AmI in the wrong?

OddSox

Active member
May 3, 2006
3,143
2
36
Ottawa
So, I've been going out with this girl for about 6 months. I've been separated from my ex for about 5 years (married 27 years) - we still talk, but rarely. My daughter lives out of town so I only see her a few times a year. She's 28.

My girlfriend wanted me to spend Christmas Eve with her. No problem - I arranged to see my daughter on Xmas Day. But she's staying with my ex and they're going to see friends for dinner, so the plan was that I would go along. (I've known them for 30 years as well).

My girlfriend is upset, for a number of reasons which I didn't see coming at all. Basically, she's jealous and thinks I have not put my marriage behind me etc.

Maybe I should change my plans? I can probably take my daughter for brunch or something and leave it at that...
 
I wouldn't say "wrong" per se, but it sounds like this first Christmas is pretty important to your new girlfriend and really wants you to spend Christmas Eve with her. If you can, I'd say honor the original commitment to her.

On the other hand, it's not really fair of her to say what she said about your not being over your marriage. If she's been in the picture six months and she's jealous of a 27 year relationship that ended 5 years ago, and of your adult daughter, then maybe this is just the tip of the crazy iceberg.

Can't offer more solid advice than that. Do what you thing is the right thing to do, and maybe suggest there's enough OddSox for everyone!

How old's the girlfriend?
 
I am honouring the Christmas Eve - it's Christmas Day that seems to be the problem. The girlfriend says the issue isn't seeing my daughter, but hanging out with my ex. She sort of has a point...
 
Oh, I thought dinner was the Christmas Eve and your girlfriend thought you were bailing on her.

Tell your ex you'll be bringing your girlfriend to the dinner, and see how fast you get awkwardly uninvited!
 
... then maybe this is just the tip of the crazy iceberg.


How old's the girlfriend?

I am sure the new gf is young and hot to death to be acting up like that over a man's past... I feel for you, but to maintain the frequency of date night with sexy outfits and strawberries, you need to keep away from that old comfortable option for Christmas Day. New girl wants you to do new things... BTW fuck the amicable divorce shit... She need to see conflict to feel secure about where your head is at.

I might be off but that is certainly how it seems from what you explained.
 
Its been my experience that women can be VERY territorial about such things. :confused: :hand:

This behaviour from the new GF is a HUGE red flag. :Eek:

I recently dumped a GF for a similar situation, but it was Thanksgiving... 2 months later she's STILL texting me numerous times a day! :frusty:
 
The new girl has to be made to realize that you had a life before her. Your daughter was in your life before the new girl, so she has seniority and priority.

Do you really want to be in a relationship where this is going to be a regular problem?
 
I don't get it. Christmas eve with gf, Christmas with daughter sounds fine with me. Ensure your gf that you're going just to see your baby girl and nothing else.
 
If it were me, I'd RUN!!! This is insecure, immature and petty behavior on your girlfriends part and is a clear indicator that there will be more trouble in the future surrounding your family. A six month old relationship doesn't carry the weight to walk away from spending Christmas with your daughter and ex. My ex is a great guy but his gf is very insecure and it's now to the point that my children choose to spend their Christmas with their SO's and we celebrate as a family without their dad early so he doesn't even get a Christmas with them which is really sad. Your ex-wife will always be a factor in your life as she is the mother of your child and if that relationship is amicable then protect it. Your girlfriend needs to grow up and realize she's your ex for a reason and it doesn't mean you are not still a part of a family unit. Be full of care here, this is not a good sign...

cat
 
I agree with Cat....run. You will always be co-parents with your ex, and there will be many more events that put you together. If the GF is reacting like this after only six months together, I can only imagine how she will be reacting in a few years.

Perhaps the GF is extra-insecure because you have been separated for five years without divorcing?
 
This one incident may be a flag, depending on the voracity of her objections, but I don't think its enough on its own to mark her as an overly-jealous woman. You would have to compare this to the rest of her behaviours. The way you lay it out, she is fine with you spending Christmas with your daughter, so she seems normal in that sense. But as you point out, spending Christmas with your ex-wife is a bit troublesome. You are basically cocooning with your old nuclear family on Christmas Day - I can understand why she would be a bit surprised by that.

Ways out? Well, your daughter is 28 - an adult. She's beyond needing daddy at her side - why don't you and your gf spend Christmas alone on a little jaunt somewhere. Its not too late to book Vegas or hop a quick flight to Tampa even. Really, you want to spend Christmas dinner with your ex-wife, your adult daughter and some people you dont' even know, as compared to taking off somewhere with your new girlfriend? Enjoy your freedom instead.

Plan B - invite the new gf along. Your daughter, at 28, needs to be mature enough to handle that daddy has a new squeeze. And who gives a fuck if your ex wife doesn't like that idea?
 
Some guys obviously didn't read your post correctly - the issue is not Christmas Eve with the gf or Christmas Day with the daughter...the issue s extending this to the evening meal where you are back in the 'old' family situation - and enjoying dinner with friends (CapitalGuy, he does know the other people)....that is what the GF doesn't like....I would go with her on this one, just see your daughter during Xmas Day and leave it at that
 
Some guys obviously didn't read your post correctly - the issue is not Christmas Eve with the gf or Christmas Day with the daughter...the issue s extending this to the evening meal where you are back in the 'old' family situation - and enjoying dinner with friends (CapitalGuy, he does know the other people)....that is what the GF doesn't like....I would go with her on this one, just see your daughter during Xmas Day and leave it at that

Oh yeah, he's known them for 30 years. D'oh. My bad.

That make it worse, I think. Like you say, he's going back to the olden days when everyone was one big happy, which makes it worse and gives more credibility to the new girl's grievance. It can seem as if he's longing for his old life. I'm sure that's not the case, but from an outsider's point of view, it can look like it, so I get the new girl's objection even more, looking at it like that.
 
And if he spends Christmas day with old family and friends, does she have someone with whom to spend Christmas day?

Perry
 
I am honouring the Christmas Eve - it's Christmas Day that seems to be the problem. The girlfriend says the issue isn't seeing my daughter, but hanging out with my ex. She sort of has a point...

No she doesn't.

Sorry but the relationship is 6 months old. She doesn't have claim yet. Tell her to wait a couple more years before she can put your balls her purse.

You had no xmas day plans with the GF. Nothing has changed. Put your foot down now. Trust me. Tell the GF, this is the way it it. Live with it or leave.

Explain briefly and to the point, you are not hung up on your past marriage but you are not going to make the same mistakes this time around either and bow to the whim of the vag because she is having a little hissy fit. The walk away. She will call back, and will be better behaved in the future. If not, she will leave and you should count your blessing.

This is all coming from a woman too. So no worries mate. Keep your balls. It is too soon to hand them over.

 
Well, as of this morning she has 'unfriended' me on Facebook and won't answer text messages. So I'm thinking that's that - hey, I'll be able to get the money back on her Xmas gift!

Thanks for all the responses. Every now and again I think a real GFE will work, but then realize I'm probably better off with the SP kind of GFE!