Any HD experts out there?

LurkingInMyTent said:
Not so fast, me bucko... the reasonably priced cables are every bit as good for today's HD needs as the monstrously overpriced variety. Where the cheaper ones start to fail is when the lengths get up to 30 feet or more.

Check this article...http://i.gizmodo.com/268788/the-truth-about-monster-cable-part-2-verdict-cheap-cables-keep-upusually

First, I said there are differences in cables. The tests confirm this. I never mentioned price. Price is not the last word, but bandwidth is bandwidth, and usually there is some correlation.

There is a lot of science behind cables, and there are differences for more expensive brands that will pay attention to insulation, shielding, capacitance, grounding, etc. I am not a fan of Monster Cables (though I do like their power conditioners), but there are expensive cables (expensive being relative of course) that in my opinion are worth it for both perfornance and build quality.

The main thing I take exception to is people parroting tests they hear without understanding them, and there limitations (I like the test you posted). In addition, most people who say all cables are the same oddly have non-HD material (though think they are HD) and are listening over a shitty home theater in a box (a la Bose).
 
Garrett: construction? it's fricken wires behind a foil insulator wrapped in a plastic.

Your comments remind me of some people I met in the early 80's. They would have NO problem spending 1,000's of dollars to get less than 1% increase in sound quality. For eg: One guy built zorbathane rubber feet for his amplifier to isolate it from the harmonics of the speakers. Something about the vibrations affecting the transistors. Another would only use oxygen free speaker wire at $30.00 per foot.

If a test shows no noticeable difference between $70.00 cables and $10.00 cables and I can't see a difference, no way you'll convince me to pay $70.00 for cables.

BTW: I bet you also adhere to the Kiro school where you'd give your left nut to own one? I reviewed them before buying my plasma and you know? I'd rather have 3 of my pannie's instead of 1 Kiro.....
 
tboy said:
Garrett: construction? it's fricken wires behind a foil insulator wrapped in a plastic.

tboy, as I said, there is science. Not all insulators are created equal, and you can measure and see differences. As for the shield, there are different ways to manage depending on what you want to achieve. The fact you do not understand any of this does not mean it is not relevant, it simply means you have no idea what you are talking about.

tboy said:
Your comments remind me of some people I met in the early 80's. They would have NO problem spending 1,000's of dollars to get less than 1% increase in sound quality.

Where did I ever mention 1000s of dollars, never mind how are you measuring that 1%. Stop blowing smoke. The net is there are differences, and there is a correlation to cost. However, the correlation can be on the order of dollars or tens of dollars, not hundreds or thousands. Suppliers like belden make a good product at reasonable cost and available at HD no less in bulk.

tboy said:
If a test shows no noticeable difference between $70.00 cables and $10.00 cables and I can't see a difference, no way you'll convince me to pay $70.00 for cables.

The problem is, tests *do* show a difference. You can measure this and see the results. I am a scientist. Somehow I imagine you are not.

tboy said:
BTW: I bet you also adhere to the Kiro school where you'd give your left nut to own one? I reviewed them before buying my plasma and you know? I'd rather have 3 of my pannie's instead of 1 Kiro.....

Uhhh, you would lose then.... besides, anything below a 106" screen does not interest me. Stop assuming too much and relax.
 
Garrett said:
tboy, as I said, there is science. Not all insulators are created equal, and you can measure and see differences. As for the shield, there are different ways to manage depending on what you want to achieve. The fact you do not understand any of this does not mean it is not relevant, it simply means you have no idea what you are talking about.



Where did I ever mention 1000s of dollars, never mind how are you measuring that 1%. Stop blowing smoke. The net is there are differences, and there is a correlation to cost. However, the correlation can be on the order of dollars or tens of dollars, not hundreds or thousands. Suppliers like belden make a good product at reasonable cost and available at HD no less in bulk.



The problem is, tests *do* show a difference. You can measure this and see the results. I am a scientist. Somehow I imagine you are not.



Uhhh, you would lose then.... besides, anything below a 106" screen does not interest me. Stop assuming too much and relax.

Sorry dude, I am not a scientist (which explains your posts a LOT) but I do understand a LOT of a/v technology.

Yeah, measureable difference. I never said there wasn't. But I will await you to provide proof of what that measureable difference is. For eg: there is a measureable difference between 1 micron and 2 microns. Does it make a difference in wall construction in a standard house? Not a bit. Just like 1 or 5 % difference in video quality is irrelevant to 99% of HD buyers.

The op just bought his first LCD tv. It isn't a 106" so wtf are you talking about? I mean hell, the guy doesn't even own anything that can produce any sort of HD signal and you're trying to upsell him on something he doesn't need?

Guys like you are the type that make 99% of homeowners waste (yes I mean WASTE) money on expensive cables. (and yes, $50.00 on cables that are NO better than $20.00 ones IS a waste of money). Oh, btw, I did an a/b test between my $15.00 Infinity cables and a $65.00 belkin and using the same video source there was NO visible difference and since my plasma screen is based on visible images, it is a waste of money.

In addition, since you seem to know what you're talking about, a 5% increase in quality will be far more noticeable on a 106" screen than a 42". But then again, you're also probably the type that buys a 106" screen then sits on the other side of the room just so you can say you have a 106" screen.
 
look...there will be little or no difference in HDMI cables tested that are brand new and less than 12ft. in length. The weakness in HDMI cable is the connector. There are 19 conductors (wires) in a HDMI cable, which are much smaller than a typical Ethernet cable. Where the cheap cables fail, is at the connectors. Move then around a lot, pull them through conduits or stress the connector, and the cheaper cables are more likely to fail or cause problems handshaking.
You can also use 2 CAT6 Ethernet cables for HDMI with the appropiate connectors.
http://www.engadgethd.com/2008/02/21/brando-offers-up-cat5-cat6-hdmi-extenders/