Another Soldier killed

spankingman

Well-known member
Dec 7, 2008
3,639
321
83
A 20 year old FEMALE soldier was killed yesterday in Afghanistan. The truck she was in hit an IED on na road they were on. Four others were injured.She had been there only TWO BLOODY WEEKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GOD bless her and all who serve.
 
Why any country is callous enough to send it's young men and women
to be killed that way, is completely beyond anything I can understand.

I truly wish they would all be called home to avoid any more deaths.
 
danmand said:
Why any country is callous enough to send it's young men and women
to be killed that way, is completely beyond anything I can understand.

I truly wish they would all be called home to avoid any more deaths.
Maybe you should try harder to understand, because this is a stupid thing to say. Canada did not send them to be killed. The Taliban killed her, not our country.

The soldiers there know what they're doing and why they are there, and don't need people here in Canada wishing they were home to avoid deaths. They're in the ARMY. To keep them home to keep them safe means disbanding the military. They go where they go when called on to serve. I remind you that they are all volunteers, too.

This is another tragic incident, but we are contributing to positive change, and none of the lives lost have been in vain. If we abandon the mission, then they will be.
 
Hangman said:
If we abandon the mission, then they will be.

That's an argument for never admitting that we were wrong. I'd say it's well past time that we got our troops out of there. Whatever progress has been made - and I'd say that'd be hard to demonstrate - isn't commensurate with the value of the lives lost.

jwm
 
The irony is that it was a female soldier fighting for democracy and human rights in a country that just tried to pass a law restricting the role of women in their society and making them chattels of their husbands.
I wonder how the Shia Muslims view the presence of women in the military fighting, in part, for their womens rights! Rights, they don't appear to want to give.
My prayers are with her family...her sacrifice will not be in vane.
 
Hangman said:
Maybe you should try harder to understand, because this is a stupid thing to say. Canada did not send them to be killed. The Taliban killed her, not our country.

The soldiers there know what they're doing and why they are there, and don't need people here in Canada wishing they were home to avoid deaths. They're in the ARMY. To keep them home to keep them safe means disbanding the military. They go where they go when called on to serve. I remind you that they are all volunteers, too.

This is another tragic incident, but we are contributing to positive change, and none of the lives lost have been in vain. If we abandon the mission, then they will be.

I have tried plenty hard. And I think I am entitled to my opinion,
just like you are entitled to yours. If you find it stupid, so be it.

See, I would be able to understand, if Canada's soldiers were over
there in a real war, in combat. But for them to drive back and forth
on roads, that are routinely mined, I find insane. The military should refuse
to expose it's soldiers to this, even if they do it willingly.

I wouldn't mind it so much if Canada sent old retired people over
there to do this. There are plenty of war-eager middle aged men,
Lancslad comes to mind, that would love to go. better them than
young men and women, who still deserve a long life ahead of them.
 
Fighting in a war in which your country no longer believes in is very difficult. All of the talk is regarding the withdrawal of troops, not aiding those in combat. Bring the troops home, restructure the war, send aid, save lives.
 
Yes, this is indeed sad news. RIP to the brave young trooper and her friends and family.

Why any country is callous enough to send it's young men and women to be killed that way, is completely beyond anything I can understand.

I truly wish they would all be called home to avoid any more deaths.

In my opinion the words in the above quote are from an ill informed individual. I'm truly sorry you feel this way.

While it is true that WAR seems senseless, it is a very necessary "evil" to beat down a MUCH worse evil in the form of opposing ideals of what many consider to be an unjust way of life.

Think what would have happened to our present society if people in the 30's felt that same way as the poster of that quote? I SHUDDER to think of life in anything but an otherwise free country. Sure we bitch about the taxes we pay and belly ache about some of the decisions our various levels of government make, but at least we have the right to do so!

My brother-in-law is an officer in our armed forces. He is not stationed overseas but would go in a heart beat if asked to. (He was deployed during the peace keeping mission in Serbia a number of years ago if memory serves). The brave men and women of our forces are fully aware of the dangers involved in their chosen vocation and are PROUD TO SERVE! But hearing attitudes such as those in the quote above do hurt their pride a little bit each time. Regardless of the reasons, they are there to do a job, and we should support them 100% until they accomplish their goal, or until the powers that be bring them home.

That's all I got to say about that!
 
Rest in Peace.....

OTB
 
danmand said:
Why any country is callous enough to send it's young men and women
to be killed that way, is completely beyond anything I can understand.

I truly wish they would all be called home to avoid any more deaths.

Think of how many American lives could have been saved if we'd followed this advice in the 40s.....

OTB
 
Cycleguy007 said:
Think what would have happened to our present society if people in the 30's felt that same way as the poster of that quote? I SHUDDER to think of life in anything but an otherwise free country. Sure we bitch about the taxes we pay and belly ache about some of the decisions our various levels of government make, but at least we have the right to do so!

Canada's role is anything but a goodwill measure. We're there to appease the Americans...and who gave us the right to superimpose our values and way of life on another country..
 
onthebottom said:
Think of how many American lives could have been saved if we'd followed this advice in the 40s.....

OTB

America was directly attacked in the 40s...I don't recall Canada being a victim of a direct attack that would demand a reciprocal measure
 
max_2002 said:
XXXXX XXXXX was with the XXX Battalion of the XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXXX Group, the famed Quebec regiment nicknamed the XXXX XXXX.

She was killed Monday when the armoured vehicle she was travelling in rolled over an improvised explosive device.

Her' godfather said: that it's time for Canada to pull out of Afghanistan.
XXXX XXXX said relatives are in shock and that the family wasn't happy his goddaughter chose a career in the military.
XXXXX leaves behind her mother XXXXX, her grandmother XXXXXX and her brother, XXXXX.


Rest in Peace Trooper XXXXX. My Prayers to the family.

Max
Probably not a good Idea to mention names as well as other personal info on an escort review website... dontcha think?

People googling it may accidentally find it and get the wrong idea... :o
 
Last edited:
Plan B said:
America was directly attacked in the 40s...I don't recall Canada being a victim of a direct attack that would demand a reciprocal measure

I'm not going to respond to this, not because there isn't a response but out of respect to the very important topic of the thread.

My deepest respect to all soldiers who are injured or give their life in service.....

OTB
 
Plan B said:
Canada's role is anything but a goodwill measure. We're there to appease the Americans...and who gave us the right to superimpose our values and way of life on another country..

Has nothing to do with the USA... but everything to do with our commitment to a small military agreement, (you may have heard of it...) called the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, (AKA N.A.T.O.), since Louis Stephen St-Laurent signed the agreement at the time of its inception on April 4th 1949. :rolleyes:
 
Any further posting of family names will result in an immediate banning.
 
Plan B said:
America was directly attacked in the 40s...I don't recall Canada being a victim of a direct attack that would demand a reciprocal measure
I don't recall Canada having been attacked at all before it declared war in 1939 and then again in 1941 - so therefore your point is?
 
Mr. Lucky said:
Only 2 weeks and just 20 years old.. R.I.P.
It is indeed horrible. Unfortunately she is not the first nor shall be the last.

President Lincoln who had a way with words perhaps said it best.