Android: So open that Google is going against net neutrality

djk

Active member
Apr 8, 2002
5,937
0
36
the hobby needs more capitalism
In other words, Google and Verizon are working together to make it that if you do not use an Android phone on Verizon's network, you will experience slower speeds than if you did.

This completely goes against the Internet's open nature. Unlike some so-called death grip that has impacted 0.05% of Apple's customer base, if this goes through it will impact 100% of Verizon's non-Android using customers.

Shame on Google.

http://www.dslreports.com/shownews/To-Be-Clear-Google-bISb-Fighting-Real-Net-Neutrality-Rules-109784

http://voices.washingtonpost.com/posttech/2010/08/google_and_verizon_have_come.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2010/08/05/technology/05secret.html?scp=2&sq=verizon&st=cse

Google and Verizon, two leading players in Internet service and content, are nearing an agreement that could allow Verizon to speed some online content to Internet users more quickly if the content’s creators are willing to pay for the privilege.

The charges could be paid by companies, like YouTube, owned by Google, for example, to Verizon, one of the nation’s leading Internet service providers, to ensure that its content received priority as it made its way to consumers. The agreement could eventually lead to higher charges for Internet users.

Such an agreement could overthrow a once-sacred tenet of Internet policy known as net neutrality, in which no form of content is favored over another. In its place, consumers could soon see a new, tiered system, which, like cable television, imposes higher costs for premium levels of service.

Any agreement between Verizon and Google could also upend the efforts of the Federal Communications Commission to assert its authority over broadband service, which was severely restricted by a federal appeals court decision in April.

People close to the negotiations who were not authorized to speak publicly about them said an agreement could be reached as soon as next week. If completed, Google, whose Android operating system powers many Verizon wireless phones, would agree not to challenge Verizon’s ability to manage its broadband Internet network as it pleased.
 
you can be such a twit djk and jump the gun every time, before there is substantial evidence to the claims you post.
Google and Verizon denies the web deal to threaten Net Neutrality
Google has now dismissed the report that the NYT has published on the issue, the spokesperson of Google has said that they never had any conversation on the payment for the carriage of Google traffic. The Guardian quotes the Google man stating that Google will remain committed to provide open internet.

Google denies deal to end net neutrality
Search giant says there is no agreement allowing telecoms company Verizon to prioritise the order and speed in which it delivers content to users



here you go dozens of other sources
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...vwUoAQ&q=google+denies+net+neutrality&spell=1


nice try though (NOT)

shame on djk!! ;) what say you now??
 
A look at the news has it potentially far more wide reaching than the usual android vs. iphone partisans.

It is also a bit comical since net neutrality seems to only be a western ideal. Saudi and BB, China and google. I even remember something about Australia and limiting some access. There are enough examples.



p.s. there are two great android phones now available in canada.
http://www.telusmobility.com/en/ON/htc_desire/index.shtml
http://www.bell.ca/shopping/Samsung-Galaxy-SVibrant/70269.details

The screen on the galaxy is absolutely phenomenal. Blows everything else out of the water - including the ip4. To bad they have sub-par software and are dam ugly. The desire is a solid phone too. The ip4 is a great too. I'd say my future choice is a toss up.
 
Probably true, who knows. It's only a matter of time before a ton of people are on these networks and flooding it, in turn having some effect on speeds.

Gotta see the Galaxy in action, as well as the HTC (I'm sure they're great), but there's just something more appealing to me in the iPhone.
 
you can be such a twit djk and jump the gun every time, before there is substantial evidence to the claims you post.
Google and Verizon denies the web deal to threaten Net Neutrality
Google has now dismissed the report that the NYT has published on the issue, the spokesperson of Google has said that they never had any conversation on the payment for the carriage of Google traffic. The Guardian quotes the Google man stating that Google will remain committed to provide open internet.

Google denies deal to end net neutrality
Search giant says there is no agreement allowing telecoms company Verizon to prioritise the order and speed in which it delivers content to users



here you go dozens of other sources
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&...vwUoAQ&q=google+denies+net+neutrality&spell=1


nice try though (NOT)

shame on djk!! ;) what say you now??

Of course, Google is going to deny. They got caught with their hand in the cookie jar by the NYT. All you posted is they issued a denial.

