Auto Insurance Broker?

Keebler Elf

The Original Elf
Aug 31, 2001
14,845
507
113
The Keebler Factory
So I've had the same auto insurance broker for 15+ years. Lately I've been with a particular insurance company (Intact) and I'm satisfied with them. Here's the rub...

For the past 2-3 years when renewal time comes around, I get the renewal notice from the insurance company and then about 1-2 weeks later I get a letter from my broker telling me the exact same thing (i.e., what the renewal price is). My broker gives me no comparisons, nothing. Just the renewal notice.

Last year I called my broker and basically asked them what am I paying you for. If you're not going to show me you're doing some homework to guarantee the lowest price then I don't need you. So they sent me the top 10 quotes and lo and behold there are cheaper options. I didn't switch because the cheaper ones were a little shady and for the reputable ones the savings didn't justify switching.

This year, same thing. No comparisons provided by my broker, just the renewal letter for Intact.

Here's the question: For those of you who use insurance brokers, do they do the same thing with you or do they automatically send you renewal options rather than just a renewal notification?

I'm at the point where I'm considering just cutting the broker loose, staying with Intact, and doing my own homework next year.
 
My insurance has gone down 20 dollars a year for the last 4 years so Im not complaining, my broker works for me.
 
Mine's gone down by more than that but I would have gotten it anyway without my broker.

The Liberals have been pressuring the insurance companies to lower their rates so if yours didn't you should be up in arms. Most people have gotten savings (assuming their didn't have claims).
 
My insurance has been going down every year for the past 4 years. Clean driving record, no tickets, no accidents, no claims. Although my car has been hit in a few different spots while parked. The shitty part is total damage is probably 2K but it would be 3 separate claims. Likely not worth paying 3 deductibles and rates may go up.