Anyone with Bose Quietcomfort?

Been seeing many biz travellers with the Bose Quietcomfort in flights. Must have been 8-10 pairs in 1 flight.

Tried out a pair @ LGA Bose booth during transit. They had simulate jet engine blasting while you tryout the noise cancelling. It was heaven. Anyone with a pair? How's music quality?
 
Last edited:
It's QuietComfort actually, not Quietmaster. And yes, they work well. The downside is that they're quite large but they do sound good. A big advantage with the noise cancellation is that you don't have to crank the volume of your device so high just so you can hear.

I recently had a chance to try a pair of Shure e3c headphones in a store and I quite liked them. The e4c and e5c are supposedly better sounding though. I'm not sure what they would be like on a plane, but I suspect they'd be pretty good. The main advantage with Shure is that they're quite small.

Personally I think I might end up getting a pair of the Shure e5c for use around town but I'll likely stick with my Bose QuietComfort in airplanes.
 
Bose Sucks

This may be the best product Bose has released in a long long time (generally, Bose sucks). Not great for home usage, but indispensable on a plane. I tried the Senn equivalent too (I hate Bose) but not as good.
 
Noisey chatters

xarir said:
It's QuietComfort actually, not Quietmaster. And yes, they work well. The downside is that they're quite large but they do sound good. A big advantage with the noise cancellation is that you don't have to crank the volume of your device so high just so you can hear.

I recently had a chance to try a pair of Shure e3c headphones in a store and I quite liked them. The e4c and e5c are supposedly better sounding though. I'm not sure what they would be like on a plane, but I suspect they'd be pretty good. The main advantage with Shure is that they're quite small.

Personally I think I might end up getting a pair of the Shure e5c for use around town but I'll likely stick with my Bose QuietComfort in airplanes.
Thanks it was late. Corrected the post.

Saw ads promoting QuietComfort II, hoping price of orignals drop. If I talk about it often enough, get it as Xmas present. ha ha.

I don't like to spend on toys, rather do more trips.

It's good for the odd times to tune out the noisey chatters, when I want to catch up on rest. Yelling over 4 rows to your buddy is disrepectful to fellow passengers. Can't stand the noise cellphone calls in gates with U.S. biz people intentionally loud to friends back home to boast they are overseas. "What time is it at home?" "Oh, there's nothing to see or do here..." Hello, try get out of the hotel room and experience the surrounding...

Crying babies and engine noise are part of travelling and usually tune it out after a while. But the ignorant loud chatter, I have trouble tune out.
 
forrrget about it...

rubmeister100 said:
Absolutely incredible fit, noise cancelling and fidelity.

Just don't forget them in the lounge ... like I did. :confused:
That and also crushing it in my luggage. It's so light easy to forget about it. I know, you get the carrying case but I'm minimalist when it comes to packing, only carry-on so likely to turn into pieces the way I sometimes connect bus, trains and automobiles.

Hoping they put out the ear jack version.
 
Meister said:
Why?

It's not like Sanyo, Curtis or Emerson or anything like that.

They are pretty close (in fact, Sanyo may be ahead of them). They tend to be cheaply made (horrible drivers on their speakers), overpriced, poor performing, and marketing heavy. Their noise cancelling headphones break the mold.. they are actually a good product.
 
Garrett said:
They are pretty close (in fact, Sanyo may be ahead of them). They tend to be cheaply made (horrible drivers on their speakers), overpriced, poor performing, and marketing heavy. Their noise cancelling headphones break the mold.. they are actually a good product.

Sure it's not like the high end British or Canadian speakers. But, have you ever heard the sound that comes out of these tiny home theatre speakers? The reason the sound is quite amamzing for its size is that the sound snails around the internals 3 or 4 times before it leaves the speaker. There is nothing that beats it in that size.
 
Meister said:
Sure it's not like the high end British or Canadian speakers. But, have you ever heard the sound that comes out of these tiny home theatre speakers? The reason the sound is quite amamzing for its size is that the sound snails around the internals 3 or 4 times before it leaves the speaker. There is nothing that beats it in that size.

If you like 'em, great. I actually build speakers for fun. Bose is doing nothing new (in fact it is a cheap version of better, more established designs) and they are using extremely cheap/poor drivers on top of it. I have made my own version of the Bose cubes (cost:30usd each) that measure (and sound) much better There is a reason Bose avoids specs... they quite frankly suck. In around the same size, I think the monitor audio speakers kill them.

Here is one person's take on the quality:
http://www.intellexual.net/bose.html

Odds are if you are buying bose, you could buy something much better for less.. The noise cancelling headphones are great though...
 
goodtime said:
Saw ads promoting QuietComfort II, hoping price of orignals drop.

QuietComfort 2 have actually been out for a while now (at least 1 year if not 2). I doubt you can even buy QC I anymore. I have the original QuietComfort which I picked up on eBay for $100 less than what they were going for in the stores. The differences between model 1 & 2:

Model 2 has ear pieces that rotate so you can store the whole thing flat. That would actually be handy because the headset overall is fairly large so any space you can save is useful particularly while travelling. Also, with earpieces rotated you have less chance of crushing something I think. YMMV on that point though.

Model 2 has the sound cancellation circuitry built into the headsets. On model 1 the circuit and corresponding battery placement is in a small box that's attached to the headset. I don't find it a big deal personally, but I admit that it would be nice sometimes, particuarly when you're in the back of the bus to have less stuff hanging from your head. Flying biz is easy as there's always somewhere to put that little box.

If you're really interested in getting the Bose, I'd recommend eBay as it's generally cheaper there.

If size matters, consider the Shure. Different technology (sound isolation as opposed to cancellation) but they probably work well enough on airplanes.
 
Thanks for the info.

I must have tried on the QC II as the headpiece rotates and build-in battery compartment + switch. Surprise the young sales guy didn't mention it was a II. He's an interesting combination of Korean/Chinese with a Brooklyn accent. I was listening to his accent more than what he was saying. Thought people may mistaken I was trying to pick him up. Girls would consider him a poster boy given his mix look.

Back to QC II, the cost and luggage room is consideration, so I'll an eye on it as well as smaller size competitors. With carry-on electronics & flying, given today's airport screeners, they are bound to want to see and play with them to ensure not weapons. Last thing I need new headphones break from manhandled.
 
wave goodbye to bose

Sukdeep said:
The Tivoli sounds as good as the Bose Wave? If so, I'm on way to Bay-Bloor right now!!
In many people's opinion it will sound better, but I only posted it as an example of a good alternative at a low price - it's the direction I'd be looking in.

PS Goodtime, you should check out Shure E4 as well as Etymotic 4P.
 
I love mine, use with my DVD player, iPod and PSP.

OTB