Anyone see this crap that's going on???

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
http://www.citynews.ca/news/news_13622.aspx

Not sure if it's been posted, forget search for now.

Anyways here are 2 emails you can use to tell them what dickheads they are for suspending this guy.
Reasoning is his conduct of handcuffing the guy to the car.
Sure okay, Tre Smith is supposed to try to save a dog's life while there's an irrate guy flipping out about his poor little window, but it's okay for his dog to be locked up inside in the fucking heat.

Here's an email to complain to.
cmabee@ospca.on.ca

Sent this to a few people already and they actually got replies from the guy.
 
I like the part where it said by-standers beat the handcuffed man for doing it to the dog...I say his punishment should be lock HIM in a car on a sunny day for 8 hrs and see how HE likes it......
 
STASH said:
Handcuffing people shouild only be a job of the police. It's too bad they were late getting there.
Why don't we give the folks who write parking tickets a batton so they can beat you when you get back to your car
I have no support for that " dog catcher "

OK, so I guess you think that he should have let the dog die and or suffered the attack of the guy handcuffed?

BTW: I guess you don't know that as citizens, everyone is allowed to handcuff or detain another person if we feel our life is in danger?

If you think that he shouldn't be allowed to handcuff an offender, why is he issued handcuffs?
 
He did all the right things, including handcuffing the guy, until he left. That was a mistake. As much as animal lovers may hate it when I say this, people have rights, animals don't have rights. The guy who got handcuffed has rights to freedom and safety that were violated when he was left there. The dog has no right to life. Another solution would be to put the dog out of his misery if he was suffering so as to be able to properly tend to the offender. More likely the dog still did have some chance of surviving if he'd stayed there with the dog and the offender waiting for help.

Flame away animal lovers, but thems the facts. It's fully legal to shoot and kill a dog, so long as you aren't cruel. Dogs just don't have rights. Period.
 
Sorry Fuji, did you read the article? The dog had stopped breathing when the officer decided to handcuff the guy and rescue the animal.

He also "didn't leave him" as it were. Don't make it sound like the officer drove him three blocks, handcuffed him to a tree, then drove back to the location where the dog was in peril. The officer handcuffed the guy, to his car, then tended to the dog.....

BTW: you're wrong, animals DO have rights hence why offenders are prosecuted for animal abuse all the time.....
 
Is there some misunderstanding? I read the article and it says that after he handcuffed the guy he had to leave to save the life of the dog. He handcuffed the guy to the car and then left the scene, at which point bystandards beat the guy. I think he failed in his duty of care towards the guy he had essentially taken charge of by handcuffing. He left him helpless at the hands of an angry mob, that really could be criminal negligence.

Also don't confuse laws against animal cruelty with animals having rights. It's also illegal in some jurisdictions to deface currency or flags, but that doesn't mean currency or flags have rights.

People have rights to life, liberty, security of person, etc., that go beyond any law. Dogs don't.

I'm pointing this out to point out that there is no "contest of rights" here. It is not the offenders rights versus the dogs rights. The offender has rights. The dog doesn't.
 
Yes the guy was an idiot asshat for leaving his Friend in the car......no argument there Tboy.
Giving the dog catcher or other government authorities handcuffs or guns......no thanks. Fuck what next give the ladies at the driver license office the right to take you down because you have unpaid tickets when you go for your plate.
The cops should have come to deal with him and let the dog guy be a dog guy.
It's just a shame the guy was so cruel in his thinking. Having a non cop handcuff people is NOT OKAY WITH ME.

People who never question authority are the dangerous ones in reality.

Hell Tboy thinks it okay that you neighbour has the right to handcuff you for whatever is pissing him off at you at the time..........duh !!!!
 
tboy said:
Sorry Fuji, did you read the article? The dog had stopped breathing when the officer decided to handcuff the guy and rescue the animal.

He also "didn't leave him" as it were. Don't make it sound like the officer drove him three blocks, handcuffed him to a tree, then drove back to the location where the dog was in peril. The officer handcuffed the guy, to his car, then tended to the dog.....

BTW: you're wrong, animals DO have rights hence why offenders are prosecuted for animal abuse all the time.....


