American Wealth Distribution

The free market is far from perfect. I know the Europeans are trying to cap the salaries of bank executives. In Japan, I think the desparity is much smaller.

In the U.S., the brokerage firms use to be partnerships and the partners were playing with their own money. Now they are public companies and they gamble with public shareholder money and, except for Lehman Bros., they expect the government to bail them out if they screw up.
 
As the average tenure of a CEO in a Fortune 500 company has decreased, so their average compensation package has increased, to the detriment of shareholders and stakeholders alike. To claim that CEOs are true "leaders" who are worth exorbitant compensation packages is to dismiss the business leaders of the 50s, 60s, 70s and 80s, who (generally) made much less than CEO have since the mid-90s, when CEO compensation first became largely unmoored from performance metrics.

Increasingly, CEO compensation packages (including very, very generous golden parachute clauses) are unrelated to medium or long-term performance measures. Those that have any connection to performance are typically tied to short term share price fluctuations, which can be manipulated by short term cost-cutting at the expense of long term growth, or to increasing use of tax loopholes and parking revenue overseas.

Shareholder activism can only go so far to restrain abuses by entrenched management, whose positions are typically protected by legal devices (such as poison pills) by reciprocal presence on each other's Boards of Directors and by an army of lobbyists in Washington.

Rather than attempt to impose regulations limiting or structuring upper management compensation, I'd like to see experiments with laws requiring all revenues to be repatriated and subject to US corporate taxes. The addition revenue could be used to assist in balancing the governments books, for humanitarian necessities like health care and social assistance and for government infrastructure programs. All of which would improve the domestic market for US goods and services.
 
I have no idea what the 'right' comp ratio is. A crazy high ratio can be the result of stupid high CEO pay, or stupid low employee pay. Would I have a problem if a CEO found a way to maximize profit by using low cost labour (that did not compromise product/service quality)? Nope.

I have a fundamental problem with comparing CEO to average employee pay. It assumes comparability. I don't understand how it is. If someone can explain it to me, I'm willing to listen.

I like the idea of high executive pay. It's entirely consistent with the idea of capitalism. I want my people to believe that they all have a shot at the top job. It's all about reaching for the brass ring.
 
While I wouldn't call it a 'fix', the French and Russian revolutions certainly redistributed wealth...

My understanding is that after the French Revolution for decades the standard of living of the people "saved" went down and starvation became an even greater problem.

Was the Russian one not one of the most violent blood baths both during it, and for decades after?

I am not being sarcastic, the French stories are sort of family history, but Russian ones are just a vague memory from school days :). So I may be way off.
 
Translation:

"I was soaking my hairy balls & 60 year old nutsack in a dirty bathtub last night thinking up ridiculously fictitious stories that I could pollute the TERB forum with and I this is what I decided on."

Well not exactly. A rafting party is where people with boats you can sleep on meet at specific co-ordinates and tie all the boats that show up form a floating island. Most often based on my limited exposure, you tend to get several smaller parties all at the same time. Sort of like "Drinkers go to the drinker boat", people who like to talk go to the chatter boat, sex fiends and pervs..... well you get the idea.

A great opportunity to hear other peoples opinions :).
 
I have no idea what the 'right' comp ratio is. A crazy high ratio can be the result of stupid high CEO pay, or stupid low employee pay. Would I have a problem if a CEO found a way to maximize profit by using low cost labour (that did not compromise product/service quality)? Nope. .

I am not well versed in the "comp ratio" side. I do know that it is driven by wanting more money :). I also know that when you let the old boys decide how much they get paid they will get paid a lot. :)

I was talking about HQ locations with a C suite guy whose company had abandoned Montreal for political reasons. He sort of indicated that moving was always an option.
 
Translation:

"I was soaking my hairy balls & 60 year old nutsack in a dirty bathtub last night thinking up ridiculously fictitious stories that I could pollute the TERB forum with and I this is what I decided on."


So was I.
 
Al Gore makes a billion dollars because he has a bully pulpit on green energy and access to the government honey pot. Fair?
No Wall Street executive goes to jail after selling toxic securities and helping to blow up the economy. Fair? Hell the vast majority of them didn't even go bankrupt and ended up with no personal financial pain because of the bailouts.
Jon Corzine steals a billion dollars of customer funds to cover up his shitty trades at MF Global and doesn't go to jail. Fair?
No politician who offered extravagant pensions and other benefits - which cant possibly be paid goes to jail. Fair?

