Analyst says Wilson

onthebottom

Never Been Justly Banned
Jan 10, 2002
40,880
197
63
Hooterville
www.scubadiving.com
Can't really vouch for the source but thought this was interesting:

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=47242

...

A retired Army general says the man at the center of the CIA leak controversy, Ambassador Joseph C. Wilson, revealed his wife Valerie Plame's employment with the agency in a casual conversation more than a year before she allegedly was "outed" by the White House through a columnist.

Maj. Gen. Paul Vallely told WorldNetDaily that Wilson mentioned Plame's status as a CIA employee over the course of at least three, possibly five, conversations in 2002 in the Fox News Channel's "green room" in Washington, D.C., as they waited to appear on air as analysts.

.....

"He was rather open about his wife working at the CIA," said Vallely, who retired in 1991 as the Army's deputy commanding general in the Pacific.

Vallely made his claim in an interview Thursday night on the ABC radio network's John Batchelor show.

.......

Vallely said, citing CIA colleagues, that in addition to his conversations with Wilson, the ambassador was proud to introduce Plame at cocktail parties and other social events around Washington as his CIA wife.

"That was pretty common knowledge," he said. "She's been out there on the Washington scene many years."

If Plame were a covert agent at the time, Vallely said, "he would not have paraded her around as he did."

"This whole thing has become the biggest non-story I know," he concluded, "and all created by Joe Wilson."

......

Wilson traveled to Niger in February 2002 on a CIA-sponsored trip to check out the allegations about Iraq and wrote up his findings in a July 6, 2003, New York Times opinion piece titled "What I Didn't Find in Africa."

White House defenders insist the aides simply were setting the record straight about Wilson, seeking to put his credibility in context by pointing out it was Plame who helped him get the CIA consulting job. Wilson denied his wife's role initially, but a bipartisan report by the Senate panel documented it.

OTB
 
Suck it, OTB

From: http://americablog.blogspot.com/

Two GOP attack dogs (who are regular pundits on FOX and have been published by Regnery, the nutty GOP publishing arm) are now trying to spread a lie about Joe Wilson, saying he revealed to them in a casual conversation in the Green Room at FOX News in 2002 (a year before Novak outed Valerie Wilson) that Valerie worked at the CIA.

Amb. Wilson says categorically that this never happened - like he'd blare this to two total strangers, at FOX News no less - but the two FOX News pundit-authors, who of course suddenly appear out of nowhere two years into the investigation once Scooter is indicted and the Bush White House is falling apart at the seams, are now intent on spreading their suddenly rediscovered "memory."

The phony report was first published at WorldNetDaily, then it was repeated tonight on the convervative talk radio John Batchelor Show. Batchelor received but refused to include the statement, below, by Amb. Wilson's and Valerie Plame's lawyer Christopher Wolf.

This is yet another clear effort by the pro-treason wing of the Republican party to resurrect Swift Boat Veteran tactics as a counter-offensive in RoveGate. I hope Wilson sues their asses off.

And lest these guys forget, it was the same Christopher Wolf, Wilson's lawyer, who sued USA Next for $25 million for stealing the wedding photo of the gay couple and using it in a homophobic anti-AARP ad. You haven't heard squat from USA Next after that little suit was filed (the suit is still ongoing). Here's hoping Wolf does an equally good job ripping these bozos.

Here's the letter from Wolf that the conservative stations don't want you to hear:

Dear Mr. Batchelor:

We have seen your posting which states that

Lt. General Tom McInerney, USAF (ret), West Point '59, will join his colleague Maj. General Paul Vallely, USA (ret), West Point '61, on my show Monday 7 November (1005 pm Eastern Time on ABC Radio Network) to repeat and expand upon Vallely's memory that Joe Wilson more than once in 2002 in the green room at Fox New Channel in Washington D.C. boasted about his wife the "CIA desk officer." McInerney has the same memory and more, since both he and Vallely were on FNC between 150 and 200 times in 2002 each.

Please be advised that the proffered allegations are utterly false and are intended to defame our client Ambassador Wilson. Broadcasting such statements will subject you to liability as the statements are knowingly false or made in reckless disregard of the trust or falsity.

We note that you have not invited any representative of Ambassador Wilson to appear on your program in order to allow the record to be corrected. Accordingly, if you insist on broadcasting the scurrilous allegations, as you threaten to do, we ask that the following statement be read in its entirety on the air:

(continued)
 
More than two years after the start of the investigation into who leaked the identity of Valerie Wilson's secret CIA identity, Thomas McInerney and Paul Vallely, FOX News commentators and co-authors of a book published by right-wing Regnery Publishing, reportedly have come forward to falsely claim that Ambassador Joseph Wilson told them of his wife's role at the CIA before the July 2003 column by Robert Novak -- the column which revealed for the first time that Ms. Wilson was a CIA operative. It is reported that they claim Ambassador Wilson casually and repeatedly disclosed his wife's status in the waiting area at the FOX News studio in Washington, DC. Those allegations are utterly false and are defamatory. At no time did Ambassador Wilson disclose his wife's CIA employment to these people. The statements appear to be invented solely to discredit Ambassador Wilson in the wake of the indictment of I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby.

