Are hobbyists neo-cons?

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Following the posts in the Lounge area, I am astonished that the majority of posters are strong supporters of the Bush administration and anything it is doing. I believe that polls has shown that canadians in general are much more critical of the Bush administration and its policies.

Are hobbyists in general more conservative than the general population?
 
I am not sure one need be a NEO-Conservitive to be supportive on BUSh or any president for that matter. Myself I am neither republican nor conseritive. Yet I support the war on terror and support all US troops whereever they are deployed.

I belive you will find it is a cakewalk to be critical of others when you have no vested interest in anything you are critical of. But when you live in a country, city or state you tend to relize that you can speak with your vote and let the others make noise.

Yes I am still critical of Clinton but during his presidentcy I supported the office of the President.
 
danmand said:
Following the posts in the Lounge area, I am astonished that the majority of posters are strong supporters of the Bush administration and anything it is doing. I believe that polls has shown that canadians in general are much more critical of the Bush administration and its policies.

Are hobbyists in general more conservative than the general population?
I think that you will find a cross-section of the population represented. Do a search, I think that you will find lively debates with all sides represented.
 
In American politically speaking, I am Liberals on social issue.

BUT, I am neo-conservative on fiscal policies, national security, military and diplomacy.

I supported Bill Clinton on the social issue and economic policies but I also support George W. Bush national security policies....not so sure whether he has a strategy or the ruthlessness to deal with the worst enemy in the human history I can think of :(
 
i tend to think the first thing is to recognise that hobbyists are not representative of the population - the majority of hobbyists are:

male
middle aged
married (or "attached")
richer than average

now, there are some women who post - mainly SPs, and the age skew tends to have fewer young guys (students can't afford to hobby, and young guys probaly have a better shot at picking up young hotties and so don't need to hobby). i tend to think seniors hobby less - for the average male, sex drive does diminish with age.

married - well, this is less certain, but i understand that many guys hobby because either their mate has a lower sex drive or will not partake in certain activities.

as for being richer than average, well maybe not rich, but low income people can't afford the hobby.


now if you look at the above, remember that there is a "gender gap" in politics, particularly in the US - guys tend to be far more conservative.

the age skew is less clear - seniors tend to be more supportive of big government, largely because they are more dependent on government for health care, pensions etc.

and as for income, again, there is a clear political bias here - rich people tend to be more conservative and more supportive of anyone promising tax cuts - lower income people tend to be more left, but of course there are many blue collar conservatives (archie bunker types!)

so, i think when you take all of this into account, there is no surprise that a hobbyist discussion board will have an over-representation of rightwingers/conservatives, and fewer left/liberal voices. but that doesn't mean that there isn't a diversity of opions, just it is skewed to the right.
 
Good points Mr. X. One thing though... the average hobbyist is probably more socially liberal... especially when it comes to decrimilization of the adult industry!!!
 
mr. x said:
i tend to think the first thing is to recognise that hobbyists are not representative of the population - the majority of hobbyists are:

male
middle aged
married (or "attached")
richer than average

now, there are some women who post - mainly SPs, and the age skew tends to have fewer young guys (students can't afford to hobby, and young guys probaly have a better shot at picking up young hotties and so don't need to hobby). i tend to think seniors hobby less - for the average male, sex drive does diminish with age.......

Guess I don't fit the profile of a hobbyist since I am not middle-aged and NEVER married or attached.

BTW, regarding young guys don't need to hobby, as a young guy who is going back to upgrade my skills (student again), I find hobbying less expensive and economical than picking up young hotties. No pressure and you know what you will get.

Not surprising when many SPs don't want to take my business when they ask for my age because I figure out they don't want to have clients the same age group.

Maybe some of them are the young hotties you are dreaming and ogling to pick up at the clubs ;) and they don't want to get "acquainted" at the clubs by "not wealthy patron" like me.
 
sweet guy said:
Guess I don't fit the profile of a hobbyist since I am not middle-aged and NEVER married or attached.


actually - i am not married or attached - but in the time i have been on these boards, i have found that the majority of hobbyists are married.

keebler - good point about americans - americans do thend to be further right than canadians - so that has an impact.

don: i think you are also right - the guys who post are not maral majority type "social conservatives" but are more economic conservatives/libertarian conservatives.

the terms liberal and conservative are almost meaningless in that there are many things that can be described by the term, and the meanings have changed over time.
 
