Animated fear about crime
By Kris Kotarski, For the Calgary HeraldJuly 25, 2011
Last week, Canadians found out our crime rate has dropped to the lowest level in nearly four decades. According to Statistics Canada, police services reported fewer crimes in 2010 than in any year since 1973, and the crime rate has continued its 20-year descent, despite the economic crisis.
This decline includes violent crime, which is at its lowest point since 1998, and the homicide rate, which is at its lowest level since 1966. It includes robberies, car thefts and other property crime, which are following multi-year downward trends.
Why is this relevant? Because despite the statistics and in the absence of common sense, Prime Minister Stephen Harper seems hellbent on creating Canada's version of Springfield's Bear Patrol.
On May 5, 1996, the fictional town of Springfield succumbed to a panic attack when "a large, bearlike animal, most likely a bear" wandered down the hill into the town "in search of food or perhaps employment."
When he saw the bear, Homer Simpson's neighbour, Ned Flanders, crashed his car into a tree.
The bear was tranquillized and taken away, but that did not matter. What followed was a perfect illustration of our media/ political culture. Sensationalist news reporting led to popular fear; the residents formed a mob and marched into the mayor's office demanding protection from "these constant bear attacks."
Thus, the Springfield Bear Patrol was born, equipped with ambulances, helicopters and a hefty tax bill.
This is not terribly different from Canada in the past few years, where media coverage of gang violence and other rare but highprofile crime stories (the G8 violence and the Vancouver hockey riot are perfect examples) has created an atmosphere of anxiety at odds with reality.
Into this void steps Harper and his Conservative Party, which prides itself on being "tough on crime," a popular rhetorical position that is all emotion and no substance, at least not for tackling Canada's already-falling crime rates.
Does it work? Sure it does. Just as Springfield's mob supported the Bear Patrol boondoggle, many Canadians believe this country is caught up in a crime wave and the situation can be improved through more prisons, longer mandatory sentences, and harsher laws targeted at youth offences.
The problem is, just as there was never a bear problem that the town of Springfield could not handle with its police force, there is no sign there is anything in our society that our present laws, our generally competent police forces and our judges cannot deal with at the moment.
The Harper government is planning to shift to a jailintensive approach to youth crime, a move that has baffled criminologists and judges in the U.S., U.K. and Australia where similar approaches have been shown to fail over the past couple of decades.
The government is planning big investments in additional prison spaces and imposing mandatory sentencing guidelines and new crime legislation that would fill those prisons with inmates.
Again, Statistics Canada reports the crime rate is at its lowest since 1973.
Homicides are down to 1966 levels.
Why should Canadians stand by as the Harper government assembles its own Bear Patrol at taxpayers' expense and to society's detriment?
The same Simpsons episode contained a great discussion of faulty reasoning, which should be mentioned to anyone who supports this set of Harper policies.
While a Bear Patrol helicopter patrols overhead, Homer proudly declares that there is not a bear in sight.
Lisa: By your logic I could claim that this rock keeps tigers away.
Homer: Oh, how does it work?
Lisa: It doesn't work.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: It's just a stupid rock.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: But I don't see any tigers around, do you?
(Homer thinks of this, then pulls out some money)
Homer: Lisa, I want to buy your rock.
Read more: http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Animated+fear+about+crime/5153477/story.html#ixzz1TPQkBY00
By Kris Kotarski, For the Calgary HeraldJuly 25, 2011
Last week, Canadians found out our crime rate has dropped to the lowest level in nearly four decades. According to Statistics Canada, police services reported fewer crimes in 2010 than in any year since 1973, and the crime rate has continued its 20-year descent, despite the economic crisis.
This decline includes violent crime, which is at its lowest point since 1998, and the homicide rate, which is at its lowest level since 1966. It includes robberies, car thefts and other property crime, which are following multi-year downward trends.
Why is this relevant? Because despite the statistics and in the absence of common sense, Prime Minister Stephen Harper seems hellbent on creating Canada's version of Springfield's Bear Patrol.
On May 5, 1996, the fictional town of Springfield succumbed to a panic attack when "a large, bearlike animal, most likely a bear" wandered down the hill into the town "in search of food or perhaps employment."
When he saw the bear, Homer Simpson's neighbour, Ned Flanders, crashed his car into a tree.
The bear was tranquillized and taken away, but that did not matter. What followed was a perfect illustration of our media/ political culture. Sensationalist news reporting led to popular fear; the residents formed a mob and marched into the mayor's office demanding protection from "these constant bear attacks."
Thus, the Springfield Bear Patrol was born, equipped with ambulances, helicopters and a hefty tax bill.
This is not terribly different from Canada in the past few years, where media coverage of gang violence and other rare but highprofile crime stories (the G8 violence and the Vancouver hockey riot are perfect examples) has created an atmosphere of anxiety at odds with reality.
Into this void steps Harper and his Conservative Party, which prides itself on being "tough on crime," a popular rhetorical position that is all emotion and no substance, at least not for tackling Canada's already-falling crime rates.
Does it work? Sure it does. Just as Springfield's mob supported the Bear Patrol boondoggle, many Canadians believe this country is caught up in a crime wave and the situation can be improved through more prisons, longer mandatory sentences, and harsher laws targeted at youth offences.
The problem is, just as there was never a bear problem that the town of Springfield could not handle with its police force, there is no sign there is anything in our society that our present laws, our generally competent police forces and our judges cannot deal with at the moment.
The Harper government is planning to shift to a jailintensive approach to youth crime, a move that has baffled criminologists and judges in the U.S., U.K. and Australia where similar approaches have been shown to fail over the past couple of decades.
The government is planning big investments in additional prison spaces and imposing mandatory sentencing guidelines and new crime legislation that would fill those prisons with inmates.
Again, Statistics Canada reports the crime rate is at its lowest since 1973.
Homicides are down to 1966 levels.
Why should Canadians stand by as the Harper government assembles its own Bear Patrol at taxpayers' expense and to society's detriment?
The same Simpsons episode contained a great discussion of faulty reasoning, which should be mentioned to anyone who supports this set of Harper policies.
While a Bear Patrol helicopter patrols overhead, Homer proudly declares that there is not a bear in sight.
Lisa: By your logic I could claim that this rock keeps tigers away.
Homer: Oh, how does it work?
Lisa: It doesn't work.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: It's just a stupid rock.
Homer: Uh-huh.
Lisa: But I don't see any tigers around, do you?
(Homer thinks of this, then pulls out some money)
Homer: Lisa, I want to buy your rock.
Read more: http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Animated+fear+about+crime/5153477/story.html#ixzz1TPQkBY00