The fact that these persons have not come forward with these reported recollections until now, more than two years after the start of the highly-visible, nationally-watched investigation into who revealed Ms. Wilson's secret CIA identity, is strong evidence by itself that their alleged recollections are invented, and false. Moreover, since Ambassador Wilson never disclosed his wife's status to anyone, including close friends, it is preposterous to suggest that he would have shared the information with strangers in a waiting room. Their allegations are similar to that of the Washington Times newspaper which in an editorial claimed "that numerous neighbors were aware that she worked for the agency", when there was no basis whatsoever for that claim, as demonstrated by a news article written by the Washington Times own reporter.

It has been reported that an individual named Victor Davis Hanson also has said that Ambassador Wilson told Mr. Hanson in a waiting room that Valerie Wilson worked at the CIA. In a telephone call initiated by Cliff Kincaid of Accuracy in Media today to counsel for Ambassador Wilson, Mr. Kincaid reported that he has spoken with Mr. Hanson, and that Mr. Hanson denies that Ambassador Wilson spoke to him about Valerie Wilson's CIA employment. Mr. Kincaid also said that while his organization, in his words, "has had its differences with Mr. Wilson", it is not proper to make things up and he intended to correct the record in an upcoming edition of Accuracy in Media's Web Site.

To suggest that Ambassador Wilson breached his own wife's secret CIA status is inexcusable and is a further attempt to smear Mr. Wilson. While one is tempted not to dignify such attacks with a response, the willingness of others to republish the scurrilous statements by these persons requires this response.
 
onthebottom said:
Can't really vouch for the source but thought this was interesting:

http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=47242

...

A retired Army general says the man at the center of the CIA leak controversy, Ambassador Joseph C. Wilson, revealed his wife Valerie Plame's employment with the agency in a casual conversation more than a year before she allegedly was "outed" by the White House through a columnist.

Maj. Gen. Paul Vallely told WorldNetDaily that Wilson mentioned Plame's status as a CIA employee over the course of at least three, possibly five, conversations in 2002 in the Fox News Channel's "green room" in Washington, D.C., as they waited to appear on air as analysts.

.....

"He was rather open about his wife working at the CIA," said Vallely, who retired in 1991 as the Army's deputy commanding general in the Pacific.

Vallely made his claim in an interview Thursday night on the ABC radio network's John Batchelor show.

.......

Vallely said, citing CIA colleagues, that in addition to his conversations with Wilson, the ambassador was proud to introduce Plame at cocktail parties and other social events around Washington as his CIA wife.

"That was pretty common knowledge," he said. "She's been out there on the Washington scene many years."

If Plame were a covert agent at the time, Vallely said, "he would not have paraded her around as he did."

"This whole thing has become the biggest non-story I know," he concluded, "and all created by Joe Wilson."

......

Wilson traveled to Niger in February 2002 on a CIA-sponsored trip to check out the allegations about Iraq and wrote up his findings in a July 6, 2003, New York Times opinion piece titled "What I Didn't Find in Africa."

White House defenders insist the aides simply were setting the record straight about Wilson, seeking to put his credibility in context by pointing out it was Plame who helped him get the CIA consulting job. Wilson denied his wife's role initially, but a bipartisan report by the Senate panel documented it.

OTB

With all the information out there i will wait for the final verdict on this. Too much information is not good either.
With out a doubt..Wilson is no choirboy either...
 
TOV,

So, he denies it......

OK then

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
TOV,

So, he denies it......

OK then

OTB

Yeah OTB. Joe Wilson is just sitting around the FOX studio with 2 right wing analysts and casually drops that his wife works for the CIA.

And these guys decide to reveal themselves 2 years AFTER the investigation starts and indictments come down.

Keep on drinkin' the Kool Aid, OTB.
 
langeweile said:
Yeah..don't forget everybody that is in prison is innocent...:D

Do you always have to say something, no matter how stupid or inane?

Lange: "I dream of a better tomorrow...where chickens can cross the road and not be questioned about there motives"

TOV: "I dream of a better tomorrow ... where idiots like lange can learn the difference between there, they're, and their."
 
TOVisitor said:
Yeah OTB. Joe Wilson is just sitting around the FOX studio with 2 right wing analysts and casually drops that his wife works for the CIA.

And these guys decide to reveal themselves 2 years AFTER the investigation starts and indictments come down.

Keep on drinkin' the Kool Aid, OTB.

Apparently so, you want to be careful dismissing a General Officer that quickly with blog talking points..... I've known a couple and they're, as a rule, fairly serious guys, especially given that every small pricked pale blog copier like you will be gunning for them.....

I don't know if this is true, neither do you.

