Are "Bitcoins" a scam?

rafterman

A sadder and a wiser man
Feb 15, 2004
3,504
101
63
I keep hearing about these "Bitcoins" which I gather are some kind of virtual internet currency. Are they a scam? Any of the TERB brain trust in on the ground floor?
 
The best way to model bitcoins is less as a currency, and more of a commodity, like gold: they take work to make (lots of computer work, specifically), but have no intrinsic value. A quick google search will turn up lots of articles, some good and some bad; I'm afraid I don't have a ready list for you.
 
Funny, I was googling bitcoms a few days ago. The main concern I saw in the various articles I read was regarding privacy. Some people said it exposes you, others said its the most private way to move money. Seems to me its a large bubble, gaining momentum, but will eventually burst. That's how the pendulum swings. With good timing, a little luck, and some know how, I can see it being a major player in some people's financial game plan.
 
As good an article as any:

http://www.businessinsider.com/presentation-what-is-bitcoin-2013-3

Cant be sure where this phenomenon is going, but it is intriguing. I think most transactions are limited to about $1000 or so, after that liquidity problems develop. It seems to behave like a commodity, but I have trouble wrapping my brain around the whole idea: monetary value created with computational power and stored in code.
 
Like most money, it is a fiat currency. Unlike most money, it does not have a government's fiat behind it.

Like a tulip, it is worth what people will pay or trade for it. And like a tulip, once people realize that it has no "real" value backed by anyone of substance, its value will evaporate. Don't be there when the music stops.
 
I've actually been mining bitcoins for a few months, moving to litecoins recently (it's a derivative which I wont get into details but should be "better") and its decent. The cool thing is that it has major deflation. So holding your coins will make them worth more in the long run lol.
 
Like most money, it is a fiat currency. Unlike most money, it does not have a government's fiat behind it.

Like a tulip, it is worth what people will pay or trade for it. And like a tulip, once people realize that it has no "real" value backed by anyone of substance, its value will evaporate. Don't be there when the music stops.

So... fake money, that no one backs. So it can be worth nothing in 2 minutes flat someday?
 
Absolutely.

It's been relatively unregulated so far but plans in both Europe and the USA are underway to reign it in as it could be used as a way to transfer monies for use in crime and terrorism.
 
Absolutely.

It's been relatively unregulated so far but plans in both Europe and the USA are underway to reign it in as it could be used as a way to transfer monies for use in crime and terrorism.

It's been completely unregulated. It's a money laundering dream. I cashed out my principal but still riding my gains (which swings more than a fat kid at the playground!). Will need to cash the rest out soon to pay for some toys though.
 
Don't know if I'd use the word "scam." But I'd certainly say extremely speculative, and a possible "bubble."
 
Last edited:
If I can't buy a BBBJ with it, what good is it ?

You probably couldn't buy a BBBJ with an actual gold nugget, either (because nobody would know if it's authentic), but that gold nugget has value which is recognized by many people. The difference with bitcoins is that (as pointed out above many times), there is no lasting entitiy which is supporting its value - if people suddenly decide they're worthless, then they're worthless.

To be certain, people can suddenly decide that a stock in a particular company is worthless, but that stock is regulated under specific securities laws and regulations which provide shareholders recourse to the assets of the company under certain circumstances. Bitcoins aren't even as secure (in the financial sense) as a stock certificate.