Am I dealing with disability discrimination at work?

Cattlesnake

Member
Oct 4, 2013
31
18
8
Far Niente
I received what I think are few odd requests from my manager.



First, a little context:



I work in a warehouse, and have been in the company and same position for almost 10 years. I've had a physical disability since 2017, and have been receiving treatment since late 2018. I've been submitting a WSIB-compliant Functional Abilities Form (filled out by my physiotherapist) monthly for the past two years, which outlines the accommodations that are needed in order for me to do my job. It is issued once a month because that's how often my physiotherapist conducts their assessment and testing on me.



My employer has been pretty good about providing the necessary accommodations, but a situation arose a couple of weeks ago, where another worker caused some problems for me by not doing his job, which my job relies upon. I confronted him about it, and he provided some glib remark while smirking. After I made a fuss about it, my manager (who has been with the company for 3 years) told me to keep quiet about it. My manager's boss, a VP who has been company for 1 year, told me to do the additional work........ even though it is not part of my job description, and completely contradicted the modified duty criteria. I refused, and someone else ultimately completed the task.



A few days ago, my manager instructed me to stop submitting the monthly Functional Abilities Form to him and our Human Resources department. They said that this is because the contents of the form has never changed, and that my disability hasn't healed. Human Resources never contacted me on this, and I haven't asked them yet. Aren't I legally obligated to provide my employer this documentation in order to communicate what accommodations are required? My concern i that I might be set-up, with them saying that I never provided them with the required documentation.



I have evidence and documentation proving that the above incidences occurred. Am I being too sensitive or paranoid, or is what my superiors doing illegal and discriminatory? Both my manager and his VP boss have made it clear to every staff member under their umbrella that we are not to go to HR to report any problems. In fact, they are somewhat verbally abusive whenever they pull someone aside for a private conversation. They are also playing games with a co-worker who is also disabled....to the extent that the company is already being investigated by WSIB. The company does not like to package-out employees who have been there a long time (like me); they would rather make it tough, and they already have been sued multiple times by former employees.



Should I bypass Human Resources, and contact an employment layer and the Ontario Human Rights Commission?
 
If the forms you submit are required as part of you working keep submitting the forms. Contact your workplace human resources to get their response to your current situation if the forms you submit are still required because of your disability. If they say yes, have them give that in writing with an emphasis that your work requirements are modified because of your disability. If they refuse ask why and say you will continue submitting the current forms.
I would also suggest that you talk with your doctor and physio about what was said by your bosses.

If your manager/management are abusive about going to HR then go to Ontario Human Rights Commission. And get ready for any fallout that's likely to occur.

LTO_3
 
Last edited:
Ask for everything in writing if they tell you not to submit forms ask them to put it in writing same with not going to HR, record any private conversations, the reality is if they want to get rid of you they'll find a way just make sure you got lots of backup always cover your ass don't let them intimidate you. I just finished settling with the company but I've been working for for 15 years. Sonic is right try not to let it ruin your day to day life this could become very stressful for you
 
Thank-you for the advice so far everyone. I'm well aware of the one-party consent rule when it come to recording conversations, especially when it comes to discrimination. I am ready for any fall-out, have no problem going toe-to-toe with them, and financially speaking, I don't need the job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sonic Temple
Document everything
Keep submitting the forms until you are told not to in writing.
I would approach HR about the issue & discussion. But Document that too.... say with a follow up email thanking them for the chat on this topic & reconfirming the direction they gave you verbally if it was not in writing from HR
 
Document everything
Keep submitting the forms until you are told not to in writing.
I would approach HR about the issue & discussion. But Document that too.... say with a follow up email thanking them for the chat on this topic & reconfirming the direction they gave you verbally if it was not in writing from HR
good suggestions by all. Document everythings and i would suggest keeping a journal of all the event that have happened amd when. could come in handy in the future.
 
I just settled a fairly simple severance issue and went with Samfiru Tumarkin: https://stlawyers.ca. Their inital consult is free. Send them all the relevant info including your original employment contract and all evidence especailly if it's proof of abuse. They will talk about how much severance you could be owed and more importantly the fee structure. They will likely send you this document that talks about how contingency fees work: https://lawsocietyontario.azureedge...en_contingencyfee_consumerguide-april2021.pdf NOTE: you could also pay for legal services by the hour.

Your lawyer will negotiate with your employer until you can reach a settlement. Let them do the work for you and don't tell anyone the details: not even friends, family or co-workers until you get the settlement in hand. Most companies prefer to settle instead of going to court because it's expensive in time and money. On the other hand, you might work for that one special company that will fight to the death and would go to court over such an issue. In either case, employers go back and forth with your lawyer many times to appear they are fighting with you. You will more than likely have to reject multiple offers until you are totally satisfied.

Some other things to think through carefully and discuss with your lawyer:

1. How are going to receieve the settlement: as a lump-sum or salary continuance? A salary continuance is when you keep getting paid like you were still working there. A lump sum is obviously easier for all parties as it's one payment. IMO a lump-sum is best since you get the money up front and you cut ties with your past employer right away. You can deposit the lump-sum into your RSP if you have enough contribution room. Severance is still employment so it will be taxed as such.

