America's Failed Model for the World

canada-man

Well-known member
Jun 16, 2007
33,837
3,774
113
Toronto, Ontario
canadianmale.wordpress.com
America's Failed Model for the World


Europeans keep asking me, has America lost its mind? From healthcare to its economy, the US is looking merely average

By Steven Hill

September 18, 2009 "The Guardian" --- Europeans are shaking their heads over their American friends again. Whether talking to people in the street, in the cafés or to journalists or political leaders, everyone here asks me the same question: Has America lost its mind? Town halls filled with angry citizens, shouting at their elected leaders, some of them armed with guns and threatening signs? Besides the media spectacle of these neo-1776 revolutionaries, what is doubly perplexing to Europeans is the focus of the protests: healthcare.

What's strange to a European is that everyone here already has healthcare. The place that Donald Rumsdfeld once sneeringly called "old Europe" long ago solved this dilemma, producing quality healthcare for a fraction of the price that Americans pay. Many Europeans are astonished when they find out that 47 million Americans – larger than the populations of most European nations – don't have any healthcare at all except a hospital emergency room.

Contrary to stereotype, most of Europe doesn't use single payer, with France, Germany and others having evolved a "third way" that combines individual choice with private, nonprofit insurance companies and Medicare-like cost controls. Even countries like Croatia, Hungary and Slovenia, with per capita incomes only a fraction of that in the
United States, have healthcare for all their people. Europeans simply don't understand how a wealthy United States could remain the last advanced nation that does not have universal healthcare.

Lounging one evening in one of Budapest's elegant thermal baths larger than an Olympic swimming pool, with Europeans of all ages and nationalities soaking their limbs in relaxed leisure, I was treated to a dose of the common wisdom that is taking hold here. Introducing myself as an American evinced a swift reaction from one sweating sauna companion:

"I don't understand you Americans. You blow billions on a useless war in Afghanistan and Iraq, and billions more to bail out banks that nearly bankrupted the world economy, but you don't ensure healthcare for your own people. Even Obama can't make a difference. It's as if your democracy doesn't work anymore."

He was Austrian but spoke in a near-perfect English that was as good grammatically as that spoken by some of my relatives.

And his reaction was typical. As Europeans watch the United States flailing about over something as basic as healthcare, they are reminded once again of the impotent US response following Hurricane Katrina. TV images of stranded, poor, black people in New Orleans have been melded to those of this new healthcare insurgency with pitch forks, leaving an indelible impression. The last remaining superpower is not looking so super anymore, whether in Iraq, Afghanistan, healthcare, the economy – not anywhere.

The global economic collapse, largely blamed on out-of-control Wall Street capitalism, is stinging here as well, though in most regions Europe has not suffered as much as America has. In my informal polling of small business and shop owners, they said the downtown had hurt, but only a little bit. Since the crisis, Europe has employed clever strategies – some of them since copied by the Obama administration, such as the popular "
cash for clunkers" auto rebate programme – that have prevented it from suffering the doubling of unemployment that the US is enduring.

Indeed, Europe, once looked down upon by American pundits as the land of double-digit unemployment, currently has lower unemployment than the United States. Contrary to Europe's reputation as having a sick, sclerotic economy, its per capita economic growth rate actually was slightly higher than America's in the 10 years leading up to the economic crisis.

Still, a number of people fear that the worst is yet to come. And so Europeans appear both angry and perplexed by America's deregulated capitalism run amok, which has further served to undermine the American brand. As one Slovenian acquaintance, a representative of a consortium of small businesses said to me: "The US used to lecture us in Europe about just about everything, but what does America have to teach now? Maybe America should learn something from Europe."

Indeed, with Germany and France becoming the first major western economies to emerge from recession into positive growth, perhaps the US should learn something from our transatlantic cousins. But what might we learn?

Here's a clue, say some Europeans. German chancellor Angela Merkel once was asked by then-British prime minister Tony Blair what the secret was of her country's economic success, which includes being the world's largest exporter nation and running substantial trade surpluses. She famously replied: "Mr Blair, we still make things."

