Auto sales tax question

wawa

Well-known member
Jan 15, 2004
329
270
63
I am selling a car privately. I have an offer from someone that has taken 3 days to get the money together and notify his insurance which is the first red flag. It shouldn't take more than 1 hour to get insurance and get a bank draft. What concerns me more is that this buyer wants me to state on the bill of sale a lower selling price in order to save on the HST. This, to me is, fraud. The Vehicle Information Package has a line for the seller to sign to verify the selling price. I am not comfortable signing a government document and lying to the government in order for someone else to save on the tax. I'm so pissed off that I don't want to do the deal with this buyer who wants to cheat the government. Comments please.
 
I wouldn't do it, however, regardless of how low you said you sell it for, the car's black book value will be the price point if it is higher than what you stated.
 
Could also be his attempt to state a lower value for insurance purposes, which could be insurance fraud.
 
Just tell him he won't save any HST since private used car sales are not subject to HST

That changed about 5 years ago, all vehicle sales are subject to HST now.


Even if you did legitimately sell it to them for a low price, they will still pay tax on the amount showing as a market price for that year and model of vehicle. Only way that doesn't apply is if it is an older model (pre-1990s), in which case an MTO appraisal form has to completed and signed by an authorized agent stating the value.
 
Umm, nope. The 13% charged when you transfer the ownership of a car in Ontario that you bought privately is not HST. It is a special Ontario tax on this transaction. It was 8% prior to Ontario moving to the HST. When the province did the switch they quietly raised the tax to 13%.

Call it what you want its still there and it's 13%.

Doesn't matter what the op puts down as the selling price, the buyer has to pay whatever value shows up on the used vehicle information package.
 
Umm, nope. The 13% charged when you transfer the ownership of a car in Ontario that you bought privately is not HST. It is a special Ontario tax on this transaction. It was 8% prior to Ontario moving to the HST. When the province did the switch they quietly raised the tax to 13%.


I work with the MTO on a daily basis and its 13% HST.
 
I wouldn't do it, however, regardless of how low you said you sell it for, the car's black book value will be the price point if it is higher than what you stated.

Not sure if that's the case on every type of transfer. For example it used to be if you were buying the car "as is" to certify yourself and re-register later, than you could pay tax on an amount smaleer than balck book value. Not sure if they've changed that?

.... What concerns me more is that this buyer wants me to state on the bill of sale a lower selling price in order to save on the HST. This, to me is, fraud. Comments please.
Well you could think of it as selling it for the declared value and billing the rest of the money as a "brokers fee" or "delivery surcharge" then declaring that as "Income" on your Tax Return to satisfy your civic conscience ... but the bottom line is it's YOUR car and YOUR transaction, so if YOU"RE not comfortable with it, best to walk away.