OTB
 
TOVisitor said:
Yeah OTB. Joe Wilson is just sitting around the FOX studio with 2 right wing analysts and casually drops that his wife works for the CIA.

And these guys decide to reveal themselves 2 years AFTER the investigation starts and indictments come down.

Keep on drinkin' the Kool Aid, OTB.

Didn't Fox freak out after Wilson's interview with CNN, calling him a fraud and liar without ever interviewing him.. I find it very hard to believe that someone with some political savvy like Wilson would even bother with Fox in the first place.
 
onthebottom said:
Apparently so, you want to be careful dismissing a General Officer that quickly with blog talking points..... I've known a couple and they're, as a rule, fairly serious guys, especially given that every small pricked pale blog copier like you will be gunning for them.....

I don't know if this is true, neither do you.

OTB
Telling a general that someone is in the CIA is not exactly the same as telling a reporter (assuming it is not a foreign general). Moreover, it is just a diversionary issue that changes nothing.
 
someone said:
Telling a general that someone is in the CIA is not exactly the same as telling a reporter (assuming it is not a foreign general). Moreover, it is just a diversionary issue that changes nothing.

Really, he was a private citizen at the time, getting ready to go on a news program........ did you read the article?

The question it raises is, if everyone in Washington knew, how could it be news to a reporter....

OTB
 
onthebottom said:
Really, he was a private citizen at the time, getting ready to go on a news program........ did you read the article?
Not closely. Still, even a retired general is a different kittle of fish. I'm sure they are still subject to whatever the American version of the Official Secrets Act is.

onthebottom said:
The question it raises is, if everyone in Washington knew, how could it be news to a reporter....

OTB
I’m sure it will come out in the trail if everyone knew. I’m prepared to wait.
 
TOVisitor said:
Do you always have to say something, no matter how stupid or inane?

Lange: "I dream of a better tomorrow...where chickens can cross the road and not be questioned about there motives"

TOV: "I dream of a better tomorrow ... where idiots like lange can learn the difference between there, they're, and their."


I dearm of tov crossing the road while I am driving driectly trward it and all of a sudden I look away from the road to change the CD:D
 
papasmerf said:
I dearm of tov crossing the road while I am driving driectly trward it and all of a sudden I look away from the road to change the CD:D

Not worth the dent....

OTB
 
Jane Hamsher nails these two idiots (and YOU, OTB, BTW).

From: http://firedoglake.blogspot.com/2005/11/let-your-freak-flag-fly.html

Without Queen Rove to spoon feed them their talking points, the wingnut borg have ceded control of the tom-toms to the tin foil hat brigade. Dig it: Joe Wilson was a French spy. No, really:

"Enter our hero, Joseph C. Wilson, from stage left. The French forgery about Niger led straight to Wilson's bogus trip to Africa. Wilson supposedly went there to find out the truth for the CIA. But every government involved already knew the truth about the bogus document, because it showed incorrect names of Niger officials. A single telephone call to Niger would have established that fact."

How exactly this is helpful to any cogent argument is open for speculation. I guess when you can produce reptilian brain rage just by stringing the words 'French", "Joe Wilson" and "CIA" together in a paragraph, any attempt at erudite logic would be overkill.

And now Sean Hannity is dragging out some old GOP war horse named General Paul Vallely, noteworthy only for a conspicuous silence on the matter up until now, to claim that Joe Wilson was jabbering to him about how his wife worked for the CIA in the spring of 2002 while they were both in the green room at Fox News. Never mind that Joe Wilson never appeared on Fox News until July 2002. Vallely has now changed his story to accommodate this discrepancy. Apparently this is supposed to make him more plausible, since if his intent was to lie he would've checked his dates first.

They may have to run the one about how an inconsistent story makes it more plausible past me a few times before it starts to make sense. The only salient commentary I found on the whole situation came from the comments at Tom Maguire's: "One thing's for damn sure: this Plame/Wilson leak thingy is way too complicated for Sean Hannity to understand."
 
Oh, and just so we know who these two nutcase ex-Generals are, here is a small exerpt from a Publisher's Weekley revbiew of their book:

"As the authors would have it, North Korea must dismantle its nuclear program or face U.S. invasion. Syria, unless it stops supporting terrorism and coughs up the Iraqi WMDs the authors say it’s hiding, should also be invaded. Saudi Arabia should be nudged toward a diversified economy and political reform, but if Islamic radicals take over, it too must be invaded. Iran, too big to invade, should be slapped with an embargo and naval blockade,[that view is no longer operative. Iran should now be tactically nuked -- ed] while Pakistan should be enticed with aid packages into curbing its nuclear proliferation and cracking down on the Taliban and al-Qaeda. The authors’ ambitious schedule of ultimatums and conquests leads them to focus almost exclusively on the U.S. military, for which they recommend the Rumsfeld doctrine of light, mobile forces, supplemented by additional weapons spending."

Oh yeah, baby. roger - the draft dodger - staubach would really get a woody for these guys.