Werner Abelshauser, an economic historian at the University of Bielefeld in Germany, says the European way of running the economy "is fundamentally about firms that emphasise high-quality products and long-term relationships between suppliers and customers". Company managers set long-term policies, while market pressures for short-term profits are held in check. Gunter Verheugen, vice-president of the European Commission, echoed the virtues of Europe's strong, competitive industrial base, succinctly stating Europe's recipe for success: "Don't try to be cheaper. Try to be better."

But in the United States, for decades under the sway of the Reagan revolution's economic philosophy, which favoured corporate finance over manufacturing, the economy has seen a
stark decline in manufacturing. Since the second world war, the financial sector in the United States has tripled in size as a percentage of the overall economy and of corporate profits. That increase accelerated during the eight years of the Bush administration, even as the US lost 5.5 million manufacturing jobs.

European capitalism for the most part didn't succumb to the financialisation that swept the United States in the 1980s, and which paved the way for the speculative bubbles that have now caused economic collapses in both 2001 and in 2008 (with notable exceptions in Britain, Spain and Ireland, similarly plagued by a collapsed housing bubble).

So from the other side of the pond, the
city on the hill is looking pretty average these days. America is still a leader, but not the leader. That's a post-post-cold war concept that the world is still getting used to, and that Americans don't want to admit. But the evidence is everywhere, and especially obvious when you step outside the American bubble.

As one Viennese politician told me: "If the American model no longer is the blueprint for the world, what comes next?" Some Europeans think they have the answer, and much of the world is paying attention, even if most Americans still are not.

http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article23537.htm
 
Germany has the world's oldest universal health care system, with origins dating back to Otto von Bismarck's Health Insurance Act of 1883.[61] As mandatory health insurance, it originally applied only to low-income workers and certain government employees, but has gradually expanded to cover virtually the entire population.[62] The system is decentralized with private practice physicians providing ambulatory care, and independent, mostly non-profit hospitals providing the majority of inpatient care. Approximately 92% of the population is covered by a 'Statutory Health Insurance' plan, which provides a standardized level of coverage through any one of approximately 1100 public or private sickness funds. Standard insurance is funded by a combination of employee contributions, employer contributions and government subsidies on a scale determined by income level. Higher income workers sometimes choose to pay a tax and opt out of the standard plan, in favor of 'private' insurance. The latter's premiums are not linked to income level but instead to health status. [63]
 
An article in The Guardian, no great suprise that they found people who both fail to understand and hate the U.S.A.
 
aardvark an american who doesn't get it
 
An article in The Guardian, no great suprise that they found people who both fail to understand and hate the U.S.A.

Please tell us what

a. they do not understand
and
b. Why you deduce that they hare the US.

I see no indication of either claim in the article.


I have a friend in California, who is in his mid 70's. He had a long career with
IBM and a couple of other high tech companies.

He and his wife has Medicaid/Medicare, and supplemental health care
insurance through blue cross or someone like that.

They are now being economically crippled by medical cost, to doctors and
medications. medicaid/medicare and the insurance pays only a part of their
expenses for health care. They have to skip some medications because of cost.
 
Please tell us what

a. they do not understand
and
b. Why you deduce that they hare the US.

I see no indication of either claim in the article.
I love field sports - but I believe you mean hate not Hare ;)

Read the subtext of the article Good Lord it smacks you in the face!

"I don't understand you Americans. You blow billions on a useless war in Afghanistan and Iraq, and billions more to bail out banks that nearly bankrupted the world economy,". . . . the impotent US response following Hurricane Katrina. TV images of stranded, poor, black people in New Orleans (Not the political corruption of the Louisiana Levy Boards). . . . [the U.S.A. is] not looking so super anymore, whether in Iraq, Afghanistan, healthcare, the economy – not anywhere. . . . out-of-control Wall Street capitalism
Need I quote more?
 
Read the subtext of the article Good Lord it smacks you in the face!

Need I quote more?

Yes , I think you do. I see no evidence of hate (or hares) there, and I do not see much misunderstanding of
the US either.
 
