Astronomy / Physics Question

I vote that arthurfonzerelli is probably the smartest dude on this board, second only to dtjohnst who put on the MOST impressive display of intellect ever seen on TERB in the LGBT in Russia thread some months ago. Well done arthur!

It's nice to know that when I look out my locked car window at today's youth, there are intelligent guys like you and dtjohnst out there actually running our planet and keeping the world in order. :thumb:
 
I vote that arthurfonzerelli is probably the smartest dude on this board, second only to dtjohnst who put on the MOST impressive display of intellect ever seen on TERB in the LGBT in Russia thread some months ago. Well done arthur!

It's nice to know that when I look out my locked car window at today's youth, there are intelligent guys like you and dtjohnst out there actually running our planet and keeping the world in order. :thumb:

That still won't get you laid, but you can ask them.
 
Everything is relative

Sure. Why not? In fact, they wouldn't appear to move in the sky *at all*, except over thousands of years.
I think if you explain why you think the stars would move at all, it will help me explain things.

Day dreaming one day, and instead of pursuing other answers,...I made a assumption,...and you know what that does.

My thinking was that since the earth was moving through space at about 1000 mph,... stars in a sector of view from earth should move by fast enough to cause them to appear to be moving quickly through that view sector.
My dumb assumption was that the stars stayed in position in that sector because the earth is rotating on its axis, in the correct direction at the same time to maintain that relationship.
Example,...looking out the side window of a moving car, everything is whizzing by,..."rotate" your head in the right direction,...no apparent movement,... relatively.
Look straight up at the stars, then move your head, the stars move.
I brought up the other 2 planets, because of videos taken from them, showing the same none movement as a view from earth, and thought that this was a strange coincidence .

Thanks for your input, makes sense...things are looking up.
 
Dunno. I been too worried about whether a tree falling in the woods without anyone there to see it makes any noise or not.

My understanding is that no, there would be no noise. In order for noise to exist, there has to be something capable of "downloading" that noise. In this example, it is the ears of a living creature. So a tree falls, there is a disturbance in the air, our ears receive that disturbance and tell our brain that there is a noise. If there is no receiver, there is no noise, similar to radio waves. There are currently radio waves moving through your living room, but if you don't have a radio to receive them, you don't know that there are radio waves moving through your living room. In the forest, it is the ears of the creatures near the falling tree that receive the noise. No creature, no noise.

So I'm told, anyhow.
 
Too noisy

My understanding is that no, there would be no noise. In order for noise to exist, there has to be something capable of "downloading" that noise. In this example, it is the ears of a living creature. So a tree falls, there is a disturbance in the air, our ears receive that disturbance and tell our brain that there is a noise. If there is no receiver, there is no noise, similar to radio waves. There are currently radio waves moving through your living room, but if you don't have a radio to receive them, you don't know that there are radio waves moving through your living room. In the forest, it is the ears of the creatures near the falling tree that receive the noise. No creature, no noise.

So I'm told, anyhow.

My understanding that this is really a debate about semantics.

Is the tree falling, and creating waves in the air, "sound",...or is "sound", our brains interpretation of the air waves as a sound.
Radio waves are radio waves, even if they are not rcvd by a receiver.

FAST
 
Last edited:
My thinking was that since the earth was moving through space at about 1000 mph,... stars in a sector of view from earth should move by fast enough to cause them to appear to be moving quickly through that view sector.

Not sure what the 1000 mph speed refers to precisely.

The distance between the earth and the sun is roughly 100 million miles.
The orbital speed of earth around the sun has to be a lot greater than
1000 mph. Make it around 30 km/sec. The sun (along with the entire
solar system) moves in the Milky Way at a much greater speed. And the
Milky Way itself moves through the universe at a even greater speed than
the solar system. The distances covered by such planetary and galactic
movement over any meaningful period of time are obviously infinitesimal
in comparison with the distance between the stars we are observing.
 
I think what that cat does in your signature gif is more interesting. Talk about defying gravity (I think it landed on all fours on the sidewalk - ouch).
 
Experts

Not sure what the 1000 mph speed refers to precisely.

The distance between the earth and the sun is roughly 100 million miles.
The orbital speed of earth around the sun has to be a lot greater than
1000 mph. Make it around 30 km/sec. The sun (along with the entire
solar system) moves in the Milky Way at a much greater speed. And the
Milky Way itself moves through the universe at a even greater speed than
the solar system. The distances covered by such planetary and galactic
movement over any meaningful period of time are obviously infinitesimal
in comparison with the distance between the stars we are observing.

The number I throw out there was just as a reference, the number it self was not significant.
But as some one else has already said,...its the distance from any one of these 3 planets to the stars, that is the why the stars don't appear to move in relation to were you are standing.
If the earth was rotating on its axis a lot faster,...sure as hell the stars would appear to move,...assuming of coarse,...the rotation direction didn't cancel the effect.

FAST