any coin collectors here?

pokergod

Member
Apr 15, 2007
614
0
16
So I inherited a large coin collection. I have no clue what they are worth or how to sell them. I know alot of them are old quarters with silver in them. Would you hold them or sell them. for 1 quarter circulated, I can get 10 times that. Any advice on what to do? thx
 
One place to start is purchase a Red Book. Whitman Publishing I know offers one that covers both Canadian and U.S. Coins. (actual title: Checklist & Record Book of U.S. & Canadian Coins) also by the same company A Guide Book of Canadian Coins.
 
Do you have an inventory list of the collection?

You may want to get the collection appraised.

And they would know best whether to hold on to it or sell it. It may be that only some of the coins have any real sale value like 1960 and prior silver dollars.
 
Do you have an inventory list of the collection?

You may want to get the collection appraised.

And they would know best whether to hold on to it or sell it. It may be that only some of the coins have any real sale value like 1960 and prior silver dollars.

Sort of.....

Canada stopped using silver in quarters, dimes, silver dollars, 50 cent pieces in 1968 (actually, in 68, they made both silver and nickel quarters)

I'm not sure when, but at some point the mint started making silver dollars again, but not with the classic voyageurs on the backside.

It's more than just silver as well. It comes down to rarity. For example, a 1970 quarter is actually quite rare and worth more money than a 1967 quarter despite the 67 quarter being made of silver.

It also comes down to the quality of the coin. If you've got an old silver coin and it's in pristine (or proof as they are known) condition and later, "brilliant uncirculated", it's worth a lot more than one that is all scratched to hell.

Coins that were in circulation are also worth a lot less than mint sets.

Speaking of mint sets, if you have even modern mint sets, you could put them on ebay and you'll sell them for sure. (If the price is reasonable.)

Check your coins - I'm looking for a Canadian 1911 Silver Dollar. I'll give you $100.00 for it sight unseen if you have one.

:D
 
Check your coins - I'm looking for a Canadian 1911 Silver Dollar. I'll give you $100.00 for it sight unseen if you have one.

:D


[TABLE="width: 98%"]
[TR]
[TD="align: center"]LOL - "In 1911 the first Canadian silver dollar's were struck, but it was only 4 examples used to show Parliament what they might look like, and none were ever issued for circulation. Only two of the four examples are known to still exist, but they cannot be considered "Coin of the Realm", but rather they are patterns for a proposed design that was never adopted."

[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
http://www.calgarycoin.com/modern/cddollar.htm
 
My two cents is take a small sample of your collection to some coin dealers, those with a store that have been in business for a while. Don't go to one of those guys that set up in a hotel room. Get an appraisal. No obligation on your part to sell anything. When we tidied up my Mom's estate we took her coin collection to have it appraised and most coins value was in the silver content and not as a coin. It's all about condition.
 
I had a interesting conversation about coins with a hobby shop owner a few weeks ago.We were talking about collections that don't have NEAR the selling power that they used to.Unfortunately coins and stamps were on this list.Like comics, collectors of these items are not really being replaced by new generations of collectors in the last 30 years.The gent I spoke with has had many people bring their coin and stamp collections in and are shocked when A).They are not wanting to purchase them or B). at not near what they thought they were worth.

In order to have a sellers market, you need a strong buyers market and with a movement of society to digital entertainment(music,movies,TV,video games, etc etc)there's just not as big a market for physical collectables that there used to be.
 
When I looked into it and checked the book value the coins had more value for their silver content than their coin value. Even old newfie coins and 1800's quarters if they were in mint condition
It depends upon what you mean by "mint condition." I find it hard to believe that with the small mintages they had, that a nineteenth century Newfoundland coin in Proof Condition, would not be worth far more than the silver value.
 
So I inherited a large coin collection. I have no clue what they are worth or how to sell them. I know alot of them are old quarters with silver in them. Would you hold them or sell them. for 1 quarter circulated, I can get 10 times that. Any advice on what to do? thx

I'd hold them.

1) Don't sell them. Research all of them.
2) The old quarters are now at $16 USD per ounce. In the recent past, they were $51.00 USD an ounce. I'd hold them and wait for silver to go back up to $32.00 an once.

Any Gold? Gold coins, I'd sell now because QE in US is done. Silver I'd hold. (AU: $1160; AG: $16). AG more scarce than AU. Easy math there.

Gyaos.
 
As previously alluded to three concepts to educate yourself about before you talk with anyone save the very most honest and ethical are: condition (what are the coin grades - different terms for North American and British - Continental coins), absolute rarity, and condition rarity (how many were minted, how many have survived in superior grades typically they are not the same).