a 1 player said:
I agree with his tactics. Why would anyone worry if they were on the up and up?
Using this logic why worry about having any sort of constitutional rights or abuse of power agencies? After all the authorities NEVER do anything for the wrong reason or from a personal bias?
It's easy to look at these people as dogs and no doubt all sorts have done bad things and maybe this is a scared straight scenario in some cases. At the same time you are talking about the country in the world with the highest incarceration rate which would seem to suggest at least on some level that something is wrong there. Certainly all this applause of this tactic reducing crimes does not seem to bear out. It is a complex issue in this respect.
What however is a bit more disturbing is that along with that high incarceration rate the US also has falsely incarceration levels that rival Russia and China. It is part of their system where a prosecutor knows that if his guilty rate falls below certain targets then his re-election is gone. 60 Minutes ran a segment on a Tennessee county that has the highest guilty prosecution rate in the country and it was eye opening. The prosecutor in charge fully admitted that all sorts of innocent people are found guilty in his system, (high pressure tactics to make deals and lots of 'questionable ethics' such as "if you plead innocent then we may have to delve in your whole family to check out if they have done anything that needs them to be arrested for"), and of course their target crowd is the uneducated, lower class and naturally the black population. The phrase "if they didn't do this then they probably did something else" came up once.
We have this seemingly insane idea that O.J. or Boston Legal is what it is like for most people accused a crime. The system is not set up to provide justice but to put poor people away. The judge usually is the extra man on the prosecution's side, (after all he has to get elected as well so he doesn't want to be seen as helping criminals), the defendant is almost always caught in a life financially destroying situation, if they are poor they get a crappy overworked PD, if they are middle class they do not qualify for a PD and may have to chose to mortgage/sell their house to pay for representation. Nice choice... "go to jail or prove my innocence but impoverish my family as we become homeless."
If you are rich odds this all just goes away before trial. If it doesn't? Well I wonder how many 'rich kids' are under this Sheriff's thumb?
So be careful tossing out the old "they have it coming adage" lest it comes back to bite you.