Depends on how you understand the term "conservative." I like Republicans simply because they tend (though there are exceptions) to be for lower taxes, less government, and strong military. Democrats scare me by their constant attempt to legislate morality. Sure they're pro-choice but other than that, they are big into legislating against whatever they don't like.
 
ocean976124 said:
Depends on how you understand the term "conservative." I like Republicans simply because they tend (though there are exceptions) to be for lower taxes, less government, and strong military. Democrats scare me by their constant attempt to legislate morality. Sure they're pro-choice but other than that, they are big into legislating against whatever they don't like.
Interesting ... "less government"? I think only when it comes to government intervention in big business. What about social issues like gay marriage and abortion? Ah then they are all for government intervention. What about foreign affairs? There too they are for government intervention in the affairs of sovereign nations in order to advance what they see as any self-interest (usually leading back to big business). Why be involved in Nicaragua and Haiti and Iraq? Humanitarianism? Maybe I am just cynical, but yeah right!

I am extremely fiscally conservative. I believe in balanced budgets and that deficits eventually come home to roost. Republicans believe that they can spend away deficits.

I believe in less government! I believe in conservative finances. I do not think that the Republicans do. Also I think that there is a whole lot of rhetoric on the Republicans side to cover over their real interest, advocating the interests of big business (like Enron, Halliburton, etc) and the haves and have mores. When in fact it is small business and mom and pa shops that are the economic back bone.
 
tompeepin said:
Interesting ... "less government"? I think only when it comes to government intervention in big business. What about social issues like gay marriage and abortion? Ah then they are all for government intervention.
Not really. For me, being a Republican, means that issues like gay marriage and abortion should be decided by state legislatures not by court fiat. I elect law makers for a reason, I don't like being ruled by 9 wise men who have jobs for life.
What about foreign affairs? There too they are for government intervention in the affairs of sovereign nations in order to advance what they see as any self-interest (usually leading back to big business). Why be involved in Nicaragua and Haiti and Iraq? Humanitarianism? Maybe I am just cynical, but yeah right!
Democrats were involved in all that fun stuff as well. Republicans are more unilateral when it comes to foreign affairs but Democrats enjoy screwing around with global issues.
I am extremely fiscally conservative. I believe in balanced budgets and that deficits eventually come home to roost. Republicans believe that they can spend away deficits.
Thats where Bush and Reagan differ from the average Republican.
 
danmand said:
Following the posts in the Lounge area, I am astonished that the majority of posters are strong supporters of the Bush administration and anything it is doing. I believe that polls has shown that canadians in general are much more critical of the Bush administration and its policies.

Are hobbyists in general more conservative than the general population?

I for one and definitely not a supporter of Bush. I tend to be economically conservative and socially liberal in the classical since of the word liberal.

Are hobbyists in general more conservative than the general population? Well they tend to be males who are more conservative than females, higher income (also more conservative than the general population) , and I suspect on average older (againmore conservative than the general population. Put these factors together, and I would predict that they would be more "conservative". I think that a more interesting question is whether they are more conservative that other higher income older males. I don't know.
 
Like I said before I am liberals on social issue. But I am definitely hawkish (neo-cons) on defense, fiscal and national security issues. I am for smaller government and less tax BUT I am against tax cuts or policies blatently benefiting for the wealthy at the expense to the rest of the population.

Put it this way, I am tend to be more say "Red Tory" than say to the NDP or Sheila Copps camps.

I am not a big fan on the Conservative party. The party is simply just a rural, Alberta-based, white men majority, conservative Christian party. Those female and non-white conservative Candidates, be the South Asians or what not are just bunches of "garnish" and "showcase" of diversity.

