Android Fragmentation - It's a Great Experience - Larry Page

danibbler

Active member
Feb 2, 2002
2,241
0
36
Toronto
It's not often I listen to Google's earnings calls but yesterday I looked over a transcript of its latest and here is what Larry Page has to say about fragmentation on the Android platform:

There are differences like that which are somewhat fragmented. I find that a pretty great overall experience

So, are they going to do anything about it? No.
 
It's not often I listen to Google's earnings calls but yesterday I looked over a transcript of its latest and here is what Larry Page has to say about fragmentation on the Android platform:



So, are they going to do anything about it? No.

????

Unlike apple, the variety of platforms is a strength of android. Why would they stop?
 
Apparently, you don't understand the problem for users.

Nobody demonstrates that better than you salesman nibs.
As was pointed out on you in another thread here, ignorance is bliss.....;)
 
Apparently, you don't understand the problem for users.

I'm not sure if you understand the benefits for users. If you have a MAC computer this may not help but if you are a PC user, you know that when you buy HP, DELL, IBM ,etc - you will get a Windows computer with an enhanced manufacturer user interface that forms a signature of that manufacturer but in the end - they all run Windows software. The story can be similar for Android.

Let's look at the NFC functionality offered on Android phones (not available on iPhone). Android Beam is allows messages to be transmitted simple by touching the Android phones together. The benefits are the ability to instantly message between devices without pairing, addressing, etc. This works between all NFC Android devices. Samsung has enhanced this technology further by allowing complete file transfers between Samsung devices. They use the NFC capability to set up a WiFi Direct connection so that files up to 1 Gig can be shared between devices.

This is part of the Android 'fragmentation' that you suggest is bad for users. If Android was locked down like Apple iOS - Samsung innovation would never happen but it isn't and it helps spur innovation. Android apps will still run on Android products but the downside is that new Android releases vary as manufacturers incorporate their own features with it. This same variation is very evident in camera functionality between Android products.

I think an analogy of Apple iOS and Android would help here. Think of Apple like Communist China - everyone has the same thing, innovation is strictly controlled, everything is in the same shade of pale grey. Android is like capitalism - individual freedom is encouraged not repressed, ideas may flourish, your selection of smartphones varies to meet your individual needs. You have your choice of keyboards, players, software, content - your universe is filled with colours and uninhibited choices.

So now you have the choice of having big brother decide for you and the other iPhone users (the the safest road) .... or ... freedom to choose and enter a world that spawns innovation and individualization.
 
Apparently, you don't understand the problem for users.

Maybe it's a problem for iphone users to have too many choices but having used 3 android, a blackberry and an iPhone I can't see it as anything other than an apple fanboy trying to feel good about himself by bashing a different system.
 
I think an analogy of Apple iOS and Android would help here. Think of Apple like Communist China - everyone has the same thing, innovation is strictly controlled, everything is in the same shade of pale grey. Android is like capitalism - individual freedom is encouraged not repressed, ideas may flourish, your selection of smartphones varies to meet your individual needs. You have your choice of keyboards, players, software, content - your universe is filled with colours and uninhibited choices.

So now you have the choice of having big brother decide for you and the other iPhone users (the the safest road) .... or ... freedom to choose and enter a world that spawns innovation and individualization.

Excellent analogy!!!

Face it some folks like freedom, while others/fanbois prefer being herded as sheep in a closed pen!.....:eyebrows:
 
It's like Windows. MS advertised improved stability as a feature for every release, lmao.
 
Linux has always been incredibly stable, faster and far more secure than M$, as you have discovered.....:thumb:

Currently there are over a 100 flavors of Linux to choose from, most completely free because unlike M$ and Apple, Linux overall is not out there to make a fast buck. Although there are some for-profit versions of Linux out there, that I've never had need of. By using Linux you are on your way to being FREE of having M$ and Apple continually picking your pockets!

It's nice being FREE......:cool:
 
Maybe it's a problem for iphone users to have too many choices but having used 3 android, a blackberry and an iPhone I can't see it as anything other than an apple fanboy trying to feel good about himself by bashing a different system.

I currently have three phones...iPhone 4S, Samsung Galaxy S I, and a Nokia...that I use.

The Nokia is a C series phone with a QWERTY keyboard. Fantastic for texting but not much else. Really like it.
 
Where is my benefit when my Galaxy S I (three years old) cannot run the latest Android when an acquaintance's iPhone 3GS can run almost all of the latest iOS?

Define "Run". Is that like video game system recommendations? Run used to mean, "Will Load", but there is no way a 3GS is able to run iOS 6.0 or higher as that system was meant to run. I know, I upgraded from a 3GS to a 5. The iOS updates made my old 3GS less and less useful from somewhere in the high iOS 5 iterations.

I'm no fanboy and I'm not 100% a fan of android either. Both have their issues. Its all a matter of which deficiencies you can most live with.