stalwartly fighting an oppressive government in the name of their sacred liberties and made elected life as difficult as they could fore anyone who tried to actually make the thing work at all, never mind making it work better. What membership card they might have carried when they did that makes little difference; they were the same folks, with the same message.
But that word fail only applies if the registry didn't meet some standard of performance, and apart from the results of Harper's deliberate sabotage there has been little if any evidence that it did not do what it was set up to do: Establish a current database, recording weapons and their owners in Canada.
Like the distraction around the assaultiveness of certain rifles, gun-owners kept alive the myth that the registry was supposed to eliminate all gun crime, so they could say how stupid it was and point to any shooting as its failure—a bit like proving assault rifles are safer than being hit by lightning, and so should be regulated the same as thunderstorms—but repeating it don't make it so. Registering guns, like registering cars, or pets, or kids for swimming lessons doesn't do anything except give the people who do the work one of the tools they need to do it.
What registering does do, is remind the folks who are doing it that this is not a trivial thing they're entering upon and that the authorities take it seriously and have information enough to make sure you do as well. All that is educative. And so is a Prime Minister who says, "Ignore the registration law, we won't enforce it, even if we won't repeal it either. Laws mean nothing; what you and I want is all that counts".
I see no evidence the registry failed, but Harper did us the disservice of killing it as effectively as he could, and heck, he even got around to doing it in legally. Just took him years.
Some folks wind up in jail when they ignore laws and wave guns around doing it, but not if you're the PM's guys.