The whole system is corrupt! We need to all wake up soon. OCCUPY WallStreet had some good points, but it was woefully poorly executed and messaged. I'd like to see some Occupy 2.0 emerge that is actually smart and sustainable as a force for change.

Many CEOs and leadership teams are wildly overcompensated. Their compensation isn't tied in to the creation of value. They stack their Boards with friendlies and assign themselves juicy compensation. The ultimate you scratch my back, I'll scratch your's scenario. They also cultivate relationships with politicians and other government officials who can offer contracts, grants, favourable legislation,etc... and in return the govt officials or politicians are offered cushy jobs on Wall Street or other lucrative industries to perpetuate the virtuous - to them- cycle. Bushs oil guys? Robert Rubin? Peter Orzag? getting paid millions by Citibank who hasn't exactly done well by their shareholders lately. Well at least they got bailed out by Paulson and Geithner, and Geithner may be the WORST of all as he was in charge of the NY fed at the time of the blow up. Watch where Geithner goes now, he's not going to get super rich at the Council on Foreign Relations , his initial landing spot. Both parties are corrupt.

There is a difference btwn professional managers -who own a very very small fraction of the enterprise, usually through stock options , not through shares that they actually buy and take risk on and FOUNDERS, entrepreneurs and critical early employees who build wealth mainly through the building of a valuable company and the long term alignment of their interests with the increased value of the company.

I am a free market capitalist, but we are a long LONG way from that system these days.

http://www.businessinsider.com/henry-ford-salary-increase-2012-8
 
No, its not a stupid question....

Besides, your comparing a menial position with a highly skilled position which is not what the question is.

The average employee at Apple for example is part of a team that develops software and new products. The executive didn't write the operating system for mac's.... the skilled employee's did. Yet, working at Apple as an engineer or designer in Cupertino CA is relatively low paying. Engineer's are a dime a dozen it could be argued. So are executives truthfully.

That last bit is where your argument falls down, very good executives are like starting pitchers, they are rare and worth tons....

OTB
 
That last bit is where your argument falls down, very good executives are like starting pitchers, they are rare and worth tons....

OTB

Agreed..... they are rare. So you understand my frustration that just about every CEO gets paid like he is the rare one. Not too many perform like Jack Welch did. He was actually visionary and rare. Wasn't too long ago that Wall Street almost melted down the global markets buy insuring mortgages that they didn't have the capitol to back. Yet, they all got bonuses.
 
A good CEO can turn a company around, a bad one can ruin a company - how much is that worth to shareholders?
I distinguish between "founder CEO" and "Hired Gun CEO". A founder CEO like Bill Gates, Michael Dell, Steve Jobs, etc. who founded and grew their companies are worth every nickel they made.
 
At the end of the day, the market determines what a CEO, or engineer, or janitor is worth.

I disagree. And thats my point. The rules are made by the person who controls the cheque book. Business leaders and politicians have long been in bed together. The rules are rigged by those people, for those people.

http://www.hotcoffeethemovie.com/

This documentary explains how companies in the 80's were afraid of being sued for negligence..... so Carl Rove, and Republican party had a plan. Put a Cap on what you could collect in a law suit!

Over the next few years they ran corporate friendly judges in elections. Appointed Corporate friendly Supreme Court Judges in R controlled States. They changed the rules so that if your kid was paralyzed in the playpen at McDonalds, you could only legally collect up to $400 000. I'm guess the lifelong Medical costs of a paralyzed kid in the states would run well over that sum.... hope its not your kid.

No.... the rules are rigged. They have been examined up and down by business men, CEO's, and Politicians. The risks have been evaluated, and the right people have been put in place to handle that.

I'm not saying good CEO's don't deserve good compensation. They do. I want the company I work for to have a great CEO. However, when the top 1% has 40% of everything, then things are out of whack.
 
OCCUPY WallStreet had some good points, but it was woefully poorly executed and messaged. I'd like to see some Occupy 2.0 emerge that is actually smart and sustainable as a force for change.
[/url]

Perhaps the occupy movemnt lacked the leadership, organizational skills and vision a top notch CEO could add?
 