It makes me sick when ppl do this kinda stuff why have an animal if your gonna be like that ... Geez i cant even watch those humane society commercials without crying*ya im a huge mush for animals*:(
 
fuji said:
Is there some misunderstanding? I read the article and it says that after he handcuffed the guy he had to leave to save the life of the dog. He handcuffed the guy to the car and then left the scene, at which point bystandards beat the guy. I....

yeah, you DID misunderstand. He left the guy to go tend to the animal. He handcuffed the guy to his car (his being the animal rescue officer). Do you think he parked 3 blocks away? Shit, I bet he was less than 20 feet because obviously he'd park his vehicle, WITH his equipment as close to the scene as possible....

Oh yeah, and I guess he took the offender's car to transport the dog too and "left" him all by his little bitty lonesome in the big scary parking lot....

Come on dude, think about it for a second.....just a second.....
 
fuji said:
He did all the right things, including handcuffing the guy, until he left. That was a mistake. As much as animal lovers may hate it when I say this, people have rights, animals don't have rights. The guy who got handcuffed has rights to freedom and safety that were violated when he was left there. The dog has no right to life. Another solution would be to put the dog out of his misery if he was suffering so as to be able to properly tend to the offender. More likely the dog still did have some chance of surviving if he'd stayed there with the dog and the offender waiting for help.

Flame away animal lovers, but thems the facts. It's fully legal to shoot and kill a dog, so long as you aren't cruel. Dogs just don't have rights. Period.

You can't just walk down a fuckin' street and shoot a dog.
That's why there's an SPCA for fuck sakes.

Those are words from a friend reading this article over my shoulder Fuji.
I'll just add this... quit being such an ignorant womanizing sack of shit and wake the fuck up.
 
Why did the owner of the dog need to be hand cuffed. That should be the job of the police. However much we love dogs, and I do, people are more important.

There should be no reason for animal rescue officers to carry handcuffs. You cannot handcuff a bear anyway.
 
danmand said:
Why did the owner of the dog need to be hand cuffed. That should be the job of the police. However much we love dogs, and I do, people are more important.

There should be no reason for animal rescue officers to carry handcuffs. You cannot handcuff a bear anyway.

According to the story he was threatening and/or assaulting people. I think the officer acted appropriately in getting him under control. His mistake was walking away afterwards--as you say, people are more important.

As for why, animal control officers have the same legal powers as police officers when enforcing animal cruelty laws. They're empowered to arrest people and apply the criminal code like any other police officer, except that they're limited to enforcing the laws relating to animals.
 
tboy said:
yeah, you DID misunderstand. He left the guy to go tend to the animal. He handcuffed the guy to his car (his being the animal rescue officer). Do you think he parked 3 blocks away? Shit, I bet he was less than 20 feet because obviously he'd park his vehicle, WITH his equipment as close to the scene as possible....

Your interpretation is different than mine. My interpretation is that he actually left, as in he went far enough away that he was basically not around to protect the guy. In any case he put the dogs' life ahead of the man's safety. When I first read it I thought "had to leave" meant he got in his car and drove away. Maybe that's not the case--anyway, it seems he wasn't taking proper care of the offender.

I agree with you that if he was 20 feet and doing his best but the crowd somehow overpowered him anyway it's not a big deal at all (at least not his fault). However if he knew the guy was in danger, saw what was happening, but decided to save the dog rather than the man, then I think this guy needs to be charged with criminal negligence causing bodily harm.
 
danmand said:
Why did the owner of the dog need to be hand cuffed. That should be the job of the police. However much we love dogs, and I do, people are more important.

There should be no reason for animal rescue officers to carry handcuffs. You cannot handcuff a bear anyway.

No, but you can 'cuff idiots.
 
fuji said:
As for why, animal control officers have the same legal powers as police officers when enforcing animal cruelty laws. They're empowered to arrest people and apply the criminal code like any other police officer, except that they're limited to enforcing the laws relating to animals.

'scuse me???? Police are trained at a college, SPCA guys aren't. Police are issued a provincial offences badge that allows them to enforce the criminal code. SPCA guys are bylaw guys that enforce bylaws.