The bottom line is they are the "poor cousins" of the Republican Party. They feel they are damned of not having powerful lobby groups like the NRA or Christian coalitions to mobilize their power base (those evengelical groups in Burlington, ON are small potatoes compared to Pat Robertson).

This is also true to the Bloc Quebecois. It's tough to find any native French speaking Quebecois like the Haitians, Algerian or those from former French colonies to be Bloc Quebecois members.
 
the whole left right thing is awkward sometimes because of the fact that there are those who are left/right on socail issues, and those who are left/right on economic issues.

ever hear of the nolan chart? go to http://www.lairdwilcox.com/news/nolanchart.html.
 
Can somebody please tell me what a "neo-con" is? The term is bandied about by the media as effortlessly as the phrase "US-style" this-and-that, a phrase deployed mainly by under-achievers at the CBC and the Toronto Star when they’re about to launch an anti-US rant.

I know what “neo-con” means literally, but my understanding of the term is at odds with its usage in today’s media.

Can someone explain?
 
A few thoughts: You guys are being sloppy with the neo-con term. I've found that most posters here are much more liberal, have you not seen all the US bashing threads? I would agree with the demographic analysis above, many of the left leaning posters seem very young. Many polls down here show that Bush is leading among voters making more than 50k (doesn't everyone?) In other words, those who pull their own weight. OTB
 
I find that this board has a pretty good cross-section of opinions and therefore is pretty moderate overall, with a few exceptions.

For one, most posters are Canadian who tend to be more liberal then Americans. A lot of the more right wing opinions, incuding the ones above tend to be American.

I have visited some American boards - sports related boards that allow political discussions, and those boards are so right wing that it's scary.

I tend to be liberal on social issues but lean to the right on economic matters, which means I believe in being fiscally responsible. This means tax cuts if we can afford them and not running up huge deficits like Bush.
 
onthebottom said:
A few thoughts: You guys are being sloppy with the neo-con term. I've found that most posters here are much more liberal, have you not seen all the US bashing threads? I would agree with the demographic analysis above, many of the left leaning posters seem very young. Many polls down here show that Bush is leading among voters making more than 50k (doesn't everyone?) In other words, those who pull their own weight. OTB

OTB, first let me say, I like you, and am always amazed at the energy with which you can post.

second, you love the "US bashing posts". Not that they are truly US bashing. True, many of us, myself included, dislike much about the current US policies. But you would be hard pressed to find too many Canadians who truly despise all americans.

third, most Canadians are far more liberal than most americans. If Canada were to vote in the US elections, probably 31 million out of 32 million would vote democrat.

I think that US politics - Conservative / liberal are more divided by geography than by income. I always think of NYC, or Chicago, or LA / California as being far more liberal than say a small town in the bible belt regardless of income.

But getting back to the issue of the thread, I think there are more conservative members of this board than liberal yes.

Myself, I will vote for Martin. Not the liberals, I will vote for Martin because I know how he will run the economy. I have listened to harper yack about a big tax cut, and increases in spending and I don't think he has A CLUE of what he is talking about. I abhore deficits and think they are the worst thing a government can do.

With commodity prices going through the roof, it is only a matter of time before inflation finds its way back into the system. When that happens, and it already is, the interest rates will soar and countries with large deficits (like the US) will find themselves spending more and more tax dollars on debt financing.

Under Martin, the liberals have been fiscally prudent. And that's what I want. Yes yes yes, adscam, HRDC, gun registry, I know, and it sickens me, but not enough not to vote for Martin.

I KNOW that if Martin is in there, the government will be fiscally repsponsible. And, they won't be poking around my bedroom. All warts aside, that's what I want, and Martin will deliver that.

I am not going to cut off my nose to spite my face and vote for Harper to punish Martin and the liberals. That's just plain stupid.
 
northerner said:

I have visited some American boards - sports related boards that allow political discussions, and those boards are so right wing that it's scary.

You want scary....

visit

www.rightnation.us

click on "news"

Some of those guys are Nazis on there. I post there sometimes just to irritate them. I keep getting warned that I am due to be banned for speaking out against Bush.