Another dumbass lawsuit coming

As much as I hate to agree with Lisa

She is right. That was a definite safety violation, and completely negligent on the part of the city workers. She has good grounds for a law suit.
 
She's completely right.

It's fine to watch where you're going, but it's also reasonable to assume that you can walk and take your eyes off the ground to text without falling into a manhole. If you have to worry about the possibility of falling into a manhole every second you're walking, that's fucked that.
 
a 1 player said:
As much as I hate to agree with Lisa
Lisa of Toronto said:
you love to hate me

lol why what did i do to you?
Do you have reading comprehension problems??
 
The story said she only suffered cuts and bruises.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't you have to suffer damages to win a lawsuit. Like you were permanently injured and can't walk and therefore can't work. That's damages.

Cuts and bruises because of stupidity on both the city workers and her part frankly don't qualify for big bucks.

Too many people are lawsuit crazy these days and figure that their ship has finally come in.
 
james t kirk said:
The story said she only suffered cuts and bruises.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't you have to suffer damages to win a lawsuit. Like you were permanently injured and can't walk and therefore can't work. That's damages. . . .

Too many people are lawsuit crazy these days and figure that their ship has finally come in.
Philosophically I largely agree with you. But legally cuts and bruises are certainly enough physical injury to bring suit. Now the extent of your injuries certainly do go to damages. . . . New York is a “pure comparative negligence” state. Should the girl prevail in a lawsuit her award will be reduced by the percentage (if any) that she is found to have been herself at fault for her injury.
 
WTF how about people paying attention to where they are going?? First you had that girl who got run over in Toronto because she was texting and walked into a truck. Another girl gets drunk and falls backwards into traffic and gets run over. Now you have another girl fall in a manhole. Rollerbladers, cyclists, pedestrians all blasting their music and playing on their phones are hazards. Can't see or hear. Sorry, no sympathy from me.
 
Should the workers have left the manhole open and unattended? - No
Should the girl have been texting on her phone instead of watching what was going on around her? - No

Should she be entitled to some compensation? Yes as the workers were negligent, but not much more than the cost of fixing up her scrapes IMO.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Philosophically I largely agree with you. But legally cuts and bruises are certainly enough physical injury to bring suit. Now the extent of your injuries certainly do go to damages. . . . New York is a “pure comparative negligence” state. Should the girl prevail in a lawsuit her award will be reduced by the percentage (if any) that she is found to have been herself at fault for her injury.

Right. This should not be one of those outlandish suits. Just minor compensation. Nonetheless it's important. She potentially could have gotten seriously hurt.

If the cones were in place and sectioned off that area and she fell in, it would be her fault. But that wasn't the case.

Don said:
WTF how about people paying attention to where they are going?? First you had that girl who got run over in Toronto because she was texting and walked into a truck. Another girl gets drunk and falls backwards into traffic and gets run over. Now you have another girl fall in a manhole. Rollerbladers, cyclists, pedestrians all blasting their music and playing on their phones are hazards. Can't see or hear. Sorry, no sympathy from me.

The girl that walked into a truck - that's her fault. A woman once ran in front of my car and I hit her. It was her fault stepping into oncoming traffic. There were no crossways or lights there so she should have waited for traffic to pass. Ditto for the drunk girl - her fault.

Those examples are different than falling into an unattended manhole.