Anyone do a Private Prosecution?

moeman69

Banned
Nov 23, 2010
48
0
0
Are these worth it? I have all the evidence but every lawyer I spoke with said don't bother?
Any one try one? ANy one have a lawyer I can use? Thanks
 
Are these worth it? I have all the evidence but every lawyer I spoke with said don't bother?
Any one try one? ANy one have a lawyer I can use? Thanks

If the lawyers are telling you not to bother it may be that their assessment of the evidence and the prospects of conviction are such that they feel it does not merit proceeding. Without knowing anything about the matter I could not comment but you may wish to take the lawyers' advice.
 
If the lawyers are telling you not to bother it may be that their assessment of the evidence and the prospects of conviction are such that they feel it does not merit proceeding. Without knowing anything about the matter I could not comment but you may wish to take the lawyers' advice.

Sorry but they haven't seen evidence or want to hear the case. As soon as you mention "private prosecution" they go forget it. Not worth it. my take is they don't make money on it buut who knows. I have the evidence on paper and a Judge's endorsement. I just want a lawyer with me to proceed but will do it alone if I hear positive results from others.
 
I understand private prosecution to mean you've consulted police and the Crown, and neither will pursue the case on the taxpayers hook, so you're looking to hire a lawyer to do so at your expense. Furthermore, lawyers—more than one—you have spoken to about your case and evidence have said don't.

As a certified crank who has spent what he cannot afford to fight where wiser folk said don't bother, let me ask if I may PM you a brochure about some well-watered Florida land directly abutting the Brooklyn Bridge, which also can be yours as a low-cost extra.

Alternatively, from what I know of lawyers, you just haven't named a high enough fee to interest them.

Or did you really intend to ask about filing a civil suit?
 
Sorry but they haven't seen evidence or want to hear the case. As soon as you mention "private prosecution" they go forget it. Not worth it. my take is they don't make money on it buut who knows. I have the evidence on paper and a Judge's endorsement. I just want a lawyer with me to proceed but will do it alone if I hear positive results from others.

Private prosecutions are very tricky and hard to accomplish.

And I would think, ridiculously expensive.

If you were to hire your own lawyer to do it, you would have to fund the whole thing out of pocket, and it would be really expensive.

Perhaps if you could give us some bare bones facts we might be able to be a bit more useful.
 
you've consulted police and the Crown, and neither will pursue the case
Moeman, is this the case have you spoken with both police and the Crown?

If so were you given a reason by the Crown that they are declining the case, such as the odds of prevailing were so low as to not justify prosecution?
 
Moeman, is this the case have you spoken with both police and the Crown?

If so were you given a reason by the Crown that they are declining the case, such as the odds of prevailing were so low as to not justify prosecution?

Only police and they said a crime was committed but declined to charge. Hows can I speak to a Crown directly?
 
Only police and they said a crime was committed but declined to charge. Hows can I speak to a Crown directly?

Depending on where you live you can make an appointment to see a "duty crown" at the local courthouse.

The other thing you can do, is go before a JP and swear out an information and if the JP agrees you have grounds he will issue the information which you then take to the crown's office with a written request that they assume it and prosecute it.

Doing the whole 9 yards on your own dime would be prohibitively expensive.

And if there is money at stake you may wish to consider a civil suit instead.
 
Only police and they said a crime was committed but declined to charge. Hows can I speak to a Crown directly?

Depending on where you live you can make an appointment to see a "duty crown" at the local courthouse.

The other thing you can do, is go before a JP and swear out an information and if the JP agrees you have grounds he will issue the information which you then take to the crown's office with a written request that they assume it and prosecute it.

Doing the whole 9 yards on your own dime would be prohibitively expensive.

And if there is money at stake you may wish to consider a civil suit instead.
 
AS long as you have filed the report with the police......it has to be an actual 'report'......

you can then go and see a Justice of the Peace and file a complaint and advise him you want to file charges.

They will instigate..and eventually the prosecution will take place.

However...a Crown may intercept it and DECLINE to prosecute. If that is the case its a lost cause!
 
Depending on where you live you can make an appointment to see a "duty crown" at the local courthouse.

The other thing you can do, is go before a JP and swear out an information and if the JP agrees you have grounds he will issue the information which you then take to the crown's office with a written request that they assume it and prosecute it.

Doing the whole 9 yards on your own dime would be prohibitively expensive.

And if there is money at stake you may wish to consider a civil suit instead.
Thanks for the info. Yeah, I am figuring a civil lawsuit is where I should head. The Judge already called the other side (cops) 'negligent" about 20 times in his ruling so I figure I might have a shot at a lawsuit.
 