Al Gore makes a billion dollars because he has a bully pulpit on green energy and access to the government honey pot. Fair?
No Wall Street executive goes to jail after selling toxic securities and helping to blow up the economy. Fair? Hell the vast majority of them didn't even go bankrupt and ended up with no personal financial pain because of the bailouts.
Jon Corzine steals a billion dollars of customer funds to cover up his shitty trades at MF Global and doesn't go to jail. Fair?
No politician who offered extravagant pensions and other benefits - which cant possibly be paid goes to jail. Fair?

The whole system is corrupt! We need to all wake up soon. OCCUPY WallStreet had some good points, but it was woefully poorly executed and messaged. I'd like to see some Occupy 2.0 emerge that is actually smart and sustainable as a force for change.

Many CEOs and leadership teams are wildly overcompensated. Their compensation isn't tied in to the creation of value. They stack their Boards with friendlies and assign themselves juicy compensation. The ultimate you scratch my back, I'll scratch your's scenario. They also cultivate relationships with politicians and other government officials who can offer contracts, grants, favourable legislation,etc... and in return the govt officials or politicians are offered cushy jobs on Wall Street or other lucrative industries to perpetuate the virtuous - to them- cycle. Bushs oil guys? Robert Rubin? Peter Orzag? getting paid millions by Citibank who hasn't exactly done well by their shareholders lately. Well at least they got bailed out by Paulson and Geithner, and Geithner may be the WORST of all as he was in charge of the NY fed at the time of the blow up. Watch where Geithner goes now, he's not going to get super rich at the Council on Foreign Relations , his initial landing spot. Both parties are corrupt.

There is a difference btwn professional managers -who own a very very small fraction of the enterprise, usually through stock options , not through shares that they actually buy and take risk on and FOUNDERS, entrepreneurs and critical early employees who build wealth mainly through the building of a valuable company and the long term alignment of their interests with the increased value of the company.

I am a free market capitalist, but we are a long LONG way from that system these days.

http://www.businessinsider.com/henry-ford-salary-increase-2012-8

Looks like getting rich and building wealth is no longer about the "Protestant Ethic" but rather no ethics at all.

The company I work for is multinational and publicly traded.

The management hierarchy is huge especially in the middle.

With most of the productivity taking place in the lower operations level one wonders why such a large tactical level.

The business is pretty much turn key requiring less strategic employment but does require some effort in organization on a daily level.

This is handled at the tactical level.

The main reason for the large tactical belly of the hierarchy pyramid though, is to slave drive the operations level and to have someone accountable.

Promotions to the top is on a firstly "years of experience" basis.

While some of the younger management at the lower levels may have some tertiary education, the older moneymakers at the strategic level have an average grade 10 level education.

It is no wonder there is very little strategy employed except to pass the burden downwards until it reaches operations.

An impotent Union that's in the companies pockets facilitates the use of threats as the chief method of motivating employees.
 
Rather than attempt to impose regulations limiting or structuring upper management compensation, I'd like to see experiments with laws requiring all revenues to be repatriated and subject to US corporate taxes. The addition revenue could be used to assist in balancing the governments books, for humanitarian necessities like health care and social assistance and for government infrastructure programs. All of which would improve the domestic market for US goods and services.

Your experiment will see companies move offshore to other countries which don't have such tax laws. And the moment you pass them, other countries will line up to steal your business away.
 
Your experiment will see companies move offshore to other countries which don't have such tax laws. And the moment you pass them, other countries will line up to steal your business away.

It is already happening. Canada sold off a lot of its natural resources.
 

The 1% has 40% of the wealth, how much do you have to have to be in the top 1%?

If it continues society will colaspse, without balance all systems will eventually fail. We will have the super rich, the poor and criminals!
 
If it continues society will colaspse, without balance all systems will eventually fail. We will have the super rich, the poor and criminals!

I'm not sure society will collapse, but a large share of the population will certainly live in misery.

I could be wrong, but isn't the basic ideal of capitalism "the harder you work, the more you make". If anyone honestly thinks this is the way capitalism is working, I'll laugh you out of the room. Even the examples in this thread make me laugh. Does an all-star pitcher who can throw a curveball 1mph faster than his competition deserve to be paid 1000x more than the grounds keeper? Fuck no! The grounds keeper probably works harder. The pitcher gets paid what he gets paid because he's got talent that few others have, not because he's a hard worker. He makes that because people want to make money off him, and the only way to do that is to retain him. Is it fair? No, but it's reality. Are there ways to make it more equitable? Sure, but they probably won't happen. In this world, money is power and power is control. Can you see the wealthy giving that up?