Anyone been arrested from false allegations?

danzuchy

Banned
Nov 20, 2009
107
0
0
Let's say Subject one makes false claims to the police. It is clearly proved false in court. Case is thrown out.

Can you do anything about it? Like pressing private charges for Obstruction or Public Mischeif? Can you sue them?

Any advice appreciated.,
 
A lawyer might be a good place to start, with all the facts of the case.
 
No kidding. But before I see a lwyer I want to see if anyone had success in dealing with false allegations and what was the outcome.
The first place to start is were the statements malicious/knowingly false. Just because the defendant is acquitted, and the witnesses statement shown to be inaccurate doesn't necessarily mean you have any civil remedy (in fact you might even be committing a new criminal offense).

As a hypothetical: Witness identifies defendant as the man she saw stab the victim, for hypo purposes it is shown that W has a vision problem and that DNA shows that it was someone other than D who stabed the V. Sorry the witness believed in good faith that the person she saw was the defendant.
 
Let's say Subject one makes false claims to the police. It is clearly proved false in court. Case is thrown out.

Can you do anything about it? Like pressing private charges for Obstruction or Public Mischeif? Can you sue them?

Any advice appreciated.,


Public Michief under the criminal code is the relevant charge. However, it is up to the police to lay that charge, unless you can convince a Justice of the Peace that you have a case and can lay an information with that JP. That is a bit difficult, because they want to be very cautions in a situation like that. A relative of mine was in a similar situation with respect to being the victim of false claims in court, and we looked at that possibility.
 
No kidding. But before I see a lwyer I want to see if anyone had success in dealing with false allegations and what was the outcome.

Sorry, I didn't mean to be glib. I was just at a loss on how to respond without knowing more. Thankfully Aardvark has more sense than me.

I guess, to me, there SHOULD be a remedy, but possibly there is not...
 
Public Michief under the criminal code is the relevant charge. However, it is up to the police to lay that charge, unless you can convince a Justice of the Peace that you have a case and can lay an information with that JP. That is a bit difficult, because they want to be very cautions in a situation like that. A relative of mine was in a similar situation with respect to being the victim of false claims in court, and we looked at that possibility.

This is bad. So in order to clear your name in the courts you have to pay yourself?
The reason I say this, is because if you cross the border into the US and they see you were arrested, you are not allowed in. Until you clear your name and pay for it. The other individual is scott free!!!!!!!!!
At least they should pay for your troubles.
 
if you cross the border into the US and they see you were arrested, you are not allowed in

This isn't true. The US will only deny you entry if you have been CONVICTED of a serious crime. If you are acquitted or the charges are dropped that does not affect your status at the US border.
 
This is why the name of the accused and victim should remain sealed until after court proceedings are completed.
 
You can sue for the civil wrong of "malicious prosecution" if the charge was clearly malicious and false and you have been acquitted or the charges were withdrawn by the crown.
 
The crown pursues criminal charges, but anyone can bring a civil case to court, no?
 
A civil case is purely the responsibility of the person bringing it and the Crown cannot get involved.

Anyone can go to a JP and lay a criminal charge. However, the Crown and cops take the case over and run it when it comes to court, including withdrawing it, taking a plea bargain, deciding to go to trial, bargaining on sentence, etc.
 
Really? My understanding is that criminal charges can only be made by the Crown. A civilian can only make a complaint, which the Crown attorneys have discretion as to whether it is turned into an actual charge.

No. Anyone can lay a charge. The cops and Crown get involved later.
 
You can sue for the civil wrong of "malicious prosecution" if the charge was clearly malicious and false and you have been acquitted or the charges were withdrawn by the crown.

Hey, does this mean you sue the crown or the people? I want to sue those that falsely accused me directly.
 
Hey, does this mean you sue the crown or the people? I want to sue those that falsely accused me directly.

You can sue anyone that you like. That does not mean that the action will survive a motion to strike the statement of claim or a motion for summary judgment. People confuse the right to sue with success. They are very different things and just because you can commence an action does not mean that it will succeed.
 
This is bad. So in order to clear your name in the courts you have to pay yourself?
The reason I say this, is because if you cross the border into the US and they see you were arrested, you are not allowed in. Until you clear your name and pay for it. The other individual is scott free!!!!!!!!!
At least they should pay for your troubles.

Sad as it is, this is how the legal system works. My relative got the case thrown out at the appeals level. However, he couldn't get the people who perpetrated the crime against him. It is a long story and there is really no time to repeat it here in public. That is how the system works, love it or leave it. But, if you believe in Karma, the parties got what they deserved eventually a few years later, without any intervention on the part of the real victim of their crime.
 
A civil case is purely the responsibility of the person bringing it and the Crown cannot get involved.

Anyone can go to a JP and lay a criminal charge. However, the Crown and cops take the case over and run it when it comes to court, including withdrawing it, taking a plea bargain, deciding to go to trial, bargaining on sentence, etc.

Depends on whether the charge is indictable or not. If not, a private prosecution may proceed but it's very rare and expensive.
 
This isn't true. The US will only deny you entry if you have been CONVICTED of a serious crime. If you are acquitted or the charges are dropped that does not affect your status at the US border.

hey fuji;

Sometimes the records are not cleared 100 %, and the person who is acquitted still has problems crossing the border. Ideally, it has to work as you say. But, bureaucracy is a bitch.