2. You don't have to look for a new job immediately, but keep track of your search when you start. That includes when and where you applied. The legal term is called duty to mitigate losses. On the other hand, you don't have to take the first job that you come across. You can be fairly picky in that the job pays the same, has similar responsibilities, etc.

You should be able to negotiate for just about anything else like extending your health benefits until you find another job and what happens to your pension if you have it.
 
I just settled a fairly simple severance issue and went with Samfiru Tumarkin: https://stlawyers.ca. Their inital consult is free. Send them all the relevant info including your original employment contract and all evidence especailly if it's proof of abuse. They will talk about how much severance you could be owed and more importantly the fee structure. They will likely send you this document that talks about how contingency fees work: https://lawsocietyontario.azureedge...en_contingencyfee_consumerguide-april2021.pdf NOTE: you could also pay for legal services by the hour.

Your lawyer will negotiate with your employer until you can reach a settlement. Let them do the work for you and don't tell anyone the details: not even friends, family or co-workers until you get the settlement in hand. Most companies prefer to settle instead of going to court because it's expensive in time and money. On the other hand, you might work for that one special company that will fight to the death and would go to court over such an issue. In either case, employers go back and forth with your lawyer many times to appear they are fighting with you. You will more than likely have to reject multiple offers until you are totally satisfied.

Some other things to think through carefully and discuss with your lawyer:

1. How are going to receieve the settlement: as a lump-sum or salary continuance? A salary continuance is when you keep getting paid like you were still working there. A lump sum is obviously easier for all parties as it's one payment. IMO a lump-sum is best since you get the money up front and you cut ties with your past employer right away. You can deposit the lump-sum into your RSP if you have enough contribution room. Severance is still employment so it will be taxed as such.

2. You don't have to look for a new job immediately, but keep track of your search when you start. That includes when and where you applied. The legal term is called duty to mitigate losses. On the other hand, you don't have to take the first job that you come across. You can be fairly picky in that the job pays the same, has similar responsibilities, etc.

You should be able to negotiate for just about anything else like extending your health benefits until you find another job and what happens to your pension if you have it.

Even though I am financially well off enough where I wouldn't have to work for years, I'm leaning towards a contingency arrangement. As far as this company fighting to the death is concerned, the potential PR fallout would be absolutely devastating, since it is a charitable/humanitarian organization (the irony runs thick within those walls). And based on my rudimentary understanding, the Board of Directors have a tremendous personally liability risk because of the legal entity type.
 
Even though I am financially well off enough where I wouldn't have to work for years, I'm leaning towards a contingency arrangement. As far as this company fighting to the death is concerned, the potential PR fallout would be absolutely devastating, since it is a charitable/humanitarian organization (the irony runs thick within those walls). And based on my rudimentary understanding, the Board of Directors have a tremendous personally liability risk because of the legal entity type.

There's really no reason to spend your own money to fight them. You don't spend anything up front with a contingency arrangement. The legal costs are paid out of the settlement if you win and even if you somehow lose the case. Keep in mind that there are other fees like 'disbursements' and 'costs' if you go to court. They'll tell you how those work.

I've heard through many friends that non-profits, charities, etc. are a bitch to deal with during legal disputes. Management are usually the founders of the organization and it's their baby. Naturally, they are non-profit and might not have the financial resources to pay out large severange packages. I've heard that very small companies especailly family-run are more likely to fight hard during disputes too.
 
Even though I am financially well off enough where I wouldn't have to work for years, I'm leaning towards a contingency arrangement. As far as this company fighting to the death is concerned, the potential PR fallout would be absolutely devastating, since it is a charitable/humanitarian organization (the irony runs thick within those walls). And based on my rudimentary understanding, the Board of Directors have a tremendous personally liability risk because of the legal entity type.
A lot of “charitable” places are the worst for discrimination. It is odd. Same with the mental health profession.
 
A lot of “charitable” places are the worst for discrimination. It is odd. Same with the mental health profession.

Some of those charities have no issues building beautiful offices and compensating their leadership very well. I used to work near the beautiful headquarters of World Vision in Mississauga on World Drive (yep, they got the road named after them.) Some nice high end cars in the parking lot too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jenesis
Where is the Health and Safety leader of the organization on this? Ultimately, the lead should come from the H&S director.

Sounds line those you are dealing with are pretty dim whitted and making a severance package an easy option for you.
 
There's really no reason to spend your own money to fight them. You don't spend anything up front with a contingency arrangement. The legal costs are paid out of the settlement if you win and even if you somehow lose the case. Keep in mind that there are other fees like 'disbursements' and 'costs' if you go to court. They'll tell you how those work.

I've heard through many friends that non-profits, charities, etc. are a bitch to deal with during legal disputes. Management are usually the founders of the organization and it's their baby. Naturally, they are non-profit and might not have the financial resources to pay out large severange packages. I've heard that very small companies especailly family-run are more likely to fight hard during disputes too.

Thank-you for your continuing advice on this.

The company I work for is one of the biggest charities in Canada, it's valuation amounts to mid-eight digit figures, the founders are long-dead, and based on some of the information passed on to me from former employees who have sued, it wasn't too difficult to settle..... but it did take a little time and work. Fortunately for me, the company doesn't know the extent of my personal resources, and what kind of time-horizon that I have available to go down this road.
 
  • Like
Reactions: explorerzip