Sorry but they haven't seen evidence or want to hear the case. As soon as you mention "private prosecution" they go forget it. Not worth it. my take is they don't make money on it buut who knows. I have the evidence on paper and a Judge's endorsement. I just want a lawyer with me to proceed but will do it alone if I hear positive results from others.

Presumably you would have told the lawyers you consulted what you believe the evidence would be. Was that not the case?
 
Presumably you would have told the lawyers you consulted what you believe the evidence would be. Was that not the case?

They pretty much tell me no matter how good the evidence the Crown will make it as hard as possible to prosecute because 'they hate them'. I figure if it's going to cost me a lot of money I better go teh civil route.
 
They pretty much tell me no matter how good the evidence the Crown will make it as hard as possible to prosecute because 'they hate them'. I figure if it's going to cost me a lot of money I better go teh civil route.

I have no idea who you spoke with but that is wrong. In a private prosecution you or your lawyer is the prosecutor. A private prosecution is appreciate where the police and/or crown refuse to prosecute. You must appear before a JP and persuade him/her, under oath, that there is sufficient evidence, if proved, on which to form the basis of a crime. The civil route is appreciate where you have suffered damages and you are seeking money damages. You may wish to seek another opinion.
 
I have no idea who you spoke with but that is wrong. In a private prosecution you or your lawyer is the prosecutor. A private prosecution is appreciate where the police and/or crown refuse to prosecute. You must appear before a JP and persuade him/her, under oath, that there is sufficient evidence, if proved, on which to form the basis of a crime. The civil route is appreciate where you have suffered damages and you are seeking money damages. You may wish to seek another opinion.



Can you PM me some lawyer names? I spoke to some heavy hitters in Toronto and they basically roll their eyes at a PP. My guess is they think it's beneath them? I don't know. The reception I get to doing a PP is don't waste my time, but the evidence is documented and it's on paper.

Have you done a PP? Am I being misled here? Are they really as expensive as people claim? I already spends close to 80K on Bullshit legal fees what's another 10?
 
What is the jist of your claim....and why are Polcie ignoring you!

What will you sue for? Fraud? Theft? ????
 
Thanks for the info. Yeah, I am figuring a civil lawsuit is where I should head. The Judge already called the other side (cops) 'negligent" about 20 times in his ruling so I figure I might have a shot at a lawsuit.

I did not see this earlier. In what forum did a Judge make findings about police conduct or misconduct. Is it the police you are trying to prosecute? If so that might be entirely different in part because the police have certain protections which come with actions taken in the performance of their duties.
 
I did not see this earlier. In what forum did a Judge make findings about police conduct or misconduct. Is it the police you are trying to prosecute? If so that might be entirely different in part because the police have certain protections which come with actions taken in the performance of their duties.

No the PP is for false allegations where the allegations are contradicted with actual records, facts etc. It was clear the prosecution was malicious. The Judge ruled in my favor citing, about 20x in the ruling, that the cops were negligent and stopped short of calling them criminals. He was pissed and rightfully so and spent 2 hours just hammering the crown and the cops and the complainant in his ruling. It was the worse the crown seen (I talked to him in the hall and he said the case was dropped on him like a hot potato and he was pissed himself) and my attorney (well known in Toronto). He suggested a civil and won't touch a PP.

I want to do a PP for public mischief against the person who initiated the charges, not against the police. I will sue the police later
 
I don't want to look it up right now but I seem to recall there was some recent Ontario law passed that makes it very difficult to sue police for negligence. I think the threshold is something like it has to be deliberate and malicious?

the recent caselaw has been moving the other way on the civil side, the bar seems to have been lowered to "negligent prosecution"

IIRC
 
No the PP is for false allegations where the allegations are contradicted with actual records, facts etc. It was clear the prosecution was malicious. The Judge ruled in my favor citing, about 20x in the ruling, that the cops were negligent and stopped short of calling them criminals. He was pissed and rightfully so and spent 2 hours just hammering the crown and the cops and the complainant in his ruling. It was the worse the crown seen (I talked to him in the hall and he said the case was dropped on him like a hot potato and he was pissed himself) and my attorney (well known in Toronto). He suggested a civil and won't touch a PP.

I want to do a PP for public mischief against the person who initiated the charges, not against the police. I will sue the police later

It is obviously somewhat complicated but not all conduct which is either negligent or apparently malicious is criminal. Again you should contact a layer who knows something about this area. the lawyers who discouraged you from proceeding may have been giving you good advice. In any event good luck.