I don't buy the argument America is structurally flawed. The article is just taking disparate bad things that happen and pointing out how it creates an image in peoples minds, but that image isn't an accurate portrayal of structure.

The financial crisis was hardly a purely American construction, but even if you want to argue it was it wasn't caused by structural failure, but by politicians tweaking things without long term vision (deregulation by the right and pushing lending qualifications lower by the left)

Katrina was caused by corrupt local government (why the levies failed) and an inept President.

Health care is an ideological difference between America and Europe because America is a far more right wing nation, again thats not structural. I completely disagree with the right wing view of what health care should be, but that doesn't make the entire US system a failure, just one I wouldn't choose.
 
Canada is the best model. Not perfect, simply the best.

The U.K., France and Germany have GST rates in the high teens. Do you want to pay a GST rate of 19% when you buy a TV?

France suffered a heat wave a few years ago and 5,000 senior citizens died. How can a first world country allow 5,000 of its senior citizens to die during a heat wave? France also has 5 million residents whose culture is completely alien to French Christian values. How will they deal with the brewing riots?
 
American laws and institutions have been set up to support an elite. Their propaganda in newspapers and entertainment are to lull the sheep that are being sheared that they have a "government of the people, by the people and for the people".

BS.

Only the poor suffer, without hope. It is their children who go to war for some Senator or Congressmen and his supporters make a pile of cash.

If there truely was equality in the Excited States of America, there would be no War on Terrorism as Rich Kids would also have to do the fighting and dying.

If your part of the top 1% in the US, you don't care about Health Care cause that's for the masses. America is a divided nation, were 1% of the population control the nation, and their not going to let that change any time soon. The middle class is being attacked and driven under by the financial policy's put in place to keep the rich in power.

That is why the American Media is attacking Canada and Europe for our Health Care, they don't want the average American to see that they are well and truely fucked by the establishment.

There is going to be a Second American Revolution and it's gonna be ugly.
 
i.e. we disagree, and I don't believe we ever will agree on this point.

We can disagree on health care, WMD in Iraq, Iraq war, bailouts to the banks,
etc. etc.

But for you to claim that such disagreements shows "hate of the US" is
demagoguery in the worst tradition. I would have thought one needed to go back to
the soviet union to find that kind of statement. Putin would love your attitude.
 
Does that mean 2 million expatriate Canadians, including Jason Bay, will come back to Canada? Or, will they go to Mexico?

You can't continue to have the kind of deep disgregard for the majority of the population without it comeing to a head. King Louis underestimated the mood the French people and look what happened to him.
 
You can't continue to have the kind of deep disgregard for the majority of the population without it comeing to a head. King Louis underestimated the mood the French people and look what happened to him.
Exactly!
A lot of clueless smug 'Haves' sitting in their 'Gated Bunkers' may be in for a rude awakening if they don't smarten up fast!....;)



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
 
Exactly!
A lot of clueless smug 'Haves' sitting in their 'Gated Bunkers' may be in for a rude awakening if they don't smarten up fast!....;)



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them


You are spouting the have and have not theory of economics.

Worked in Russia and Germany why not here?
 
You are spouting the have and have not theory of economics.
Worked in Russia and Germany why not here?

The "have nots" in the U.S. are much better off than the "have nots" or even the "haves" in many countries. Why would 2 billion men give their left testicle to come to the U.S.?

The French and Russian revolutions were started and carried on by people who had literally nothing to lose. The American "have nots" still have their pick-up trucks, HD TV's and unlimited beer. Plus, they have more of their human rights protected than people in most other countries.
 
The French and Russian revolutions were started and carried on by people who had literally nothing to lose.
Professor Crane Brinton in his The Anatomy of Revolution argues that it is "people with nothing to lose" in the sense of the educated children of the middle classes with thwarted expectations that are the crucial factor. Not the sans-culottes, who follow along behind this group.
The American "have nots" still have their pick-up trucks, HD TV's and unlimited beer. Plus, they have more of their human rights protected than people in most other countries.
I entirely agree.