I'm surprised that no one has brought this up yet, but wasn't anyone else struck by the exclusive focus on the underrepresentation of black people being nominated?
Blacks are not even the largest minority group in the US any longer, Hispanics/Latinos are (17% vs. 14%).
If the show wanted to highlight underrepresentation, why not bring all of the groups into the discussion? Were gays underrepresented? Hispanics? Asians? Muslims? etc.
The presentation made it seem like representation of blacks was the only issue that needed discussion.
Of course, the entire black representation discussion was pointless in any event. Rock suggested that blacks don't get opportunities because "they're not part of the Sorority". Does that really stand up to any scrutiny? Blacks are overrepresented in the NFL, Major League Baseball, and the NBA, despite the prior colour barrier in these forms of entertainment. So why, of all things, would there continue to be a colour barrier in film, an industry run by left-leaning liberals?
Like a film production, the real story here is not told by simply examining the on screen product - the entire production process needs to be discussed. Simply put, black actors get fewer Oscar nominations because they get fewer parts, and they get fewer parts because there are fewer roles written that black people can be credibly cast in, and there are fewer roles for blacks because producers and directors are choosing to make movies that don't contain many black roles.
So the real question is, why aren't more movies being made that contain black roles (or roles that can be credibly played by black actors)?
Only 4 out of 10 movies make a profit. Investing in films is a risky business. Even a single failure, if large enough, can bring down a studio with a track record for successful films. In summary, film investors are in it to make money, not art, and they are not interested in social equity issues at the expense of their own pocketbook. Why should they be?
So, why aren't films about black lives and experiences made more often? Why are they viewed as higher risks than the films that are made? In short, because it appears that maybe they are higher risk. The two directors who are best known for making movies about black characters and for using predominantly black casts are Spike Lee and Tyler Perry. Spike Lee's films are predominantly about social issues, whereas Tyler Perry's movies are all comedies. On a per movie basis, Perry's movies have been more successful. If you review Spike Lee's movies, many are fairly low revenue earners. His last three pictures (all of his output since 2008) all had domestic box receipts of under 3 million USD each. His last "hit" was Inside Man in 2006. Even his celebrated Do the Right Thing did only 28 million domestically. Tyler Perry's comedies have all been moderately successful (40-60 million). In summary: 1) while there clearly is a market for comedies featuring black actors, there is obviously a saturation point for that kind of movie, 2) there would appear to be only a small market for films about the black experience or the lives of black people, and 3) the biggest grossing films are, predominantly, about white characters.
Now why is that? Could be that not enough black people go to the movies, whether it's a Spike Lee movie or Twilight (what could be "whiter" than a vampire movie

)? I'm sure someone working for a movie distribution company would have that data. Could it be that they don't go to the movies because of the cost? Could be that there is a difference in income distribution between blacks and whites in America? That seems reasonably possible. Could it be that even blacks prefer movies about white characters?
There is an interesting comparison to professional sport. As I mentioned above, clearly black people have broken the colour barrier in sport to the point that they are now overrepresented. However, I don't think much has changed as to who the buying public is. Look around at a Raptors game. You will still see a predominantly white fan base. Obviously, the main reason that blacks have successfully breached the colour barrier in professional sports is not because "that was the right thing to do", but because the predominantly white fan base would pay (handsomely) to see them play.
My theory is that there are just not enough white people (particularly Americans) who will pay to see a movie about the black experience or black lives.
As a result, there is nothing to be gained by a protest focussed on the number of Oscar nominees who are black, or the representation level of any other group, not unless you want to talk about why there aren't more movies being made that offer more casting opportunities for minorities. I simply don't buy the "you're not the Sorority" explanation when a black actor is passed over to play Abraham Lincoln.