From the NYT article:

A spokesman for Verizon said that the company was still engaged in the larger talks to reach a consensus at the F.C.C. and declined to comment on other negotiations. A spokeswoman for Google also declined to comment. While a deal between Google and Verizon would affect only those two companies, it could sway the opinions of lawmakers, many of whom have questioned the wisdom of the F.C.C.’s plans to oversee broadband service.

LOLOL, PUMP IT!
 
Of course, Google is going to deny. They got caught with their hand in the cookie jar by the NYT. All you posted is they issued a denial.

From the NYT article:



LOLOL, PUMP IT!

lol so you're calling Google a liar? you do know that Google have openly supported net neutrality for a number of years? and even have a page on their website regarding that issue...

A Note to Google Users on Net Neutrality:
The Internet as we know it is facing a serious threat. There's a debate heating up in Washington, DC on something called "net neutrality" – and it's a debate that's so important Google is asking you to get involved. We're asking you to take action to protect Internet freedom.

In the next few days, the House of Representatives is going to vote on a bill that would fundamentally alter the Internet. That bill, and one that may come up for a key vote in the Senate in the next few weeks, would give the big phone and cable companies the power to pick and choose what you will be able to see and do on the Internet.

Today the Internet is an information highway where anybody – no matter how large or small, how traditional or unconventional – has equal access. But the phone and cable monopolies, who control almost all Internet access, want the power to choose who gets access to high-speed lanes and whose content gets seen first and fastest. They want to build a two-tiered system and block the on-ramps for those who can't pay.

Creativity, innovation and a free and open marketplace are all at stake in this fight. Please call your representative (202-224-3121) and let your voice be heard.

Thanks for your time, your concern and your support.

Eric Schmidt


again, nice try djk (not)

if you believe the New York Times , then you also believe Steve Jobs knew about the iPhone 4 design flaw before the phone was released :P
as it was reported there as well as many other sources

Net Neutrality has always been an important issue with Google.

Google public policy blog page
http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/search/label/Net Neutrality
 
They got caught with their hand in the cookie jar by the NYT.

if it's in the NYT then it must be true huh djk? LOLZ

The Truth About Google, Verizon and Net Neutrality

News Analysis: The New York Times and other publications failed in their journalistic mission to tell the truth about the potential Google-Verizon deal. Here's what an agreement between the two could mean for net neutrality.

It's true that there's something going on between Google and Verizon regarding net neutrality, but it's not a business deal. While neither company is commenting specifically on what their discussions have been about, the information Google and Verizon provided makes the direction pretty clear.

The bottom line is this: Google would like to see network providers make provisions for certain types of traffic so that it can be delivered in a useful manner. Google is talking to Verizon because its FiOS service is very hot these days and provides very high-speed networking where consistent delivery is important for things like video.

This means that Google is looking for a way to have material such as video and voice services delivered with their priority set so that the material is still useful when it gets delivered. For example, if voice traffic suffers from too much latency or jitter in transit, it's nearly unintelligible to the listener. You've probably heard this kind of thing on a Skype call if you were on a bad connection or on a cell phone call when the cell user had a really crummy signal.

With video, delivery is also important, although interestingly it's not as sensitive to issues such as latency as voice. But when video doesn't get the delivery it needs, then you see the picture simply stop, or you see it dissolve into those blocks that you sometimes also see on your HDTV when an airplane flies over your antenna in just the right spot. But for reasons I won't go into here, our brains can deal with more interruption to video than to audio.

In either case, reliable delivery is important for these services to be usable. Google's belief, according to a statement made by CEO Eric Schmidt during an impromptu news conference on Aug. 4, is that network providers should be able to differentiate service types so that voice traffic gets delivered intact, for example, but not prioritize one provider's voice or video over another's.

What Schmidt is saying, in other words, is he thinks it's OK for networks to prioritize packets that need to be high priority due to their content. What this means is that network providers should be able to manage their networks to recognize packets that need to be a high priority for delivery and honor that priority.

If this sounds familiar it's probably because you're doing that in your enterprise already. You call it QOS (quality of service), and it's a critical feature for some types of traffic, especially the voice traffic that is handled by your VOIP (voice over IP) phone system. What Schmidt is suggesting is that Internet providers do the same thing.

cont....Nothing to Gain
 
Nothing to Gain....cont...

