Andy Pettitte

No, I just remember Aaron Hill stealing home on Pettitte when his back was turned. It was a humiliating moment for Andy.
 
Last edited:
No, I just remember Aaron Hill stealing home on Pettitte when his back was turned. It was a humiliating moment for Andy.
He did win over 250 games but then there was that HGH controversy.
 
As a Yankee fan I want to say yes but the HGH allegations he made regarding Roger Clemens are not cool.

He accepted his role in taking HGH for recovery purposes. Okay I'll buy that and understand it but leave Roger out of it.

Record wise he's got a good one and his postseason record of 19-11 with a 3.81 ERA gainst the best teams is solid.

The whole PED thing is murky....I'm a traditionalist at heart....So I'm on the fence for now with Pettitte.
 
As a Yankee fan I want to say yes but the HGH allegations he made regarding Roger Clemens are not cool.

He accepted his role in taking HGH for recovery purposes. Okay I'll buy that and understand it but leave Roger out of it.

Record wise he's got a good one and his postseason record of 19-11 with a 3.81 ERA gainst the best teams is solid.

The whole PED thing is murky....I'm a traditionalist at heart....So I'm on the fence for now with Pettitte.
I was thinking if Pettitte got in, that should pave the way for Clemens.