Verizon, for its part, is also denying any sort of business deal with Google. More likely the two companies are hammering out a way to provide the priority some streaming traffic needs while remaining within the bounds of net neutrality. As eWEEK Senior Staff Writer Clint Boulton mentions in his story about the supposed Google-Verizon deal, both companies deny that anything nefarious is going on.
In fact, there's little to be gained by either company in setting up some sort of exclusive deal for Verizon to deliver Google's traffic in preference to other traffic. It would cost Verizon more money, and it's hard to see how the company would benefit. Google, meanwhile, doesn't really need more than it has now in terms of delivery, although it would probably help YouTube's video quality to get the video stream delivered reliably. But this is true for every ISP, not just Verizon, so setting up a deal just with Verizon wouldn't really help Google, either.

Instead, what will come out of the net neutrality discussions between the companies is an agreement in principle that network providers should be allowed to honor the priorities set for streaming traffic, as long as they do it for everybody. This doesn't give YouTube any kind of benefit over another video provider—after all, setting QOS levels on video or voice packets is hardly rocket science, and it doesn't take anything special in terms of equipment or software. All that's really required is a general agreement that it's OK, and for network providers to provision their routers to honor the priority settings.

So how did The New York Times manage to make this into a threat to net neutrality? It appears that the reporter was swayed by a single advocacy group, Public Knowledge. The group's claims regarding net neutrality have always been at the extreme end of the hard line, and the quotes in the Times article are no exception.
 
cont...

What's harder to understand is how a journalist could base a story on unsubstantiated claims from a single group with a stake in the outcome of the article. But The New York Times has always been fairly inept when it comes to covering technology, and its understanding of the issues involving net neutrality has been tenuous at best. In other words, we've gone through two days of kerfuffle based on sloppy reporting, lazy journalism and technology coverage from a publication that doesn't understand technology.

I should also add that apparently The New York Times doesn't actually understand the technology business, either. A key point in its story is the relationship between Google and Verizon because of its Droid devices that run Google's Android operating system. The problem with this is that there is no relationship between the two companies here. Verizon Wireless, which sells the Android devices, is a separate company. It's a joint venture between Verizon and Vodafone, and Verizon (the phone company) has no operational role in Verizon Wireless. You'd think that even a really junior reporter would take the trouble to learn this.

The bottom line is that all of this gnashing of teeth has had only one useful result, which was prodding the FCC to call off its secret talks about net neutrality. The fact that everything else about this story was just plain wrong doesn't make this right, but it was still a good outcome. The FCC should be public and upfront in its discussions about net neutrality. And meanwhile, The New York Times should stick to covering the New York social scene, where it has some expertise.
 
A look at the news has it potentially far more wide reaching than the usual android vs. iphone partisans.

It is also a bit comical since net neutrality seems to only be a western ideal. Saudi and BB, China and google. I even remember something about Australia and limiting some access. There are enough examples.



p.s. there are two great android phones now available in canada.
http://www.telusmobility.com/en/ON/htc_desire/index.shtml
http://www.bell.ca/shopping/Samsung-Galaxy-SVibrant/70269.details

The screen on the galaxy is absolutely phenomenal. Blows everything else out of the water - including the ip4. To bad they have sub-par software and are dam ugly. The desire is a solid phone too. The ip4 is a great too. I'd say my future choice is a toss up.

yes, i have heard many reports that it's 4' screen is easily the best available, even better than retina display ;) looks wise it's like an iPhone 3gs

and yes i agree net neutrality sadly seems to be a western ideal.
 
Probably true, who knows. It's only a matter of time before a ton of people are on these networks and flooding it, in turn having some effect on speeds.

Gotta see the Galaxy in action,
As I said, the screen is incredible way above the iphone IMO. Futureshop, best buy all have them.

but there's just something more appealing to me in the iPhone.
I know it will run contrary to most of the android/iPhone discussions but Chacun à son goût; vive la différence.
 
I heard Vic is changing his slogan to "One Company. One Carrier. Two Internets".

Nothing new here!
Dubya has been using the Internets for years!.....:p